3 ms·
Ask people if they want tech companies to censor information or show everything exactly as it was posted, and most will pick the latter option, because of cours
by paxys 5y ago
Ask people if they want tech companies to censor information or show everything exactly as it was posted, and most will pick the latter option, because of course it is the "correct" one.
Then combine their email inbox and spam folder for a day, and there will be riots.
"But that's not what I meant!" Well, algorithmically sorting through your incoming mail and hiding a bunch of it from view based on opaque criteria decided by a large tech corporation is the very definition of censorship. And yet we are okay with it since it makes our personal experience better.
People who cry about big tech censorship are perfectly fine with a curated experience with 99% of the garbage removed. By debating endlessly about the remaining 1% you aren't making some great moral point.
- swayvil 5y agoThat's what's called "argument by taking the absurd extreme". Of course there will be a degree of necessary censorship. For example, yes, it is practical to censor the spambots.
- paxys 5y agoAnd I assume you are the one who gets to decide what is "necessary" and "unnecessary" censorship?
- car_analogy 5y agoClearly there is no distinction to be made, and a spam filter is the same as burning all copies of 1984?
- paxys 5y agoThe slippery slope argument applies to both sides of this debate. A tech company removing a random Tweet from its platform isn't the same as a spam filter, just as it isn't the same as a Nazi book burning.
- car_analogy 5y agoThe original post wasn't making a slippery slope argument - they were claiming that censorship is already severe and prevalent now.
- paxys 5y agoBy comparing it with a book burning, which is what this post is about. > Forget piles of burning books. The library is on fire.