3 ms·
> And that is without counting the returns on the investment. British officials reckon that three-quarters of the total cost of the transition to net zero will
by wolverine876 5y ago
> And that is without counting the returns on the investment. British officials reckon that three-quarters of the total cost of the transition to net zero will be offset by benefits such as more efficient transport, and that the state may need to spend only 0.4% of gdp a year over three decades.
That also omits by far the largest return on investment, which is frequently omitted: Preventing the costs of climate change.
People who criticize actions to prevent climate change often talk about the economic impact of those actions. The economic impact of not preventing climate change - in addition to the impact on human life - is usually far greater. The question is not, 'how much does this change cost?', but 'what are the outcomes of our various options?'.
- s1artibartfast 5y ago>People who criticize actions to prevent climate change often talk about the economic impact of those actions. The economic impact of not preventing climate change - in addition to the impact on human life - is usually far greater. I think public discourse avoids this topic because the benefits and costs of climate policy are not uniform. There are there are nations, groups, and individuals for which climate policy is a simply negative. Talking about net benefit risks bringing up this topic, which is largely unsolved. proactive climate policy has clear winners and losers. While net zero carbon may be relatively cheap and have net benefit for Brittan, for some poor developing countries, avoiding cheap carbon energy means more people in poverty with all the downsides that come along with that.
- wolverine876 5y ago> There are there are nations, groups, and individuals for which climate policy is a simply negative. Talking about net benefit risks bringing up this topic, which is largely unsolved. proactive climate policy has clear winners and losers. What basis do you have for these claims? If FUD is the basis for stopping us, we should never do anything; we never operate in certainty, and we never operate in a situation where people can't create FUD. Climate change is possibly the most studied issue in the history of the world; we don't need to know more. How much longer will you try to delay action?
- s1artibartfast 5y agoSee how inflammatory the mere topic is? I didn't even say it wasn't a net positive. Just that there will be winners and losers. This is how strong the dogma is around the topic. This is the economic consensus and clear as daylight. Climate policy will indisputably hamper the economies of petrostates. It will indisputably hamper growth in developing nations, where filthy coal is the cheapest source electricity. It will indisputably put workers in the fossil fuel industry out of jobs, some of whom will not retrain or recover. >FUD Like any policy, some people are harmed and some benefit. This is simply the reality of the world we live in. Rational people can accept this and debate it on it's own merits, and move on. Fear, uncertainty and doubt is a personal choice when presented with inconvenient facts. The irrational response is denial, thinking that every single person and interest will benefit.
- wolverine876 5y ago> Climate policy will indisputably hamper the economies of petrostates. It will indisputably hamper growth in developing nations, where filthy coal is the cheapest source electricity. It will indisputably put workers in the fossil fuel industry out of jobs, some of whom will not retrain or recover. That only looks at the cost side, not the benefit side. If we only look at the costs, all policies are bad ideas. > Fear, uncertainty and doubt is a personal choice It's also a propaganda technique to delay action.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoYes, I was talking about costs. I was acknowledging that some people will suffer more, and some will suffer less. Even good policies hurt some people. Sometimes a good policy will kill some and save others.