5 ms·
What is the answer to this in a world of scammers, bad actors, etc? Perhaps it should be illegal to ban a user and if a user is truly abusive then sue them in c
by 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y ago
What is the answer to this in a world of scammers, bad actors, etc? Perhaps it should be illegal to ban a user and if a user is truly abusive then sue them in court for damages.
Speaking of suing, why has nobody sued Google or others for this behavior?
- emptyparadise 5y agoGoogle really should have a manual process with actual humans one can interact with when Google accounts that had enough money pass through them are involved.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoI think if users could sue for this sort of thing Google would start doing that because it would be cheaper than fending off lawsuits.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Google really should have a manual process with actual humans one can interact with when Google accounts that had enough money pass through them are involved Flip side of this is compromised accounts, or those doing illegal or dangerous things would run far longer.
- l-lousy 5y agoYou can still suspend an account immediately and wait for someone to appeal before engaging the expensive human support
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoYour account would get suspended, and google would contact you to verify what happened, that your account did whatever it did, and if it was you or someone else doing that. It's not the suspending that's the problem, it's the inability to find out why it was suspended, and the inability to get someone to reinstate your account.
- cowpig 5y agoOr they could invest in enough humans that it doesn't
- dzhiurgis 5y agoThis. Breaking these companies apart is pointless. Regulate the support experience. These developers are borderline employees.
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y ago
- zackees 5y ago
- MiddleEndian 5y agoGiven the number of legit bad actors, I don't think it's reasonable to make it illegal to ban users. If anything it should be made easier to install programs without a "store" at all. Operating systems worked fine without this concept, and the play store and ios store are functioning as rent-seeking middle men, taking money without offering anything of value in return.
- izacus 5y agoThe same answer that existed in all other industries which do consumer services: proper customer services with humans and strong consumer protection law that stomps on the neck of corporations that abuse people without recourse.
- throwaway684936 5y agoIllegal to ban users? So a neo-nazi account spams, harasses, doxxes hundreds of users and spreads gore all over your platform, and you aren't allowed to shut them down unless you go through the court system first? This is one of the most absurd ideas I've ever heard.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoHarassment is against the law. Maybe your platform shouldn't allow such abuse? They can fix their platform so this isn't possible without banning anybody. I'm just brainstorming here.
- shadowgovt 5y ago> They can fix their platform so this isn't possible without banning anybody. How? You can't preemptively determine the output of a Turing-complete program without solving the halting problem, so while Google will always try to do their damnedest to predict a bad actor before they get to the store, they will definitely always fail to find some. If they can't ban them when they find them, what should the alternative be?
- wheresmycraisin 5y agoDon't allow free-form communication and ban toxic users. That's what nintendo does.
- andybak 5y ago> Maybe your platform shouldn't allow such abuse? They can fix their platform so this isn't possible without banning anybody. This feels more like handwaving than brainstorming ;-) It's a tricky problem and I think your suggestions should try and reflect that as much as possible.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoAre all platforms equally abusable?
- syshum 5y agoWe already have the answer. We do not really need new laws, or regulation We need enforcement of contract law (and maybe a prohibition on binding arbitration which would be a new law) However today these "Terms of service" are not really treated like a normal contract, in a few ways One most of them are massively one sided, which should make them unenforceable and disallowed. Also standard contracts most of the time require notification of specific violations with documentation of the violation that triggers termination of the contract, not these vague assertions that with no documentation of the violation. Also for the most part contracts do not allow these open ended catch all type of provisions most Terms of service have, there are exceptions of course but it seems to have enacted a completely different level of provisions for these "terms of service" agreements that would not be permitted in other contexts of contract law
- rndgermandude 5y agoI would be in favor of legislation which allows for bans, but makes it harder to (not impossible) do so for the large companies. The EU's DMA (Digital Markets Act) defines "Gatekeepers", which is an OK definition of what could count as "large" in this context. Large companies shouldn't be able to get away with banning people without good reason, documenting and stating that good reason, and have a reasonable and "real" appeals process, with courts being the last step of the process if needed. Want to ban that person harassing others? Sure thing, document the harassment, clearly spell out in your account termination email that harassment was the reason (and what even constitutes harassment), offer that appeals process. Document the decision and evidence, in case an independent mediator (like a court) asks for it. Don't just vaguely point to some 70-page "Community Standards" document, and have bots auto-respond with "Denied" emails to appeals. As the German constitution law (Grundgesetz) spells out: "Eigentum verpflichtet. Sein Gebrauch soll zugleich dem Wohle der Allgemeinheit dienen." ("Property obliges. Its use should also serve the public good."). I think that's a good approach to property.
- pdonis 5y ago> Large companies shouldn't be able to get away with banning people without good reason Why not? I understand that a lot of people don't like this behavior, but why should it be illegal? The law is a very blunt instrument, and government is already far too intrusive into every aspect of people's lives. The fact that you see a problem does not mean the law/government can fix it. Consider the law/government version of the old programmer's joke about regular expressions: Some people, whenever they have a problem with behavior they don't like, think: Let's get the law/government to solve it! Now they have two problems.
- rndgermandude 5y ago>Why not? I understand that a lot of people don't like this behavior, but why should it be illegal? Because these large companies are basically utility companies in my humble opinion, and wield a whole lot of power over people's lives and livelihoods. There are basically defacto monopolies in their respective spaces. This power and influence shouldn't go entirely unchecked. Same as we (try to) regulate other industries, often even players that are far "smaller" than the internet behemoths. Which brings me back to Eigentum verpflichtet. >The law is a very blunt instrument, and government is already far too intrusive into every aspect of people's lives. I see this argument a lot. First of all, we're not even talking about regulating people, we talk about regulating companies worth billions and sometimes even trillions, so I am a little less concerned about being "intrusive" there. And then, the law is quite often rather blunt, agreed, but it doesn't have to be that blunt. Google's or Meta's "Community Standards" at the same time seem to be rather blunt as well, and the enforcement deliberately arbitrary. >Some people, whenever they have a problem with behavior they don't like, think: Let's get the law/government to solve it! Now they have two problems. At the least with the law/government[0], we have a theoretical control (through voting), theoretical checks and balances (through separation of power) and a theoretical way to have input into decision making (through activism, lobbying, opposition parties). We do not have any of that when it comes to companies. And not everything the government does is always bad. The government is the reason you're drinking a lot less lead in your water, that we do not let regular companies sell heroin solution as cough syrup anymore, or that banks aren't allowed to redline black people anymore (whether enforcement works is another thing), or dump their toxic waste in your backyard. In my parts of the world, the government even made it so that I do not have to fear going bankrupt and homeless when I lose a job or become ill, or that an employer cannot knowingly assign me jobs that will make me ill without even telling me about that risk. Yeah, there are plenty of things the governments did and still do that are not great, or outright bad and/or evil, sometimes because a policy didn't work out the way it was expected and lead to bad outcomes, sometimes because a policy had exactly the indented outcome. And it usually takes quite some effort and time to change that. At the same time, there are plenty of bad things large companies did and are still doing, more often than not to maximize profits, or at least for power and influence, and the only real incentives we have to make them stop is market pressure (i.e. boycotts or protests, which hardly ever work) or regulation (which works quite well, but can have the side effect of regulatory capture). Take the instrument of regulation away, because it's too blunt, or the government cannot be trusted, or whatever, and we'll end up (again[1]) with a bunch of companies that are defacto governments - but of the dictatorial variety. To me, the solution neither is no regulation nor always regulation, but finding a good balance of what and what not to regulate, and how to regulate. The power balance between those large internet companies and their users/customers/subcontractors and "gig workers"[2] is skewed very heavily in favor of the large companies and thus I think could use some unskewing by regulatory measures. [0] When I keep talking about government(s) here, I mean our democratic governments. [1] The East India Company, for example, while still technically beholden to the Crown, had their own military, and made their own defacto laws in large parts of the world. It took the Indian rebellion, with a toll of close to 1M lives, and the British Government to reign them in. [2] I would consider a lot of the small time app developers to be essentially gig workers, except they write code instead of taxing you around, while a major chunk of the financial and other profits goes to the app stores.
- pdonis 5y ago> why has nobody sued Google or others for this behavior? Because there are no legal grounds for such a suit. Google is providing a service (Google Play developer accounts), and its terms of service clearly state that it can terminate any account whenever it wants. However nasty you might find this behavior in a moral sense, legally Google is perfectly within its rights to operate this way. The only real response any developer can make to this is to not use Google Play to distribute apps. And certainly not to build a business on whose income you and your family will depend on it.