5 ms·
Here's what I'll say: it's perfectly understandable to fear nuclear power. Radiation ticks all of the ultimate boxes for psychological terror: it's deadly, invi
by woodruffw 5y ago
Here's what I'll say: it's perfectly understandable to fear nuclear power. Radiation ticks all of the ultimate boxes for psychological terror: it's deadly, invisible, undetectable with human senses, and abstruse (unlike burning oil or coal).
Fear is of these things is natural, but it needs to be moderated. Specifically, it needs to be moderated against the actual danger of nuclear power plants, which is astonishingly small: the number of direct victims of nuclear power accidents is under 100, and the number of indirect victims is similarly small. This is in contrast to coal- and oil-fired power plants, which directly contribute to the deaths of over 100,000 people in India alone[1].
Nuclear power is, on face value, very scary. But it's a lot less scary than just about everything else (modulo wind and solar power) we do to generate electricity, and has far better human and environmental outcomes even in its worst cases (Chernobyl).
[1]: https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2017936118 https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2017936118
- hardolaf 5y ago> wind and solar power More people die yearly from wind and solar power during manufacturing and installation than have died directly due to nuclear energy in its entire history as a power source. And yes, those direct numbers for nuclear include the entire supply chain for it if you weren't aware.
- baby 5y agovideo with sources: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DnTzsWM_gbQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DnTzsWM_gbQ
- croes 5y agoBut we would build more power plants, this would mean more construction related deaths.
- woodruffw 5y agoThat's a good point. I hadn't realized the nuclear numbers included the supply chain; I thought it was just operational fatalities. It would be interesting to see whether the number of deaths in wind and solar manufacturing are higher or lower than similar heavy industries and operations (e.g. linemanning, heavy fabrication). In any case, it all pales compared to the death and diminished quality of life that we just accept with coal and oil burning.
- hardolaf 5y agoYeah, they always include the full supply chain for nuclear to make it appear believable but they don't do the same thing for anything else. Heck, some people include the bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki in the numbers too just to make the comparison more "fair" to every other power source in the world. By the way, that barely moves the numbers for nuclear. We don't do that for any other power source. The closest we get is installation deaths for solar and wind. But we still ignore all of the supply chain deaths for both. All that said, literally anything is better and safer than burning dinosaurs or biomatter. And the future really does need to be a mix of nuclear and geothermal (where available) for baseload demand with wind and solar combined with non-battery storage for peak demand smoothing.
- tomatowurst 5y agoagain the parent and my concern is that Japan is a whole new ball park in terms of earthquakes and none of the examples you cite here is relevant in addressing the seismological risks that is unique to Japan. Just have a look at the historical earthquake diagram from the official Japanese Meteorlogical Agency and compare it to its neighbor, the difference is night and day and so is the obvious risks...
- sosborn 5y agoJapan has had 50-ish reactors online for quite a while, and the only issue they experienced was Fukushima, which should have been avoided: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_nuclear_disaster#Prior_safety_concerns https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_nuclear_disaster#Pri...
- Loughla 5y agoI'm not sure the argument you're trying to make is as impactful as what you think it is. It should have been avoided, and wasn't. How does that make anyone feel more secure that other plants will be any safer at all? I argue that it does not. If anything, that statement only solidifies the other posts in this thread who talk about businesses focus on short term metrics and profit margins calling all safety into question.
- sosborn 5y agoAre you saying that it is impossible to learn from mistakes?
- agumonkey 5y agoI'm personally more worried about current management practices (short term and absurd metric oriented) that would not be up to the risk involved.