3 ms·
I'm very grateful for Stallman and his ideals. Software freedom is a very important long-term issue, and he's done as much as anyone to promote it. It's unfo
by dasil003 15y ago
I'm very grateful for Stallman and his ideals. Software freedom is a very important long-term issue, and he's done as much as anyone to promote it.
It's unfortunate that he feels the need to malign someone like Jobs who spent his life pursuing the orthogonal goal of improving the user experience.
As bad as the App Store is for software freedom, it's not built that way to wrest power from the users, rather the goal is to improve the user experience by enforcing some standards. As damaging as this is to freedom, I believe in my heart that it is simply collateral damage, not malice. One need look no further than the Android Market to see pitfalls of looser controls. Some think App Store policies are about greed and control, but if you compare it to the old world of smart phone apps it's a breath of fresh air, and in any case, App Store revenues are not where Apple makes its billions.
The bottom line is that for the common person, the deal they get from companies like Apple, or Google, or even Facebook is probably not a bad one. They get tremendously more value from these businesses then they could from a powerful free software toolbox which no one can make enough money from to support properly.
Stallman is quick to point out that software freedom does not preclude its sale, but that's easy to say from his batch-emailing ivory tower. I'd like to see him put his money where his mouth is and actually make his living from selling free software.