3 ms·
It's hard read these stories and not wonder about the parents. At the same time I'm often drawn to the story of my high school buddy's youngest sister. His fa
by duxup 5y ago
It's hard read these stories and not wonder about the parents.
At the same time I'm often drawn to the story of my high school buddy's youngest sister. His family was as normal as you might expect, the kids were perhaps unusually "driven", but in good ways, music, athletics, academics, all three even.
But the youngest was driven to rebel in the most distributive ways possible, the usual running away from home, older / inappropriate men, drugs, alcohol. Everything short of physical violence, although that occurred too.
It got so bad it was almost impossible to physically keep her in the house or apply any kind of rules. Any rule was just a goal for her to obliterate and more.
The parents eventually sent her to some of these camps, she escaped, was notorious even among other troubled kids there.
It all took an incredible toll on her parents. Financial and psychological. They would have done anything to help her, anything, so at times they chose those camps, even if it seemed just to provide physical safety.
Eventually she turned 18 and left. Some contact here and there, she seemed to want the contact but also was aloof in a way. It seemed like she really kept in contact to keep up with the family dog more than anyone there.
Years later in her early 20s she showed up at the family house unannounced. She was pregnant, her mom answered the door and she asked if she could come home.
I don't know what happened between 18 and showing up that day, but after that day she was "back" and was a different girl. She worked for the family business for a while but she quit saying it wasn't for her. She took some college classes but didn't like school and the rules.
She eventually took a job at a pet store grooming pets and loved it. She started doing it privately and my wife's family financed her buying a truck and remodeling it into a mobile pet grooming van (this was really early in the days before mobile pet grooming was "a thing").
Eventually the previously very troubled girl had keys to any number of houses in town (so she could pickup the pets while the owners were away) and she has been great since, kids, family, met a great guy. She's a model local small business person, mom, etc.
I often want to ask her what changed, but I feel like mentioning it would reinforce a "troubled girl" label that I'm sure she knows some folks still think of her as.
As a parent now I think on that other girl. It's unsettling to think of. These kind of camps are disturbing, but in some cases ... I get it when you feel like you're out of options. There are kids who misbehave, and there's situations that are orders of magnitude beyond that.
- wolverine876 5y agoWhen I was growing up I knew a boy who suddenly, around 12 years old, in an otherwise healthy-seeming family, began behaving badly - violence, drugs, flunking out of school, etc. Many years later, he told me the turning point: He was raped and felt he couldn't tell his parents (I don't know who assaulted him). Maybe a/the question to ask is not how the girl recovered, but why it started.
- shitshowmcgee 5y agoI know this branch in the thread is purely speculative - but it sounds awfully familiar to me as well. Dated a woman in college who fits that profile in every including being sent off to firms like TFA - it was rooted in a decade of rape by her older brother. Her mother fell into that “we don’t talk about such things” type of profile and so it was left to fester despite being addressed.
- kingcharles 5y agoIt seems like these places have nailed the brainwashing of the parents. Most of these parents seem like normal, rational human beings that are basically getting the cult treatment and ending up drinking the whole glass of Kool-Aid.
- kaydub 5y agoI was a bad kid. Nothing really changed. Kids are uncivilized people. They just grow up at different rates.
- scaramanga 5y agoWell, sometimes families can be, internally, incredibly abusive while presenting a very convincing image of being loving and caring, even "perfect in every way" to an outsider. If you go to places where survivors of narcissistic or familial abuse congregate it's not uncommon to hear stories of people saying of an abusive parent things like "all my friends used to say 'i wish my mum was like your mum'" and what not. It can be very hard to escape from such situations, sometimes people who seem to have escaped, later voluntarily return to them. Sometimes, when even heinous abuse becomes exposed, the victims will protect the abusers. Narcissistic families excel at keeping secrets. You have to realise that children have genetic wiring for survival. If their parents are neglectful or abusive, the child cannot simply go on to the free market to shop for a replacement. Rather, they are much more likely to become increasingly compliant, in order to extract as much care as possible from the defective parent. Mild forms of this can involve the child performing very well at school, or in sports, once they realise that love is contingent on performance. Children who feel invisible might act out because negative attention is perceived, perversely, as a workable substitute for love. Over time, the roles in narcissistic family systems can change around: the golden child can become invisible, or the black sheep, or vice versa. Humans are at the same time as being quite vulnerable to abusive and neglectful environments, also incredibly resilient to them - finding coping strategies which work, even if they can appear to be incredibly destructive, self-destructive, or totally inexplicable to someone lacking the full context. There is a book called "The Narcissistic Family" by Stephanie Donaldson-Pressman which describes the dynamics that can occur in these sorts of family systems.