I had a teacher do something like that for a "communication" class and I hated it. Not only on the basis of class average/GPA, but mostly just because it was a

I had a teacher do something like that for a "communication" class and I hated it. Not only on the basis of class average/GPA, but mostly just because it was a complete joke. You'd have people that could barely speak the language, were reading their cards the whole time and with powerpoint presentations stuffed with grammatical errors that got better grades than native speakers.