3 ms·
There really needs to be an intersection between law and science/reason, just a few solid touchpoints. There need to be statutes that define a logical basis fo
by sneak 5y ago
There really needs to be an intersection between law and science/reason, just a few solid touchpoints. There need to be statutes that define a logical basis for what we do and do not, as a society with a legal system, believe to be true.
It really feels like the American society (now including the courts apparently) is losing its relationship with objective reality and any semblance of a shared set of ground truth facts. Things have been trending that way for a long while, but it really feels like the Orwellian knob has been jacked up an order of magnitude in the last 24 months.
If we can't agree on some basic rules about what is or is not true about fundamental reality, why even bother having courts or trials to determine higher level truths? A trial about the outcomes of magical/nonsensical processes is meaningless.
This stuff obviously shouldn't make it into the courtroom. The fact that it has means the system is broken, even if these particular people stop peddling this particular bullshit.
- zorked 5y agoNot a recent thing, if anything things are getting better over time, just slowly. I remember reading stuff about how "forensic science" has been the realm of quackery for as long as I have known how to read. Police are incentivised to find whatever thingamajig will support their conclusions. Courts are not equipped to provide meta-review of every forensic claim. And for the bright, rational, scientific minds out there, working in forensics is relatively low-prestige and low-pay.
- JackFr 5y agoThe fact that this was ever used in a courtroom is disturbing, but before we start collectively clutching our pearls, remember that authors are selling clicks, and it us the nature of articles like these to overstate the problem. I am less concerned by the obvious nonsense like this, than I am about the far more dangerous nonsense that comes from legit, credentialed, FBI-endorsed “scientists” which a rational, informed, well intentioned judge or juror might give serious weight, (like bite marks, blood splatter, profiling, etc.)
- NateEag 5y ago> There need to be statutes that define a logical basis for what we do and do not, as a society with a legal system, believe to be true. Laws don't define that, though. Wanting everyone to approach the world with a scientific, evidence-based mindset doesn't mean they do. We can't legislate belief any more than we can legislate the value of pi.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y ago> It really feels like the American society (now including the courts apparently) is losing its relationship with objective reality and any semblance of a shared set of ground truth facts. Actually in this particular case things are getting better because less and less shit is getting through into the court without reporting and scrutiny, due to the efforts of media and groups like the Innocence Project. Bite mark analysis, hair comparison, blood splatter analysis, lie detector testing, even breathalyzers are getting their due scrutiny and criticism where they haven’t been in the past.
- BoxOfRain 5y ago>Things have been trending that way for a long while, but it really feels like the Orwellian knob has been jacked up an order of magnitude in the last 24 months. Governments having much of a relationship with objective reality at all is a fairly new phenomenon and very much a product of the Enlightenment. It wasn't too long ago that court astrologers and politicised clergy were intimately involved in decisions that effected the lives of hundreds of thousands if not millions of people. What we're seeing is the erosion of Enlightenment rationalism into what we had before, the state saying 2 + 2 = 5 when it's convenient and browbeating anyone who points out how ridiculous they're being. >If we can't agree on some basic rules about what is or is not true about fundamental reality, why even bother having courts or trials to determine higher level truths? I'm sure this exact question went through the mind of Galileo Galilei when he was forced to recant his heliocentric views. Objective reality doesn't care about society's power structures, so society's power structures return the favour.
- sneak 5y agoI can only speak to the few decades I have been watching. I understand things improved a tremendous amount before I was born. I think the general trend is one of big improvement, but things are definitely worse now in this regard than they were 2 or 10 years ago.