3 ms·
Yes, as you say, the main problem with this is that 3-helium has a much lower availability than even tritium, which has to be produced from deuterium, consuming
by adrian_b 5y ago
Yes, as you say, the main problem with this is that 3-helium has a much lower availability than even tritium, which has to be produced from deuterium, consuming a part of the energy output of a deuterium-tritium fusion reactor.
It seems that there is some 3-helium stored in the core of the Earth, but only a small part of it trickles continuously to the surface. When it reaches the atmosphere without being captured, it is lost quickly to the outer space.
Because of that, 3-helium is very expensive, but more importantly, the quantity that could be extracted each year is limited.
Even if the entire flow of 3-helium from the core could be captured, the energy that could be produced would be much less than what can be produced from uranium, not even counting the much larger reserves of thorium.
There have been some speculations that there might be larger reserves of 3-helium on the Moon, so that the only possible use of deuteron-helion fusion reactors in a not too distant future might be in some Moon stations.
- pfdietz 5y ago3He is very sparse in the lunar regolith, maybe 10 ppb. So that's not a long term source, and extracting it would be very difficult. I have hoped there's a "Planet X" in the outer solar system that's sufficiently small to easily land on and return to space, but large enough that it could retain some primordial helium in its atmosphere. If so, it might be the best place in the solar system to obtain the isotope, assuming a D3He fusion rocket could get out there and back quickly enough.
- adrian_b 5y agoWe know very little yet about the precise chemical composition of the many large bodies from the Kuiper belt. So, at least until we will know more, there is still a chance for your hope to be fulfilled. It is plausible to expect a larger 3-helium content there, but it cannot be estimated yet whether it would be so abundant that it would be worthwhile to extract and bring back.
- ncmncm 5y agoIt might be useful in situ. I.e., maybe you don't need to bring it back. In the distant future, most civilization will be in and beyond the Kuiper belt, because while energy is as cheap as a supply of 2H and 3He (and eventually H and 11B), cold is hard to get in substantial quantity except far enough from a star. We will need a lot of cold.
- PaulHoule 5y agoIf intelligent life developed D + D fusion it could live independently of stars since a high fraction of the mass of outer solar system, cometary, and interstellar objects is water, water which is a bit more D-rich than terrestrial water. D + D fusion isn't that much harder than D + T fusion and it's imaginable that a scaled up version of a D + T reactor would work for D + D. (By "scaled up" imagine a large space colony with a closed ecosystem which uses D + D energy to replace sunlight.) D + D fusion produces copious amounts of T and He3. These isotopes would burn up quickly in such a reactor but certainly some could be extracted. The He3 can be captured and used directly for fuel. The T decays with a 12 year half life. It could either be fed into D + T reactors or allowed to decay to produce more He 3. The best use for D + He3 imagined yet is something like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Daedalus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Daedalus which might be realizable with heavy ion ignition but the ignition system would be physically large which would scale the whole spacecraft up to "manned interstellar colonizer" as opposed to "very long range Voyager." Now a D + D culture would already be "interstellar" in that it could support large populations in the spaces between the stars. A civilization like that would be able to cross from one star to another in 10,000 years or so but they might not care at all because they can live their lifestyle just fine without stars. Thus they might not be that motivated to develop in-a-human-lifetime interstellar travel. Note a D + T fusion economy also could produce large amounts of He3 if that was wanted because a D + T economy is going to breed large amounts of T from lithium. If some of that is allowed to decay you get He3 which can be diverted to whatever use people have for it. Adding up those options I think the trace quantities of He3 that might turn up away from Earth don't move the needle.
- ncmncm 5y ago3He has almost exactly the availability of tritium, around here, because (almost) every last atom of tritium you manufacture will, in pretty short order, become 3He, unless you go fusing it first. It seems likely that the atmosphere of Neptune has a useful fraction of 3He. But you need to get there first, with apparatus to collect it. For that, you probably need a fusion rocket, and 3He to burn in it.
- adrian_b 5y ago3He can be produced, as you say, by storing the tritium and waiting for it to decay. Making the tritium requires another fusion or fission reactor, in which case there is no point in trying to develop a 3He fusion reactor, because it will be advantageous only if it can replace the fission reactors and the "dirty" fusion reactors. If those are still needed to produce the nuclear fuel, nothing is gained by using 3He. If there would have existed a natural source of sufficient 3He, then things would have been very different and the deuterium-3He fusion would have been the top priority in fusion research. A much more likely use of 3He is inside the so-called tritium-suppressed deuterium-deuterium fusion reactors. The deuterium-deuterium reactions produce both tritium and 3He. If the tritium is removed continuously from the fusion reactor, then it is stored for a long enough time until it decays into 3He, and then it is fed back into the fusion reactor, that fusion reactor would use only deuterium as primary input fuel and because it will fuse internally larger quantities of 3He than of tritium, it will produce a flux of neutrons significantly lower than a standard deuterium-deuterium fusion reactor, even if not so low as a reactor that could use 3He as a primary input fuel. This idea is promising, but the conditions for deuterium-deuterium fusion are more difficult to attain than for deuterium-tritium fusion. Moreover, all the papers that I have seen about this concentrated on the great advantages that would happen if one would remove the tritium from the reactor as soon as it is produced, but none of them mentioned the practical means to do this. Removing promptly the tritium from the plasma of a fusion reactor is something much easier said than done.
- ncmncm 5y agoThere are circumstances where fusing 3He is useful even where you have to make it yourself, first. Use as spacecraft fuel is just such a circumstance. It is yet to be seen whether remote laser or local fusion will be more useful for powering outer-solar-system spacecraft. If you only need neutrons to make 3H, they don't need to be hot, and are more useful cold.