8 ms·
It is correct to refer to GNU/Linux as GNU/Linux
- matthews2 5y agoWhy stop at GNU/Linux? Why not Firefox/GNOME/X11/GNU/Linux?
- tolleydbg 5y agoYou forgot systemd.
- rekado 5y agoIt is not about the components that make up a system. The GNU project started in 1983 with the explicit intent to replace proprietary components of an operating system in order to build a completely free operating system. Can you tell me any other project in the 80s that did that? Of those were any even half as successful as the GNU project? Or still relevant today? Misunderstanding GNU as a collection of little tools doesn't get you far; the C library, the complete compiler toolchain (binutils + linker + compiler), Unix userspace libraries and shells, etc --- all that got us very close to a completely free operating system in the late 80s / early 90s. Linux arrived in 1991 and in short order we had a free operating system --- with no small thanks to GNU. The project was so successful that the scope of what makes an operating system kept growing, while people took the foundations for granted. These early achievements stand on their own.
- froh 5y agoYes. It's even in the name. As a clone of Unix it's "not Unix", NU, which is homophone, pronounced the same as gnu, the animal. To avoid confusion with the animal, the leading g of G-NU is thus pronounced and audible. Thus "G-NU is not Unix", the Unix system tools clone, lacking a kernel. Then came the Linux kernel. And the gnu projects own "hurd" kernel (a herd of gnus, a microkernel, snicker in gnu). However GNU/hurd systems never took off... You probably know all that, but there is a wide audience following...
- Qem 5y agoI wonder, why does Hurd has such a hard time taking off? Is it just lack of manpower, or did they find some unsurmountable technical obstacle?
- rekado 5y agoThere are not many people hacking on the Hurd. There are a couple of reasons for this: - Linux exists and the expected benefits of the Hurd (e.g. more fine grain virtualization, userspace drivers, etc) aren't enough to mass-motivate people to switch to contribute to the Hurd. - Commercial support. Getting your contributions into Linux is cool, because you can tell employers that your code runs on millions of computers. Nobody cares that you contribute to the Hurd. - the most usable distribution of the Hurd is closely tied to Debian, for historic reasons and due to the fact that the most senior developer is a Debian maintainer. This is an obstacle to me, because it means that you can't just take the code from the Hurd repos and build your system. You need to use Debian patches and it's confusing to figure out what code is actually used. - the famous Critique of the Hurd by former contributors was devastating to morale as it suggested big changes to overcome some denial of service problems. More people explored whether other microkernels could be used and a lot of time was wasted for no perceptible gain. GNU Mach is just fine for the job. - the Hurd doesn't make use of recent hardware features. That's because of the above issues. Although slow progress is made by a handful of volunteers, there's no 64bit version, no SMP, no booting on ARM, memory / storage limits, etc. Nothing insurmountable. - no project management. The GNU project is not a "project" and RMS is not a leader. There's neither funding for the Hurd nor is there any form of support from the "GNU project". Having said all that, there have been exciting developments in recent years. The increasing use of the NetBSD rumpkernel for userspace drivers such as audio and disks (much more recent than the old Linux drivers and ironically more compatible license-wise), Guix System on top of the Hurd, etc. Many Debian-only patches are slowly being accepted in the different upstreams (glibc, libpciaccess, etc) and the project has become easier to contribute to. Still, the biggest problem is the lack of self-motivated contributors. There are people that think it would be exciting to contribute to the Hurd, but then they end up requiring hand-holding from one of the very few active contributors, so eventually nothing gets accomplished.
- yakak 5y agohttps://stackoverflow.com/questions/70649591/can-linux-kernel-glibc-bash-cover-most-posix-standard https://stackoverflow.com/questions/70649591/can-linux-kerne... Your platform isn't your optional dependencies.
- nix23 5y agoGnu/glibc/Linux or BusyBox/musl/Linux would make more sense.
- bcatanzaro 5y agoOrdinarily I’m not this pedantic, but given the subject of this article I just have to point out that it has been incorrect to refer to NVIDIA as nVidia for well over 15 years. Nvidia is what the WSJ and Wikipedia use and seems fine if one objects to all-caps. But the company abandoned nVidia about a human generation ago.
- ComradePhil 5y agoStallman is not the brightest. He could have easily suggested to call it "nux" written as "gnux". It has "GNU", it has the second syllable of "Linux", but most importantly, it brings it down to one syllable... and is cool. Instead, he tried to butcher a cool name that "Linux" is by adding capitalized "GNU" and a freaking slash. Why would anyone do that when saying and writing "Linux" serves the same... and if you have to refer to the kernel, you can say "the Linux kernel" or just "Linux" when the context lets you.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- parski 5y agoThat's actually pretty great.
- rekado 5y agoFrom "Free as in Freedom", page 151: > At first, Stallman proposed the term > “Lignux” – combining the names Linux and GNU – but the initial > reaction was very negative, and this convinced Stallman to go with > the longer but less criticized GNU/Linux.
- Gigachad 5y agoI searched this term and found a 1996 email from Linus saying how much he dislikes the term Lignux https://groups.google.com/g/comp.os.linux.misc/c/Cm15HxjDGRs/m/su3OHyLUgXcJ https://groups.google.com/g/comp.os.linux.misc/c/Cm15HxjDGRs...
- lodi 5y agoHmm, "Lignux" is actually pretty clever.
- tolleydbg 5y agoCan anyone point to where the FSF has indicated that Manjaro is its preferred distribution?
- tolleydbg 5y agoThe author has updated the article to name Parabola as the distribution preferred by the FSF.
- matthews2 5y agoI was curious too. My weak Google-fu didn't come up with anything from the FSF, but the GNU project has a page[0] explaining that they don't endorse Manjaro because it "includes nonfree software through its normal channels", "ships nonfree blobs with its kernel", and "includes a proprietary office suite and proprietary games with DRM." [0]: https://www.gnu.org/distros/common-distros.en.html https://www.gnu.org/distros/common-distros.en.html
- weare138 5y agoI can't find anything. FSF's site doesn't seem to even mention Manjaro. The only thing I could find that references both the FSF and Manjaro is this article from GNU explaining why they don't endorse any particular distribution: https://www.gnu.org/distros/common-distros.en.html https://www.gnu.org/distros/common-distros.en.html Plus as mentioned in the article Manjaro includes non-free software so I doubt GNU/FSF would recommend it even if they did endorse certain distributions.
- EdwardDiego 5y ago> Even between GNU/Linux distributions, compatibility is difficult. So... what's the point of this nitpicking then, if one GNU/Linux is hard to make work well with another GNU/Linux? Maybe we can just continuing referring to the GNU/Linux distros as Linux for short, and the non-compatible ones like Alpine and Android can be referred to as... Alpine and Android?
- jmillikin 5y agoThe core debate here is the meaning of "operating system". The GNU project does not consider Linux to be its own operating system, because they're coming from the culture of traditional UNIX where the OS interface is libc and the kernel is an implementation detail. Direct descendents of UNIX (for example Solaris and macOS) follow this model. The article's author, for example, writes: GNU/Linux is a distinct operating system in the family of operating systems which use the Linux kernel Linux developers, and many (most?) users, consider Linux to be an operating system in and of itself. It's practical to run a custom-written userland directly on top of the Linux kernel, with no libc or GNU software present. To someone who thinks of Linux itself as an OS, for GNU to demand co-branding is a bit like asking for the name to be Mozilla/Linux or KDE/Linux. Why should one particular vendor of userland software be treated specially? The GNU folks are unlikely to win this because they lost the Linux distribution market share decades ago. The most popular Linux distributions are Android (non-GNU), ChromeOS (non-GNU), and a long tail of embedded appliances. Distributions built on GNU libc/coreutils, including Fedora and Ubuntu, are below the noise floor.
- jcbrand 5y agoThe fact that some Linuxes don't use GNU (Android, ChromeOS) can be used as an argument that when GNU is being used, one can (_should_ is perhaps a bit much) mention that it's GNU/Linux to clear up confusion.
- jmillikin 5y agoSome Windows machines don't have Chrome installed, does that mean those that do should be called Chrome/Windows? On a nominally "GNU/Linux" installation, Linux is the important part of the stack. GNU software is a small (and shrinking!) part of the userland. I expect this trend to continue as Clang/LLVM pushes out GCC, modern packaging replaces Debian-style dependency resolution[1], and more software moves from C/C++ toward languages that statically link their runtimes (Go, Rust). [1] Debian-style packaging, where the binaries link against a libc, is a big part of why GNU libc has been considered by some people to be part of the OS. It's not really part of Linux, but if every userland software is written in C and needs a pre-installed libc.so, then you've got to pick one. Nowadays, packaging of userland software is moving toward FlatPak/Snap/etc where dependencies are bundled. libc.so is just another (exceptionally large) dependency in that world, and GNU libc has no more claim to be part of the platform than Bionic or MUSL.
- captainmuon 5y agoWe need a term for unixy software distributions, or what is vulgarly called Linux. Ubuntu, Debian, Red Hat, Arch are all "linuxes", but so are Alpine and OpenWrt. If you remember early SUSE distributions, they came with binary packages on a CD and no compiler, I would call that also "linux" but only barely. Android is clearly not a "linux". The OS that runs on Quectel cellular modems has a Linux kernel, but unless you gain serial access, there is no "linux". Controversely, I would also say some BSDs and macOS are, in some fashion, a "linux". Like a wooden horse is a horse, but at the same time it of course isn't a real horse. For something to qualify as a "linux" in my mind it needs to run most of the GNU/Linux software I need, with little modification. This can be headless software or GUIs. It uses posix conventions ("/" path separator, "/usr" and so on), and it has development tools preinstalled or one command away. There is a command line, and you can use all the familiar tools like ls or vi. That's why I - half jokingly of course - consider macOS to be a great alternative "linux" (although weirdly locked down, and with a lot of NIH proprietary parts). It's also fun TBH to tease the "I'd like to interject for a moment" crowd :-)
- DocTomoe 5y agoIn my bubble, and for quite some time, the term unixoid has been used to describe any OS that resembles UNIX - which lines up well with your description of that class of software
- captainmuon 5y agoYes, but unixoid reminds me of AIX, HP-UX, Solaris and the likes, which I think is another category. Maybe "linuxoid"?
- paulsutter 5y agoWhen the IBM PC came out, I was upset that the term PC began forever to apply only to intel PCs and not PCs generally (previously the term PC meant generically any personal computer) It was a waste of energy. Battles over word usage may feel like hard work but they don’t produce anything
- bencollier49 5y agoDon't get me started on "crypto" and "cyber".
- DyslexicAtheist 5y agofor 3 decades IOT meant Inter-Operability-Testing in a Telecommunications context. There where hundreds of people who's job title was "IOT Engineer" and it had nothing to do with the internet of things. Guess they all eventually gave up the fight and changed their career by pivoting into the IoT just so that recruiters leave them alone.
- witrak 5y agoPerhaps I'm wrong but for the Internet of Things, I always use the IoT acronym. And IOT != IOT...
- witrak 5y agoCorrection: IoT != IOT
- DyslexicAtheist 5y agome too but apparently the world does not care about case
- DyslexicAtheist 5y agoI've never referred to Linux as GNU/Linux simply because I dislike the activism behind the term. Also GNU is everywhere once I open my box. There is gnuplot, gawk, gnu-grep, literally every command that I read the man page has added gnu-ish features I'm deeply thankful for. I would have no problem calling it GNU/Linux if it weren't for the people (are there more than just RMS ?) whining about it. If they really felt it was so important to have the GNU label on Linux they should have made the Hurd kernel as popular as Linux, or put effort into Hurd before focusing on the tools. Or they should have added a sentence in the GPL that enforces it. (wink wink nod nod there are thousands of packages released under GPL so why continue the whining?) Because they never stop whining (and because there is a "debate" in the first place) proves my point that it's perfectly fine (if not my duty) to continue referring to it as Linux.
- tored 5y agognuplot is not part of GNU
- DyslexicAtheist 5y agowell spotted ;)
- antris 5y agoI will never understand people who have a kneejerk reaction against activism. Pretty much all of our freedoms have been fought for by activists. Sure, activists might not be media trained or have a big budget for effective and well researched media campaigns, but a little bit of cringe is a small price to pay to put people's rights forward. Yeah, RMS acts weird sometimes but pretty much everything he's been warning us about non-free software has come true. We absolutely need more people like him.
- tored 5y agoWhat freedoms am I missing when Linux is not called GNU/Linux?
- tored 5y agoDoes it say anywhere in the GNU licenses that any operating system or kernel created by the GNU tools must be called GNU/*? To my knowledge no, thus GNU activist has no case here. You are free to use the GNU tools, in accordance to their license, and name your project whatever but not infringing on other trademarks.
- rekado 5y agoThis is not a matter of licensing at all. Nor is it about "GNU tools" being used to create something.
- tored 5y agoWhat is about then? Linux uses glibc? Does the license of glibc state that any operating system using glibc requires to be named GNU/*? Hasn't many of the BSD variants and BeOS/Haiku use(d) the GCC toolchain and glibc?
- Schiphol 5y agoThe GNU activist is claiming a moral, not legal, right
- tolleydbg 5y agoThere is nothing "technically correct" about having an opinion on how important glibc and coreutils are to the operating system and including an acknowledgment in the name. This is a normative claim that I'm not particularly interest in. I call it Linux and don't plan to change, nor do I roll my eyes into the back of my head when someone calls it GNU/Linux. Okay, I lied about the last part.