4 ms·
What this email doesn't say is that Google's solution for fixing retention problems was to reach out to Apple and many other large tech employers and sign illeg
by paxys 5y ago
What this email doesn't say is that Google's solution for fixing retention problems was to reach out to Apple and many other large tech employers and sign illegal agreements to not hire each other's employees.
The subject of this email (Facebook) famously declined to participate however.
- gnachman 5y agoIf you got an offer from Facebook they would beat it. I did this in 2012 and instantly had 10x the RSUs. Some Googlers thought it was immoral to do this. It was at this time that comp for engineers radically changed.
- paxys 5y agoI signed a job offer in late 2011 and was due to start a couple months later. Two weeks before the start date, the hiring manager emailed out of the blue to say that they were bumping up my starting salary by 10%. It was a wild time to be in tech (although the situation today isn't all that different).
- pavlov 5y agoZuckerberg is widely despised on HN, but he should get some credit for standing up to the Silicon Valley wage cartel. As your example shows, it put potentially life-changing compensation within the reach of a much larger group of software engineers. Previously you pretty much had to get lucky as an early engineer through IPO, but in the past decade it's been possible to save millions by working at FAANGs. And those millions trickle down into the ecosystem: people can afford to start their own companies, do angel investments, etc.
- Teever 5y agoYou don't give despicable people credit for doing the right thing because they happened to the right thing only because it benefited them.
- ALittleLight 5y agoZuckerberg doesn't seem that despicable to me. Certainly not in the company of companies like Google. What's the worst thing you can say about him or Facebook? I think most of the bad press just comes from media clickbait. Mainstream news identifies Facebook as a competitor and threat on ideological model, see people complaining about conservative news sources topping most shared on Facebook lists, and on a business model basis (Facebook controls a large stream of traffic).
- LunaSea 5y agoI mean a good argument against Facebook (and by proxy Zuckerberg) is that Facebook designs the product in a way that benefits them rather than the psychological well being of their users.
- ALittleLight 5y agoDo companies like Apple, Amazon, Microsoft, Netflix, Google, etc prioritize their customers over their own interests? Other companies in tech or outside of tech? I don't think Facebook is some well run charity doing philanthropy - I just don't think they are meaningfully worse than their peers. I do think there is a concerted media campaign to malign Facebook and I think this is where the differential in how people think of Facebook versus these other companies comes from.
- zamfi 5y ago…is this statement not true for any, say, Fortune 100 company? Does P&G put the psychological health of their customers over their own profits? Does Walmart? Apple? Exxon? One might be able to make the slightly stronger argument is that the average user’s psychological health is more at odds with Facebook’s interests/profits than most other companies — putting it in the same category as, perhaps, Phillip Morris — but even that is not an argument against Facebook or Zuckerberg; any company in the same position would likely be doing the same kind of thing.
- sydthrowaway 5y agoSurvivorship bias.
- ditonal 5y agoThen for years Google denied wrongdoing but said they couldn't address it because it was in active litigation. Finally, the whole thing got settled (slap on the wrist but something at least), so Google employees could finally get an answer in the weekly all-hands (TGIF). Laszlo Bock was their head of people at the time, and claimed that Google still did nothing wrong, and that they only settled because they were caught up in the whole thing with other companies like Adobe who did do something wrong. He said they did nothing wrong because they only stopped outbound recruiting towards employees at those companies, which had no effect, and still accepted inbound applications. This raises the obvious question - if outbound recruiting had no effect, why was Google so eager to put at end to it? And how could Google act like they were caught up it the crossfire when it was specifically emails by Sergey Brin that provided the strongest evidence of illegal collusions? It blew my mind how Google insists they hire "the world's smartest people" but then can have executives on stage spin narratives with ridiculous holes in it and expect those smart people to believe it rather than have their intelligence insulted. But sadly, most Google employees did seem to buy it. There's a strong cult of indoctrination, starting with calling yourself a Googler and wearing the stupid hat, that Google execs just had a halo effect. I think between 2010 and now that halo effect has massively worn off, especially with all the dirty details about misbehavior from Sergey Brin, Vic Gundtora, and Andy Rubin. Nonetheless, it served as strong evidence as to how even really smart people can get caught up in cult-like communities. The "founder worship", the indoctrination into company culture, all of that is super common in Silicon Valley tech companies and for an obvious reason - it works.
- MegaButts 5y ago> Nonetheless, it served as strong evidence as to how even really smart people can get caught up in cult-like communities. I see it differently. It seems like strong evidence as to how smart the average googler really is. If you start with the assumption these people are smart then you can reach your conclusion, but if you discard that assumption you just have a group of gullible employees.
- solveit 5y agoLol, every HN commenter knows Google was in the wrong but the Googlers themselves didn't because they're gullible. No, the Googlers didn't buy it but continued working because when it comes to it, thinking your company does shady things is very rarely sufficient to get you to up and leave. Is your company bigger than, say, a thousand people? Then they have definitely done something as bad as Google's collusion and you know it even if you don't know what. Are you going to leave?
- AnonymousC1421 5y agoGoogle isn't nearly as nice of a place to work at as people make it out to be. As an example they will finally increase vacation from 15days to 20days on April 1st this year. The media reports this as "on top of already lavish perks Googlers are now getting 20 days of PTO a year!". Gee whiz amazing. An increase from 15 days of PTO. If only we didn't much more than that in my much lower quality of life home country as a standard for tech workers. And sorry if this sounds a bit spoilt. I should be grateful to work at a large megacorp in this economy right? It's just that Google isn't any better in terms of working conditions than any other big tech company. In fact in general it's a little bit worse yet there's propaganda movies (The Internship) about how great it is to work at Google. It's a job. No one else seems to want to acknowledge it.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 5y ago> As an example they will finally increase vacation from 15days to 20days on April 1st this year. That change is for junior employees. It's still overdue, but vacation bumps up to 25 days per year after you have some tenure, and has done for more than a decade. I'm not saying that 25 days is anything to write home about -- I've heard of places that give 30, or unlimited -- but 25 is not bad.
- AnonymousC1421 5y agoLets put the numbers out there objectively for others reading this. Previously after 4 years you got 20 days per year. Then you got 25 at year 6+.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- colonelxc 5y agoThis might just be an impreciseness of language, but it's actually 20 days after you've been there 3 years, and 25 after you've been there for 5. So if you're saying 'year six' starts the day after you've been there for 5 full years, then yes, we are saying the same thing. (Source: have been at Google almost 8 years, and went through both of those bumps)
- jasode 5y ago>and many other large tech employers and sign illegal agreements to not hire each other's employees. I don't remember reading about any formally signed agreements. Executives aren't going to create an incriminating paper trail like that. Instead, it was some complaints in emails and an implied understanding. E.g. Steve Jobs and Eric Schmidt emails: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_Schmidt#Role_in_illegal_non-recruiting_agreements https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_Schmidt#Role_in_illegal_n...
- jonas21 5y agoYou have both the direction and timeline backwards. It was Apple who reached out to Google, and it happened in 2005, two years before this [1]. [1] https://www.engadget.com/2014-03-24-emails-reveal-that-steve-jobs-angrily-called-sergey-brin-over-go.html https://www.engadget.com/2014-03-24-emails-reveal-that-steve...