3 ms·
Seems like a ridiculous suit, but it also seems like Krebs calling it a cover up is sort of a gray area. They did send some sort of notification, but didn't ne
by giantg2 5y ago
Seems like a ridiculous suit, but it also seems like Krebs calling it a cover up is sort of a gray area. They did send some sort of notification, but didn't necessarily conceal it either. Looking forward to the ruling and reasoning - the legal determination of what constitutes a cover up. Especially since most places use the generic type notifications.
- QuinnyPig 5y agoGenerally I tend to take a dim view of bullies, and an $18B company suing an independent journalist for saying mean things on the internet is basically the textbook example of that.
- Godel_unicode 5y agoGenerally I take a dim view of shoddy journalism. Not doing adequate investigation before printing, then refusing to retract when it turns out you were wrong is basically a textbook example of that. I get that people really like him, but he had plenty of time to do the right thing here and has nobody to blame but himself.
- paxys 5y agoRegardless of what Krebs said, the bar for defamation in US courts is incredibly high. Nothing is going to come out of this.
- smnrchrds 5y ago> Nothing is going to come out of this. How much would it cost to make it go away? If it's going to cost millions of dollars, the defendant is toast regardless.
- giantg2 5y agoApparently insurance for legal defense is big business today. But yeah, generally even an unsuccessful suit will ruin normal people.
- xxpor 5y agoCalling it a cover up is a clear opinion, not a statement of fact. Just the fact that there's a debate about what cover up even means goes to that.
- BeefWellington 5y agoCourts don't always have sensible views on these things though.
- xxpor 5y agoIn the US, they do. If the district court doesn't, someone higher will.
- giantg2 5y agoDo you have experience in the courts? It's an absolute shitshow. I've seen a magistrate think that I'm calling them prejudiced when asking to dismiss with prejudice... really. Magistrates aren't required to be lawyers or even pass the Bar. I thought the next level up would provide some level of competence, but no. The judge had poor logic skills and even poorer knowledge of the rules of criminal procedure (spent their career in family court and was past retirement age, so they brought them back as a senior judge in criminal side). Guy couldn't logic his way out of a wet paper bag. Even if you get better judges at higher levels, which is debatable given they are either politically elected or politically appointed, the cost in time and money dramatically increases.
- starwind 5y agoThat gray area strongly favors Krebs. They have to show Krebs knew that there wasn't a cover up. Krebs can make an affirmative defense that basically says "this honestly seemed like a covered up to me" and win
- giantg2 5y agoI agree. But it will likely cost tens of thousands of dollars and years of his life to defend it.
- starwind 5y agoHe may be insured against defamation cases. My umbrella policy explicitly covers me is someone sues me for libel or slander
- InTheArena 5y agoRemember that he doubled down after the report came out that this was a insider attack. The first time he could have been taken at face value. The second time? Seems closer to willful ignorance.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]