8 ms·
The "STIR/SHAKEN initiative" was supposed to fix this.[1] There's now a whole system with signed certificates, much like SSL certs, to sign caller ID info. The
by Animats 5y ago
The "STIR/SHAKEN initiative" was supposed to fix this.[1] There's now a whole system with signed certificates, much like SSL certs, to sign caller ID info. The info is at least good enough to find out which carrier generated the phony data.
You should file a complaint with the FCC that your carrier has not clearly not properly implemented STIR/SHAKEN, since they badly mis-identified the source of a call. While calls from outside the US can be unsigned, the carrier should detect that the number is inconsistent with the source.
There are "A", "B", and "C" level of verification. "A" calls are probably legit. The others, maybe not.
If you're in California, try making a personal data request to your carrier for the detailed STIR/SHAKEN data for that call.
[1] https://commlawgroup.com/2021/stir-shaken-robocall-mitigation-compliance-regime-what-is-it-why-is-it-important-who-must-comply-how-and-by-when https://commlawgroup.com/2021/stir-shaken-robocall-mitigatio...
- sillysaurusx 5y agoThe Federal Communications Commission (“FCC” or “Commission”) requires that all voice service providers (“VSPs”), with some exceptions discussed below, implement the STIR/SHAKEN caller ID authentication framework in the Internet Protocol (“IP”) portions of their networks by June 30, 2021. So stoked that there’s finally a way to fight back against robocalls, and that carriers are being forced into compliance. Thanks for pointing this out.
- karlshea 5y agoMy impression is STIR/SHAKEN is only for voice calls, not SMS. I'm no longer getting almost any robocalls on Verizon as of a couple of months ago when they "turned on" STIR/SHAKEN. What I am getting instead is the same volume of spam text messages.
- sillysaurusx 5y agoI’m starting to get those too. From the trump campaign, of all things. Somehow they got ahold of my number and keep asking me to go save America. Not sure which is worse, someone trying to sell me stuff or that. How much volume? Is it a daily annoyance? My wife seems to get hit harder than me, but as far as I can tell we’ve both been equally careless about sharing our number online. So I’m dreading the day that these people figure out how to turn text messages into a gmail spam inbox. It feels like it’s time to just write a Bayesian filter and proxy all text messages through it. It was theoretically easy to do that back when you could send texts just by emailing a special address, but sadly I think carriers ditched that feature. Nowadays I’m not sure where to start if the goal is to proxy our texts like that, but I’d like to.
- BoxOfRain 5y agoIsn't there campaigning laws around that? If a political campaign did that in the UK they'd be raked over the coals by the Electoral Commission. Not that the country's been able to do anything about the sheer volume of scam texts pretending to be the Post Office with a parcel for you or Microsoft telling people their Windows boxes are full of viruses.
- sillysaurusx 5y agoIt’s interesting to hear that the UK has sensible laws about this sort of thing. Over here in Murica we get these: https://imgur.com/a/UjELy2y https://imgur.com/a/UjELy2y My guess is that they’re sending this to all numbers in a certain area code. I’m in Missouri, which was mostly red. So they kindly delivered a MAGA to my phone and I’m like “thanks! … tell me who gave you my number so I can hire a hitman on them please” The political tactics at play are actually quite fascinating to me, because they seem so dumb. But it’s the opposite. In reality it’s effective, and I’ve always wondered why. So it’s interesting to hear that politicians are prohibited from doing this in other countries, and makes me wonder if it’s an effective policy. It seems like it might be. Of course, that doesn’t help rid us of the silagra spammers, but maybe the FCC can come up with a solution that can prohibit both. It feels sort of hopeless, but then I remember that we could literally proxy every text message through our laptops, run them through a 1997 naive Bayesian filter, and eliminate 97% of the problem with 0.03% false positives. It seems like a matter of time till some service comes along and makes that schlep effortless, and I can just pay $5/mo for the privilege of dodging spammers.
- IncRnd 5y agoSTIR/SHAKEN are only for VOIP calls not for text messages like shown in the article.
- flatiron 5y agoAnd as far as blaming the carrier if a call comes in with a B or higher rating it’s going to present the number as legit. That’s not the carriers fault!
- simfree 5y agoWhat carriers are willing to show Caller Verified when receiving a B level attestation? From my testing Verizon and T-Mobile require A level attestations.
- pards 5y agoSTIR/SHAKEN also covers Canada [1] but it's a neutered law with little impact since it only covers VOIP calls, not SMS or traditional landline calls. I guess I should drop my old skool Bell Canada landline in favour of a VOIP line... [1] https://www.canada.ca/en/radio-television-telecommunications/news/2019/12/joint-statement-by-ian-scott-chairperson-and-ceo-of-the-crtc-and-ajit-pai-chairman-of-the-fcc-on-the-first-official-cross-border-call-using-stirsha.html https://www.canada.ca/en/radio-television-telecommunications...
- julianlam 5y agoI ended up using VoIP for both my cellular and landline connections. I would recommend it for the latter, but not the former. When WiFi and 3G signals are thrown into the mix, real-time communications go south fast... To STIR/SHAKEN's credit, however, the only spam calls I've received go to the cellular number assigned to the SIM card I have that is purely for data (so I can make those VoIP calls outside of home wifi range)
- doctorshady 5y agoAgreed. VoLTE is VoIP anyway, so there's not a lot of drawbacks relative to changing out a circuit switched landline. I believe at least in the US as well, STIR/Shaken is being implemented on circuit switched networks.
- ehPReth 5y agoHow do we protect SMS? I’m kind of confused but I understand I guess why it wasn’t also addressed in the initial rollout… does STIR/SHAKEN even allow for SMS authentication? I guess you could keep your phone number by porting it and get the call spoof protection?
- bogomipz 5y ago>'The"STIR/SHAKEN initiative" was supposed to fix this.' This was only for voice calls not SMS. From a FAQ On Neustar's(SS7 provider) site: >"5. Does STIR/SHAKEN apply to SMS/text messaging? Currently STIR/ SHAKEN applies to phone calls only. However, work is on-going in the communications industry to evaluate the best authentication method for SMS / text messaging."[1] It's unclear as to my why it does not currently cover SMS. Perhaps someone else could shed some light on why this is. SMS certainly uses the same SS7 infrastructure as voice calls. [1] https://www.home.neustar/resources/faqs/stir-shaken-for-businesses https://www.home.neustar/resources/faqs/stir-shaken-for-busi...
- zbentley 5y ago> There are "A", "B", and "C" level of verification. "A" calls are probably legit. The others, maybe not. TIL. I know that makers of phone/texting apps are primarily targeting users who don't know or care about this kind of stuff, but man it would be awesome if that kind of info were available whenever an inbound call or text arrived on my phone. Just like email headers, I'd love to be able to see the raw authentication grade and other metadata.