3 ms·
I have faith the services that aren't able to understand maximum length, exclusions, and character requirements are a failure of their security design will succ
by zamadatix 5y ago
I have faith the services that aren't able to understand maximum length, exclusions, and character requirements are a failure of their security design will succeede in mucking up any solution to not work as simply as it should.
- tialaramex 5y agoHalf of the reason for the "requirements" list is people telling them about how poor passwords are, and they should try to get people to pick better ones. In WebAuthn: The relying party doesn't get to pick any of the security parameters The other half is their backend systems not being able to cope with sensible things and so they picked whatever was easier. In WebAuthn, again, the relying party doesn't get to pick any of the security parameters. Lots of bad practices that happen for passwords don't survive implementation in WebAuthn. It's the same philosophy as to why I preferred writing plain Java over Python - "You can't do that, it doesn't compile" beats, "Oops, the job ran to completion overnight, but the output phase tried to multiply an empty string with an array and so it failed at that point". For example, hey, users know this is Awesome Site, so, no problem asking for their awesome.example password on our new betteryet.example site, right? You know the Big Boss is going to insist on that. With passwords most users won't notice (which is why they get phished) and if you're the sort of person who does notice now you need to tell your password manager that yeah, this password must be entered on betteryet.example as well as awesome.example. In WebAuthn that can't work. Not "You need some fancy Javascript". Not "Tell the user to press the Destroy Security Please" button, nothing like that, it just can't work. WebAuthn knows this is betteryet.example so, it can only have betteryet.example credentials, there is no backdoor, no override, too bad, if you're really awesome.example you should have people log in to awesome.example. The big boss can rage and scream and threaten and it won't make any difference, it's just a fact, like that time they were sure nine was more than fourteen and it isn't.