3 ms·
In the economic model, cost of the externality should go to reverse the damage, or compensate those harmed. This breaks down if the government taxes a good due
by s1artibartfast 5y ago
In the economic model, cost of the externality should go to reverse the damage, or compensate those harmed.
This breaks down if the government taxes a good due to externality, but spends the proceeds on something else.
Raising government revenues is arguably a social good, but does not benefit or compensate those harmed. Without targeted mitigation or compensation, such policies are simply sin taxes.
I don't think this is a problem with economists, who understand this well. you can not "set a tax precisely at the rate of the externality" without finding the cost of the externality to those impacted.
- hackerfromthefu 5y agoYes this is an important point that is usually overlooked in arguments about taxing externalities. e.g. GS makes off with bank from introducing carbon tax