2 ms·
> Putin's invasion of Ukraine quickly shut that window. With the Germans now re-orientating their energy dependency from Russia to the US, as well as committing
by wolverine876 5y ago
> Putin's invasion of Ukraine quickly shut that window. With the Germans now re-orientating their energy dependency from Russia to the US, as well as committing to buying billions of dollars worth of US military hardware, there is no chance of any 'EU led third way'
I think that's backward: European defense independence was limited by funding; they talked about it but didn't invest in it. The Russian attack on Ukraine spurred Germany especially to fund defense; to think of the possibilities, Germany's GDP is about $4.2 trillion, Russia's is only $1.6 trillion [0]. Germany's military alone could easily far oustrip Russia's[1]. Germany's economy is 4th largest in the world, meaning they could build the 4th largest military - beyond a doubt they have the political, technological, and industrial capability. Add to that France, Italy, etc: The EU's total GDP is around $17 trillion.
Autonomy doesn't mean having no external dependencies. Only North Korea tries that intentionally, and you can see the results. Forcing countries like Russia and Iran to have no external dependencies is considered a severe punishment. Dependencies on allies is not only fine, it makes things far more efficient, which means you can afford far more military power and economic influence. Nobody can compete without friends.
[0] To consider the enormous impact of GDP on defense, the US spends the equivalent of 50% of Russia's entire GDP on defense. For comparison, the target number for NATO is 2% of GDP.
[1] Not an idle curiosity: Germany's enormous economy, relative even to Western European countries (the UK's and France's are about $3 trillion), makes Germany an eternal potential geopolitical threat, and is part of the reason for two world wars. That's one of the main original reasons for the EU and NATO - to keep Germany in the fold.