3 ms·
>Hypothetically, would capping populations of cities and towns be a better way to utilize resources as well as distribute resources so everyone can have a basic
by gruez 5y ago
>Hypothetically, would capping populations of cities and towns be a better way to utilize resources as well as distribute resources so everyone can have a basic quality of life?
Isn't that what many cities in the US are doing with their zoning laws? The "cap" is being enforced by the number of housing units that's available (although not perfectly), and the result is that the housing units available are rented/sold to the highest bidder. Whether that resulted in "everyone can have a basic quality of life" is... doubtful.
- giantg2 5y agoI assume they mean to cap it so that we don't see that fierce competition. We may be zoning to reduce the increase in housing, but there aren't any limits on number of jobs in that locale (which is largely what draws people in the first place, for many cities). Ie, zoning addresses a symptom and not a cause. Redistributing the jobs to cities where populations have shrunk could be a more efficient system (as mentioned, politically untenable).
- gruez 5y ago>I assume they mean to cap it so that we don't see that fierce competition Sounds like internal passports[1] to me. The article does not paint a pretty picture of its consequences. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internal_passport https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internal_passport
- giantg2 5y agoNah, you don't restrict the people, you restrict the businesses. There's no reason people should want to go to SV to start up a company or to work for one of the big name (they do have other offices). It's that mentality that snowballs and causes problems.