6 ms·
The British Empire Was Much Worse Than You Realize
- rramadass 5y agoRelevant: Empire in Asia, How we came by it: A Book of Confessions by W. M. Torrens. - https://archive.org/details/empireinasiahoww00mccuuoft/page/n5/mode/2up https://archive.org/details/empireinasiahoww00mccuuoft/page/... Perfidious Albion doesn't begin to describe it. - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfidious_Albion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfidious_Albion
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Stevvo 5y agoI remember my friend laughing at protesters in Hong Kong waving the British flag; they had experienced more democracy under Chinese rule than they ever had under the British.
- hnfong 5y agoIt's a complicated topic. When Britain took over Hong Kong, it was a small town with maybe a couple thousand inhabitants. The vast majority of Hong Kong people are immigrants (or their descendants). They knew what they were getting when they voluntarily entered British territory. In a sense this situation fits the Hobbes narrative perfectly -- British subjects in Hong Kong voluntarily chose to live with the government and accept the social contract in order to escape the harshness of the situation in China, which at many times in the past century was "poor, nasty, brutish, and short". And as thus despite the various faults with British rule, in general it did rule with the people's consent as people continued immigrating from mainland China. It doesn't really necessarily speak to good governance on the part of the Brits than the self-selection of pro-British people. Of course the other reasons in this thread are valid as well. It's a complicated topic.
- arcticbull 5y agoImportantly, that was because of the PRC not because of the Brits. The Brits had long sought to increase democratic freedoms in Hong Kong however the Chinese flatly refused to permit it in anticipation of the handover. This began shortly before the Cultural Revolution, actually, in the 50s. I'm not saying the sentiment is wrong per se, but Hong Kong is a bad example. [1] Liao Chengzhi, a senior Chinese official in charge of Hong Kong affairs, said in 1960 that China "shall not hesitate to take positive action to have Hong Kong, Kowloon and New Territories liberated" [by the People's Liberation Army] should the status quo (i.e. colonial administration) be changed. The warning killed any democratic development for the next three decades. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_development_in_Hong_Kong#1990s_until_the_handover https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_development_in_Hong...
- bllguo 5y ago1950s: >Grantham convinced London to scrap all plans for political reform on the basis that it did not "interest the British electorate". Later, when confronted by the Hong Kong public, he blamed London. 1980s: >British Foreign Secretary Geoffrey Howe further promised the democratic process would start "in the years immediately ahead", but they stalled due to opposition from Beijing, local business interests as represented by Executive Council, and the British Foreign Office under the pretext that it would bring chaos to Hong Kong. Not nearly as simple as you are portraying it either..
- arcticbull 5y agoYou are definitely correct. However, in the 90s: ... in 1992, Chris Patten the new governor of Hong Kong, began moves to unilaterally democratise the territory by allowing for the election of half the Legislative Council by universal suffrage, and in the process incurring the wrath of the People's Republic of China (PRC). Patten had judged that: "People in Hong Kong are perfectly capable of taking a greater share in managing their own affairs in a way that is responsible, mature, restrained, sensible" [edit] If I had to speculate I'd say the 50s were primarily due to the aftermath of WWII and reconstruction in Europe and that PRC influence was basically all of the subsequent reluctance. After all, the UK was already taking steps to divest itself of the colonies at that point and had little interest in maintaining Hong Kong one way or the other. Was Hong Kong not to be a halo territory for democracy in the region? Given the state of freedom in Hong Kong vs the PRC one could take the position that substantially all the 'western' freedoms enjoyed in Hong Kong are in fact enjoyed thanks to the British.
- Incerto 5y ago
- hhs 5y agoThis is a review of the book “Legacy of Violence” by Caroline Elkins [0], which came out a few days ago in the UK and will be released tomorrow in the US. [0]: https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/45877/legacy-of-violence-by-caroline-elkins/ https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/45877/legacy-of-vio...
- Incerto 5y ago
- SAShithole 5y ago[flagged]
- greendude29 5y agoLord, what a bad take. The ends does not justify the means, ever.
- FpUser 5y ago>"If you work in tech, and live in the UK / USA / Canada / Aus, then you literally owe everything to the Empire." This is true. And the rest of the world can enjoy the consequences of having been raped.
- AnimalMuppet 5y ago> If you work in tech, and live in the UK / USA / Canada / Aus, then you literally owe everything to the Empire. Um, what? First of all, 1776 was 246 years ago. Saying that we owe it all to them implies that we get zero credit for what we've done since then. Second, when the US left the British Empire, was the US more democratic, or less? It was more. The US revolted in favor of more democracy (among other things); attributing all the democracy we have to the British Empire is rather a distorted perspective. Third: Why single out those who work in tech? We didn't derive much of our tech from the British Empire. Sure, they kind of got us started (including in computers). That was decades ago, though (the crossover was probably around the time of Univac I). Not giving any credit to the US invention of the transistor, and the chip, and the CPU chip? Again, that seems like quite a distorted view of history.
- kwatsonafter 5y agoYeah, the continuity of institutions like chattel slavery and the divine right of kings applied to global expansion including but not limited to the brutal subjugation of India for 200 years. I'm genuinely curious as to how you can come to the conclusion that British expansion promoted democracy. I did a Google search and was able to find reference to a body of literature that seems to suppose that there is correlation between long term survival for post-colonial democracies and the time a colony had spent being rule over by the British. One paper (below) seems to tie democratic elections as being a necessary qualifier for post-colonial independence but that makes sense from a Pinko standpoint-- former colonies which formerly could be dominated through sheer political and military force may be freed from a, "formal" perspective but, "free elections" and the liberalization of the real economy (globalization) creates a new opportunity for global centers of wealth and influence to dominate developing nations without the need to mobilize the political system or military thereby side-stepping the need to garner or manufacturer consent from the public. Now where exactly do we get a historical pretext for global exceptionality? This is the promotion of, "democracy?" It seems like this is basis of all the nasty things in the world that stifle real self-determination. I now that it's fun to play edge-lord when you feel like no one else has done the reading (believe me I get it) but these simple, "good guy vs bad guy but plot twist the bad guy is actually good" and its reversal amongst people on the left just reeks of a kind of intellectual snobbery which typifies those that are insecure about what they actually know. As an insecure jackass myself I would know. Cheers. rochester.edu/college/faculty/alexander_lee/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/Lee-and-Paine-Britain-and-democracy.pdf
- tomohawk 5y agoFor thousands of years, slavery was ubiquitous. Empire after empire embraced it and used it. The British Empire, like those before it, profited from slavery. Then, they virtually extinguished it. Their navy was used to stop the slave trade on the seas. It was outlawed in lands controlled by the Empire. Piratical nations who conducted enslavement raids were supressed. It took decades and multiple reforms, but the picture of slavery before the British Empire and after are radically different.
- csb6 5y agoSure the British Navy helped enforce an end to the Trans-Atlantic slave trade (slavery, of course, continued for many decades longer on a massive scale in the U.S. and Brazil, among others), but the slave trade is just one of the many crimes against humanity that the British Empire committed. Especially when the result of ending slavery was largely the continued use of colonial subjects as cheap, disposable labor, with poverty, mass famine, and violent repression by British forces continuing. The British Empire as a project was inherently a massive resource extraction operation. Slavery was just one method to accomplish this goal, and one that they greatly expanded, developed, and promoted before it became economically advantageous for them to phase out. So I don't think they should get any credit for stopping slave traders.
- esyir 5y agoI've always found the lack of context on slavery's history amusing. In our time, it's considered one of the greatest sins. However, if you look just a bit back, it wasn't exclusive to the English-American line, as the twitter take goes, but was was commonplace across human history. Where you found people, you found slavery. If (and mind you I mean if), the OP here is correct that the British empire had a sizable impact on ending slavery, then they deserve that credit regardless. If they didn't, the that's a far stronger argument to be made.
- csb6 5y ago> In our time, it's considered one of the greatest sins. However, if you look just a bit back, it wasn't exclusive to the English-American line, as the twitter take goes, but was was commonplace across human history. Where you found people, you found slavery. Wherever there is slavery, you will also find many people opposed to slavery (e.g. the slaves themselves). The idea of liberating slaves is not new; just look back at Spartacus's revolt, for instance, which was not the only slave revolt in Roman history. People knew it was a brutal institution - they were simply conditioned to believe it was a natural part of life, and the slaveholding classes benefited economically from the practice. Of course slavery is a widespread practice in human history. That makes it more horrific, not less. The fact that the British Empire greatly expanded and commercialized the practice reflects pretty badly on them, IMO. > If (and mind you I mean if), the OP here is correct that the British empire had a sizable impact on ending slavery, then they deserve that credit regardless. I think it is debatable that they had a sizable impact on the end of slavery itself. They definitely did have a big impact in the end of the Atlantic Slave Trade, which, keep in mind, they helped create and massively expand for over a century (at least) prior. Can you really give someone credit for ending a horrific practice they promoted/expanded on such a large, intentional scale? This seems like less than the bare minimum to me. Slavery continued to thrive for many decades in the U.S. and Brazil, among other places. Britain had no qualms in trading with the Confederacy, for instance, a nation explicitly founded on slavery. Nor did it have problems with the tremendous death rates and horrible working conditions of "freed" blacks in their Caribbean colonies.
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoAlways find it amusing liberals think this is some kinda gotcha. We did the imperialist thing and exploited the fuck out of other countries: that is win one. Then a hundred years later we feel bad about about it in order to feel morally superior and pat ourselves on the back: win two. In 2022 who are still running this planet? Jamaica? India?