3 ms·
Thanks for the input. A nit, sorry, but maybe relevant to readers learning a little about anti-phishing: homophones sound the same ('-phone' refers to sound, li
by wolverine876 5y ago
Thanks for the input. A nit, sorry, but maybe relevant to readers learning a little about anti-phishing: homophones sound the same ('-phone' refers to sound, like telephone) but differ in meaning, such as 'write' and 'right'. I don't know the term for ycombinator.com / ycornbinator.com, which is a real problem, of course.
- chrismarlow9 5y agoIt's a homoglyph https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homoglyph https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homoglyph Typically used via poorly named idn homograph attacks https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/IDN_homograph_attack https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/IDN_homograph_attack
- thaumasiotes 5y agoTechnically ycornbinator.com is just a lookalike. Homographs look exactly the same. (And of course "homograph" ["same writing" or "same picture"] is a better name than "homoglyph" ["same carving"].)
- chrismarlow9 5y agoThat's fair I'm not really one for jargon and whatnot (I think it can actually become less useful if the goal is just to communicate something to a person), but the first line in wiki says: > a homoglyph is one of two or more graphemes, characters, or glyphs with shapes that appear identical or very similar. "Very similar" and "two or more" being the key words. As for homograph I found homoglyph by reading the wiki and it saying homoglyph is more appropriate. (Insert obligatory "wiki it's not always accurate etc etc"). Overall I'd take either one and personally don't care. Just trying to match what you're saying with what I'm reading and make sense of where the truth is.
- wolverine876 5y ago> (Insert obligatory "wiki it's not always accurate etc etc"). Overall I'd take either one and personally don't care. Just trying to match what you're saying with what I'm reading and make sense of where the truth is. Diving in (even if the parent doesn't care :) ): The last sentence is the real challenge: Meanings depend 100% on writer and reader understandings. If two agree that 'homograph' means 'chicken poop', as long as they're the only ones communicating then 'chicken poop' it is; but if someone else reads it, our language subsystem fails. Some dictionaries influence meaning by being prescriptive (e.g., American Heritage, IIRC); others report what has been understood by being descriptive (e.g., Oxford). The problem is, Wikipedia is neither: It represents the understandings of a few editors of unknown knowledge; it is neither descriptive nor prescriptive and we quickly get into chicken poop scenarios. * Homograph, report Merriam-Webster and Oxford, means words with the same spelling but different meanings (or origin or pronunciation), e.g., the bow of a ship and a bow and arrow. * Homoglyph doesn't appear in Oxford, Merriam-Webster, American Heritage, or any others (per Wordnik and OneLook), except Wiktionary. Wiktionary descriptively traces the word back to 1938 (though maybe with a different meaning in that case) and says it means a glyph with the same or similar appearance but different meaning. That still doesn't define a term for the entire string "ycornbinator.com", only the "rn", but close enough!
- kovvy 5y agoThere is also 'homeograph' - "A word similar — but not identical — in spelling to another." That seems a better fit for your needs.
- naniwaduni 5y ago> Some dictionaries influence meaning by being prescriptive (e.g., American Heritage, IIRC); others report what has been understood by being descriptive (e.g., Oxford). The problem is, Wikipedia is neither: It represents the understandings of a few editors of unknown knowledge; it is neither descriptive nor prescriptive and we quickly get into chicken poop scenarios. To be clear: reporting what has been understood still influences meaning. Choice of inclusion moderates spread; definitions are inherently lossy and cannot capture the whole range of nuance; the compiler's understanding can be inaccurate. Lexicography is not a neutral art, no matter your choice of biases. And OED no less "represents the understandings of a few editors of unknown knowledge" than Wikipedia does. With different goals, and to different standards, to be sure, but Gell-Mann amnesia goes hard until you get into the weeds.