5 ms·
For those who are not aware why this might be important, the hydrogen-boron fusion reaction is the easiest among the so-called aneutronic fusion reactions, i.e.
by adrian_b 5y ago
For those who are not aware why this might be important, the hydrogen-boron fusion reaction is the easiest among the so-called aneutronic fusion reactions, i.e. among the fusion reactions whose products are all stable nuclei.
This kind of fusion is the only kind of fusion that may be considered clean, because the risks of producing radioactive waste are negligible.
The easier kinds of fusion, which are attempted by almost all fusion research projects, e.g. the deuterium-tritium fusion, produce most of the energy in the form of high-speed neutrons, which must be absorbed by some shield. The shield will soon become radioactive, generating a lot of radioactive waste, even if it may be hoped that by choosing carefully the shield material the kind of radioactive waste that is produced may be less dangerous than the waste generated by fission reactors.
So any research results about hydrogen-boron fusion are far more important than the results about easier fusion reactions.
Unfortunately, even with these positive news, there is no clear path towards developing some kind of fusion reactor that could use this better fusion reaction.
- moonchrome 5y ago>So any research results about hydrogen-boron fusion are far more important than the results about easier fusion reactions. That's like saying research results in exhaust filters was much more important than research into combustion engines back when we had none - how does that make any sense ? Disposing radioactive waste isn't impossible, it's just not trivial, if that was the only downside of fission plants I doubt many people would have a problem with them. Pollution produced by coal plants is categorically worse and yet we have those all over the place.
- adrian_b 5y agoIt is not just the problem of disposing the waste. Any neutron shield will be destroyed in a relatively short time, so it will have to be replaced and processed for the separation of the radioactive waste. This is certain to greatly increase the cost of operation for a fusion reactor. Also the fusion energy carried by the neutrons will be recovered only partially, because it will be transformed in heat in the shield and taken away by a coolant and then the heat will be used in electric generators, like the heat produced by fission or by fossil fuel burning. Because the products of an aneutronic fusion reaction are high-speed charged particles, it is theoretically possible to make a direct electric generator, without using heat as an intermediate, which could have a much higher efficiency. Making a small fusion reactor that produces neutrons would be always impossible if living beings are close, due to the need for a neutron shield. So you will never have e.g. a car with such a fusion reactor. There are no known size limits for a fusion reactor with hydrogen-boron, so it might be possible to make reactors small enough to power a house or a vehicle. So if it would be possible to control a fusion reaction like hydrogen-boron, it would be possible to make fusion reactors that could produce much cheaper energy than it is possible with the easier fusion reactions, for which it remains to be proven if they could become economically viable, even long after the technical problems needed to enable the production of more energy than consumed will be solved. However, many real breaktroughs would be needed to discover how to do aneutronic fusion reactions, at the scale needed for energy production. The easier fusion reactions, like deuterium-tritium or deuterium-deuterium, have so many intrinsic disadvantages and so little advantages over fission reactors that it does not seem likely that they could ever become the main method for energy production.
- Retric 5y agoBillion degree partials produce very high energy photons. Thus it’s still producing ionizing radiation so scaling down to a car sized reactor isn’t going to practical. Further, Hydrogen born is also only aneutronic if the chamber is kept free from everything else to an impractical standard. So, yes in theory you don’t need neutron shielding, but in practice you very much need shielding at useful sustained power outputs. In the end you will still produce radioactive waste, just less of it.
- adrian_b 5y agoThere are negligible chances that a fusion reaction like hydrogen-boron will ever be achieved by thermal means. If such fusion reactions will ever be used, some means to accelerate the nuclei will have to be used, so that they will have a directed movement not a random thermal movement. So there will be no billion degree plasma in thermal equilibrium, radiating gamma-ray photons. Some high-energy photons will be produced in secondary reactions, but that cannot be compared to standard fusion, where producing neutrons is the intended result of the reactions. It cannot be predicted yet how much shielding might be needed, but in any case that would not be comparable with the needs of standard fusion. The real problem of the hydrogen-boron fusion is that, for now, there is no known method that could ensure a high-enough probability of collisions between accelerated nuclei and a solid target or other accelerated nuclei, so that the rate of collisions would be high enough to generate more energy than consumed.
- Retric 5y ago> It cannot be predicted yet how much shielding might be needed It’s not magic, you can set useful lower bounds knowing an actual reactor would be worse.
- DennisP 5y agoHB11 Energy's method is non-thermal. They use a petawatt picosecond laser, which is so intense that it shoves the target nuclei sideways into the nuclei behind them.
- southerntofu 5y ago> Disposing radioactive waste isn't impossible, it's just not trivial Source? To my knowledge, all radioactive waste disposal systems we have tried to this day have profoundly failed... and some even have failed years before they were scheduled to store any nuclear waste (eg. deadly gallery collapse in Bure, France).
- delecti 5y agoMost radioactive waste disposal schemes I've heard of have been shelved because of NIMBYism. But it hasn't even been an issue, because most radioactive waste is so benign that just leaving it in storage containers on-site is fine anyway.
- u320 5y agoThere are today 0 long term waste facilities in the world, so none have failed obviously. There are a lot of (non-military) medium term waste facilities (since that is all we need right now) and none of them have experienced any radiation leak.
- brippalcharrid 5y agoIt sounds like the lack of hard neutron flux would also avoid proliferation problems with Pu-239. https://www.hsfk.de/fileadmin/HSFK/hsfk_downloads/Strong_Neutron_Sources_final.pdf https://www.hsfk.de/fileadmin/HSFK/hsfk_downloads/Strong_Neu...
- gruturo 5y agoThat's indeed the case, but it also avoids the neutron embrittlement of the reactor building, it avoids a lot of the costly maintenances associated with it (replace strut X every 1.5 years of operation), and said maintenances would also have been complicated by having to operate in a building which is now itself radioactive due to neutron activation. The beauty of pB11 is that it just produces (mostly) helium, so it doesn't make the place radioactive. A very small amount of reactions result in short lived C11 (20 minutes half life) and the occasional neutron, but nowhere near the amount of DT (1 neutron per reaction). No proliferation potential, no waste disposal problem, no dangerous fuel also lead to greatly reduced security costs. And very little decommissioning costs. Now if it wasn't just so damn hard to ignite...
- pfdietz 5y agoIt will still produce neutrons via the (alpha,n) reaction on 11B. And it will produce very energetic gammas by the (p,gamma) reaction. These gammas are energetic enough to cause photonuclear reactions in the surrounding materials, including production of photoneutrons. While the amount of neutrons would be so low that materials could handle them, they'd still make the reactor hot enough that hands-on maintenance would not be possible (it would make it easier on remotely operated repair machines, though.) It's a shame none of the p-11B schemes appear to be workable. Helion's approach seems more realistic (if still a stretch) and would also greatly ease neutron levels, if not to the same extent p-11B would.
- gruturo 5y agoI was under the impression that the neutron flux would be very low, and those neutrons would not be likely to activate any material due to their energy - I stand corrected, thank you.
- bbojan 5y agoAnother advantage of hydrogen-boron fusion is that all the reaction products are charged. Therefore (theoretically) it would be possible to use *very* efficient magnetohydrodynamic methods of converting the reaction energy to electric energy. More mainstream fusion methods have to go through the typical hot water -> steam -> steam turbine route. There is a theoretical limit to the efficiency of this conversion (around 40%). In addition, the cost of electricity has a lower limit based on the capital expense of the steam turbine/generator. H-B11 fusion could be order of magnitudes cheaper.
- ginko 5y agoSo if I understand this correctly this essentially creates an electric charge from initially uncharged particles. Wouldn't running a fusion like this lead to us accumulating more and more of a one-sided charge over time? I guess it doesn't matter so much on Earth, but for instance if you ran a fusion reactor like that on a space station. Wouldn't it become electrically charged?
- DennisP 5y agoNo, there are still plenty of electrons. You start with hydrogen (one proton, one electron) and boron (five protons, five electrons). You end with three heliums (each with two proton, two electrons). The energy isn't extracted because of a build-up of charge. What happens is that each nuclear reaction is a tiny explosion. The helium nuclei shoot out really fast, and they're positively charged. You just need them to push through a magnetic field, and then you're getting electricity, like any generator moving magnets through a coil.
- pfdietz 5y agoThat is not HB11's proposed direct conversion scheme. HB11 proposes to have the alpha particles go up a large potential gradient, in effect charging a capacitor. I don't think their scheme works, btw. Having the ions move against a magnetic field doesn't change their energy. What would be needed for that scheme is to subject the ions to a changing magnetic field to produce an electric field that reduces their energy. Helion proposes something like this.
- herodoturtle 5y agoThanks for this insightful comment. I know very little about this field - but thankfully I know just enough to understand everything you said above. > there is no clear path towards developing some kind of fusion reactor that could use this better fusion reaction If you have the time to spare, could you unpack this a little bit? I'm sure many of us would appreciate the added insight. Thanks!
- adrian_b 5y agoI have already mentioned the problem in another reply above. People try mostly the fusion between hydrogen isotopes, or at most between hydrogen and lithium, because these nuclei have a low electric charge, 1 for hydrogen and 3 for lithium, so that the repulsion forces between them are relatively small. When nuclei with greater electric charge are involved, e.g. boron, the repulsion forces increase. To overcome them, the nuclei must have a higher relative velocity before collision. There are 2 ways to obtain high-speed nuclei, either by heating some plasma until the nuclei have a random thermal motion with high-enough typical velocities, or instead of heating everything and hoping for random collisions, you accelerate somehow some nuclei towards others, so that their movement is directed, not random. It is already very difficult to contain plasma hot enough for deuterium fusion. There are very small chances for being able to contain and control the much hotter plasma that would be needed for fusion reactions with heavier nuclei. So attempting to do hydrogen-boron fusion with the methods tried for deuterium-tritium seems doomed to fail. The workaround is to abandon the thermal way and to search for a way to cause the fusion of accelerated nuclei, using some combination of electric fields, magnetic fields and lasers. To produce more energy than consumed, it is required to have a very high probability that the accelerated nuclei will collide with their target (which might be fixed or also accelerated). For this either the ion beams would have to be very dense, or their positions would have to be controlled with nanometer precision or a single primary collision should cause multiple secondary collisions, or some other means would have to be discovered to ensure that the accelerated ions collide with the target instead of missing it. All of the methods that have been imagined yet have a collision probability lower than needed by a few orders of magnitude. So several real breakthroughs would be needed to be able to produce energy in this way. The only hope for this is based on the fact that are no known reasons that would make this target impossible, while for the deuterium based fusion reactions there are a few serious disadvantages that are impossible to overcome, mainly caused by the facts that the energy is produced as neutrons and that deuterium and tritium have low availability.
- PaulHoule 5y agoD + He3 is easier than p + B11 (in terms of required temperature and pressure) but is not so clean because you get some D + D that produces some T which then reacts with the D to make very hard neutrons. He3 though is hard to get. If you had D + T or D + D fusion running at scale you could breed a lot of it though. He3 was proposed as a starship fuel in the 1970s Daedalus project. It’s not that hard to believe it could be made to work IF you had a heavy ion beam ignition which in turn means you make a very big ship (… like a manned starship, not a ultra-long range Voyager.)
- ncmncm 5y ago3He is exactly as available as T, tritium. Any tritium you don't burn becomes 3He on a perfectly predictable schedule.
- PaulHoule 5y agoIn a D + T cycle it is easy to multiply hard neutrons to breed more T from Li. If you've got an excess of T you can let some decay. Today we produce He3 using expired T from nuclear weapons. On a scalable basis we'd be either liquefying the T or compressing it to store it as gas, either way you'd have to remove the radioactive decay heat.
- ncmncm 5y agoWe could make T and, maybe a bit more more directly 3He, given neutrons. But are there energetically cheap processes to make lots of neutrons?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]