7 ms·
While I realize this is a personal anecdote, the pandemic made starkly clear that the government will basically commandeer your property and force you to let te
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
While I realize this is a personal anecdote, the pandemic made starkly clear that the government will basically commandeer your property and force you to let tenants live there, so with that added risk it's no surprise landlords are being extra careful who they rent to.
I had a family member rent to someone in Feb of 2020. He paid one month of rent, and then nothing until the government finally let the eviction go through in Dec 2021. I don't entirely blame.the government, in that if my family member did even basic due diligence they would have seen how much of a grifter this guy was, with previous bankruptcies and other recent evictions. Still, in the past, when you made a mistake and got a bad tenant, the option was eviction. And while the government largely paid most.of this grifter's rent, my family member was still out over 15k in lost rent and legal fees.
As a consequence of this, nobody in my family would ever consider renting a property as a long term rental again - there is just too much risk, which means you'll see a lot of small, private landlords get out, only to leave large corporate landlords who will have much stricter rental policies.
- nostromo 5y agoThis happened to me in Seattle. I have a duplex and my renter just stopped paying. It's a joke that this had anything to do with Covid - the job market is tighter than it's ever been. I will never again take a chance on a renter in this city. If you have anything wrong with your credit or income history -- I'm sorry, but I can't take a chance on anyone anymore. Good luck finding a place to live. Don't blame me, blame the city government. The other thing that's happening: people like me rarely advertise our units. Instead we look through trusted networks -- friends, family, and co-workers. If you don't have a connection, you can't find these units at all.
- teachrdan 5y ago> I'm sorry, but I can't take a chance on anyone anymore. Good luck finding a place to live. Don't blame me, blame the city government. I would point out that if people in your position stopped buying rental units and invested your money elsewhere, there would be more housing on the market for renters looking to own their own home.
- tedivm 5y agoIt's always weird to me how landlords act like they're the ones who are actually building the units. On the supply and demand curve they're on the demand side, not supply.
- glencolemann 5y ago
- chrismcb 5y agoAnd fewer holes on the market for renters that want to rent.
- djbebs 5y agoThere would also be more housing on the market if more houses were allowed to be built
- throwawaygh 5y ago> And while the governent largely paid most.of this grifter's rent, my family member was still out over 15k in lost rent and legal fees. Not "the government". Taxpayers. Taxpayers bailed out rent seekers. > you'll see a lot of small, private landlords get out, only to leave large corporate landlords who will have much stricter rental policies. If this were to happen, it would be a good thing. Consolidation erodes the electoral base of rent seekers, which makes Georgist policies much easier to implement. But it won't happen, because... > long term rental
- noduerme 5y agoA staggering majority of rental units in the US are owned by individuals who own and rent less than 5 units. https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2021/08/02/as-national-eviction-ban-expires-a-look-at-who-rents-and-who-owns-in-the-u-s/ft_21-07-16_landlordsrenters_3/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2021/08/02/as-national... What really happened was that taxpayers (read: People who earn and save money and hold some property) bailed out the people who took an opportunity to skip out on paying rent, and took a hit anyway, while their renters were getting all kinds of other free handouts in taxpayer subsidies. Great. So maybe we need some wealth redistribution. But cheering the consolidation of the rental market in the hands of corporations is like snickering evil. You're advocating for the destruction of the middle class. I guess it would make revolution an easier sell. But you know what else could make you happy? Joining the middle class, buckling up and saving money, taking the hard part of it without feeling like a constant victim, and stop wasting your time trying to destroying the wealth people spend their lives working for. Harming other people to bring them down really isn't going to elevate anyone, and you know it. Rooting for the middle class to be destroyed for your own personal satisfaction is greedy, indolent and ultimately self destructive. [edit: It's sad to see you channeling your grievance into something that will only keep you down.]
- diordiderot 5y ago'Middle class' is a blip in human experience caused by fear of a real possibility of socialist takeover made possible by highly progressive taxation. There are only two classes comrade
- femiagbabiaka 5y ago> As a consequence of this, nobody in my family would ever consider renting a property as a long term rental again - there is just too much risk, which means you'll see a lot of small, private landlords get out, only to leave large corporate landlords who will have much stricter rental policies. Personally I think large corporate landlords in combination with sensible nationwide renters rights are preferable. There are tradeoffs of course, but the protection of the private/small rentier class has had many more bad effects than good for housing policy generally IMO -- Prop 13 being a good example. I think the way that you're describing your relationship with your property in terms of ownership and how you feel about the government intervening in that is shared by most small landlords with investment properties, and gets to the core of a lot of the problems inherent in the small landlord paradigm. Too much skin in the game (lack of diversification) and a dependency on turning a steady profit from a speculative investment in what is a basic human need. There are a lot of things that got us here in the U.S. and unfortunately the reality will likely be a continuance of the status quo.
- gxs 5y agoSo the answer to people not paying rent is for small landlords to..not own land? And having Amazon rent you an apartment is somehow preferable? How about we do the critical thinking, fix zoning laws where necessary, allow tenants to be kicked out for…being shitty tenants, and make an effort to put laws in place that make it easier for people to make a living wage and pay their rent.
- femiagbabiaka 5y ago> So the answer to people not paying rent is for small landlords to..not own land? Yes actually. Well, in part at least. I would put it in the non-reformist reform category. It opens up the possibility of actually doing something about renting in this country, unlike the status quo where people speculating on property demand law change whenever governments choose to keep people in homes instead of protecting their investment income. Of course, folks can own land if they want. But we should absolutely discourage treating what is at its core a shared resource critical to human existence as an investment vehicle. > And having Amazon rent you an apartment is somehow preferable? Yes. Regulating Amazon and regulating Ms. Jones who rents out her second floor are much different propositions for the average voter. > How about we do the critical thinking, fix zoning laws where necessary, allow tenants to be kicked out for…being shitty tenants, and make an effort to put laws in place that make it easier for people to make a living wage and pay their rent. It is interesting that in your formulation, critical thinking can only lead to a conclusion where the makeup of the rentier class and how we regulate housing investment are irrelevant. Are you a landlord?
- encryptluks2 5y ago> Still, in the past, when you made a mistake and got a bad tenant, the option was eviction. I think a lot of landlords see renting as easy money and then when they do have an issue like this they are looking for anyone to blame when they really never did their due diligence. There was relief for landlords during the pandemic for landlords as well, especially those that still had a mortgage on properties.
- inglor_cz 5y agoIf you enact laws that make it impossible or very hard to punish defectors from business contracts, don't be surprised that the particular market sector withers and loses its vibrancy. Geniune poverty should be taken care of by the welfare system, not by random landlords who may be in a precarious situation themselves. Not everyone who owns an extra property is rich and it does not make sense to treat a small local businessperson exactly the same as Amazon.
- encryptluks2 5y agoLandlords and businesses owners got their own form of welfare, which was significantly more than those that were without a job. Landlords need to know landlord/tenant laws but many simply want to be able to do whatever they want then act surprised when they find out what they did violated some state law. I have little sympathy for landlords who got relief then want to complain. Reminds me of businesses that got millions in PPP loans, but then put up signs saying... sorry we have a crappy business, it was due to welfare.
- onion2k 5y agoStill, in the past, when you made a mistake and got a bad tenant, the option was eviction. You say "in the past" but you really mean "when there isn't a global pandemic". Events change things. It's simply a risk of renting property to people that very few landlords bothered to consider. There is absolutely no reason why landlords should be immune to circumstances that affect everyone. Complaining about it, and tacitly suggesting that your rental income should be prioritized over a disease that eventually killed hundreds of thousands of people, is silly.
- djrironman 5y agoA society that literally enable cheaters is not going to go far, and it's actually (like in this case) going to backfire to the (poor and) honest people. It's the same in France.. some basically end up paying gypsies to forcefully remove tenants that dont' pay
- onion2k 5y agoA society that literally enable cheaters is not going to go far.. As a permanent policy, sure. That wouldn't work. However, a society that allows landlords to force people to move when everyone is meant to be quarantined will have significantly bigger problems than a temporary block on evictions even if that hurts landlords.
- djrironman 5y agoOk but you have to make them accountable in some way. How do you do with super poor people ?
- kyrra 5y agoYour logic is severely flawed. Why were only landlords impacted here? Why didn't grocery stores have to just give away food? Why wasn't gasoline free? This was the government attempting to usurp part of the economy without much timely recourse for those on the losing end.
- 5y ago