3 ms·
I grew up with A, B, C, D, and F. You always knew where you stood, where you were excelling, where you were going fine, and where you needed to put in extra eff
by ryandrake 5y ago
I grew up with A, B, C, D, and F. You always knew where you stood, where you were excelling, where you were going fine, and where you needed to put in extra effort. It was simple and effective.
My daughter’s school uses this ridiculous categorization:
- M: meeting standard
- P: progressing towards standard
- T: needs more time to meet standard
- AC: area of concern
Her “grades” are usually simply all M. Totally useless as a parent. I have no idea what “M” means in terms of her competitive ranking amongst her peers, readiness for AP or advanced courses and/or trajectory for future success in college. Someone who is barely hanging on, but technically “meets the standard” and someone who is a literal genius in the subject will both get “M”. It tells me (and her) nothing.
- sytelus 5y agoThis is classic example of what happens when system tries to make everyone feel good about themselves no matter where they actually stand. The feedback signal is now so blunt that it is fairly useless. It's like you remove all the grading in compass and how you have no idea which direction you are moving and where you have to go. As a child, grading is what motivated me to work harder and be proud of my achievement. It's the reward you get for putting in the work. It was the reason I gravitated to doing extra work instead of watching TV. This new system basically says you have to do minimal thing and there is no reward or motivation provided for going above and beyond the norms. The argument that this will somehow help underpriviledged students is so severely misguided. I was in fact the underpriviledged student. The good grades is what allowed others to invest in me and give me opportunities. It was one thing I could own and control. I feel sorry for so many talented hardworking underpriviledged students who will have nothing more to show for than "Meets standards".
- sjg007 5y agoHow would a letter grade change your understanding of where she ranks? And why is a competitive ranking among her peers important?
- alexvoda 5y agoAnd that is perhaps the point. I believe that the intention is that you should not stress about it as long as they are doing fine. And that you should not pass that stress to the child either. The grade is only there to warn you if there is a problem. To get feedback about the areas of performance, you should talk directly to the teacher and receive more than just 3 bits of information. Even with a much more granular grading system, as long as the grades are assigned based on task completion (correctly solving all the exercises in a test) instead of ranking, you will still have a inability to distinguish anything above top grade. If you move to a ranking system, where grades are assigned by comparison to peers, you run into issues of fairness, because resource availability inevitably plays a role.
- mattcwilson 5y agoYou seem to be implying that there is no value in a student who just barely meets the standard trying any harder or going any further. I hear you about stress. You seem to be saying though that even when stress isn’t an issue, there is no value in that student doing anything further (at that time). Am I mistaken?
- alexvoda 5y agoIndeed you are mistaken. What I was saying is that grades are not the appropriate tool to motivate students who already meet the standard. You need other approaches for those students in order to keep them engaged. And in those same cases, grades are not the proper measurement tool. There is no distinction between a straight "M" and a straight "A" student in terms of motivation nor measurement. Students who perform should be challenged, given responsibilities relevant to their talents, encouraged to participate in competitions (these are ranked) and various other possibilities. Grades are simply not the tool to use beyond the level of "doing fine".
- mattcwilson 5y ago> Students who perform should be ... encouraged to participate in competitions (these are ranked) ... > Grades are simply not the tool to use beyond the level of "doing fine". I am having trouble square rooting these two seemingly opposite claims. I think you are saying: in a school environment, use grades only to measure degree-below-standard. Outside school, use competitive ranking to measure degree-above-standard. Close?