3 ms·
Probably going to get downvoted for this... We have too many people and nobody is willing to do things that dramatically reduce the quality of life that are ne
by giantg2 5y ago
Probably going to get downvoted for this...
We have too many people and nobody is willing to do things that dramatically reduce the quality of life that are necessary to sustainably support ourselves.
- thehappypm 5y agoI don’t think we quite have too many people in America. The USA could easily sustain a population the size of China. We’re not even close.
- vondur 5y agoIn California? I’d agree with you. The state really hasn’t upgraded the infrastructure since the 70’s. We’ve probably tripled the population since then.
- giantg2 5y agoNot just there. The aquifers under the plains are also almost drained. A lot of that is not for those local people, but for food production for people nationally and internationally.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoTake a look at Phoenix. Way more than tripled, and now uses less water for residential purposes that it did in the 1990s. Your assumptions that people living somewhere are the main users of water is way, way out of touch with the reality: the main user is agriculture. In my state, NM, residential use is 7%, commercial/retail/business is 7%, evaporation is 7% and agriculture is 77%.
- m0llusk 5y agoPerhaps true, but not closely related. The vast amount of water being used goes to agriculture and industry and not supporting the population.
- giantg2 5y agoWho do you think uses agricultural and industrial products? People
- m0llusk 5y agoMost of those products are sold outside the state, so that leads to the problem of making the California water system capable of indirectly supporting large segments of the national and global population. It isn't clear that is what people really want nor that such a system would even be possible.
- bobsmooth 5y agoI'd respect this position more if its proponents were willing to practice what they preach.
- giantg2 5y agoLike what exactly? Much of this requires large scale policies. Without those, the lowering of demand lowers prices and allows others to increase their consumption. The vast majority people aren't going to voluntarily reduce their quality of living. Thus it will likely happen when the resources are expended and it's too late.
- Ericson2314 5y agoDo you drive? You can move to a place where you don't need to. Do you take airplanes? Why?
- Ericson2314 5y agoFocusing on mass politics and not individual choices is good but > We have too many people is the tagling of rich suburban Malthusians who don't believe in any of that. So if that is not you, best not to tarnish yourself with that phrase. Population is not that big a deal because if current trends continue and we don't boil the planet first, the population is on track to peak and then decline. > dramatically reduce the quality of life I would argue suburban life in fact sucks terribly, and walking + biking + trains is a far superior way of life. So I don't like this "sacrifice" framing at all. Yes, changing the material basis of society will be a culture shock and upsetting to some, but in no way need the replacement be "worse" on the whole. If we do everything else and then really miss more inter-continental travel, let's build a goddamn multi-track railway across the bearing Bering Strait. There's no reason we cannot afford it!
- giantg2 5y agoThe first thing to do is establish how many people the world can sustainably support. I haven't seen any numbers about that. All the estimates include industrial practices and many include assumptions that we will have technological breakthroughs. The support estimates range from about 9-12 billion, with peak population estimated around 11.5 billion. Still no mention of sustainable numbers. It seems you're using Malthusians as an insult without going into what is wrong with the general concept that population increases could outpace resource availability, especially given that resources are constrained. I wouldn't say I'm a strict believer in Malthusian theory. But some of it is looking likely when you see many of the fish species we eat have declined by 90% or more, aquifers are at risk in the next 30 years, arable land is being lost, etc. You focused on transportation, which is something, but not really about how many people the earth can support. Most people rarely fly, so I see that as mostly a moot point to most individuals (potential for a policy change). Trains could be a great replacement option - but again, something that requires massive infrastructure changes to be feasible. Could I move to a place that would require little to no driving, yet it would require giving up more than just driving. I wouldn't be able to participate in various hobbies, I'd have to quit my job, and worst of all live in a dirty crime ridden city (yeah yeah, over the top but some truth to it here in the US if we're talking about big enough cities to accommodate a large number of my interests without needing to drive. What we're really talking about is food and water, and somewhat of other constrained natural resources (metals for EVs/batteries, lumber, etc). In the case of water, we are depleting many aquifers around. This will eventually require lifestyle changes like rationing water, collecting rain water, no lawns, etc. And it could mean a reduction in crop output while populations are near their peak. For food, do we do away with foods that require a lot of water, processing, or land? Do we eliminate meat and stop fishing the oceans? These are huge lifestyle changes.
- wintermutestwin 5y agoby "too many people" do you mean using residential water? It is a small fraction of CA's water use. I am all for sustainability, not having lawns in the desert, etc, but agriculture is the first place to look in CA.
- giantg2 5y agoNot just there. The aquifers under the plains are also almost drained. A lot of that is not for those local people, but for food production for people nationally and internationally.
- tormock 5y agoI wonder how much water the largest mono-crop field in the world uses... it is in California and it is almonds.
- nitwit005 5y agoIt's not really a "too many people" issue, given that a lot of the water is going toward things like grapes and almonds.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoAnd the ocean and fishes
- giantg2 5y ago... Why do we grow those? Do people eat them by chance?
- nitwit005 5y agoSure, but the consumption of luxury food products is only loosely related to the population size.
- giantg2 5y agoThat's only true if we have authoritarian policies to forbid luxury food. That would be one of the huge lifestyle changes I imagine. Otherwise, the wealthy countries will continue to eat those foods while less wealthy countries can't find or afford adequate food. But... what is the number of people we can sustainably feed with non-luxury food? Can we indefinitely support 8 billion people? I haven't seen any good answers that speak to the sustainably, or look into the geopolitical feasibility of forced diet changes.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- refurb 5y agoSeems like a problem that solves itself?