4 ms·
Modernity and simplicity is nice an all, but the Proton redesign process was a big failure in my opinion. I've heard nothing but annoyances from basic users abo
by jeroenhd 5y ago
Modernity and simplicity is nice an all, but the Proton redesign process was a big failure in my opinion. I've heard nothing but annoyances from basic users about the weird tab display, and many advanced screens (like in the settings) are being disappeared for the sake of simplicity without an equivalent implementation. The redesigns are welcome but left unfinished.
Up until around Photon, I considered every UI update an improvement. Photon itself was a bit of a mixed bag, but mostly contained improvements. That marked the turning point for me; Photon is where I actively started disliking the more prominent features. Unlike Photon, Proton was just a huge step back, with no real improvements to compensate.
Trying to get details about a TLS certificate, something only power users do and even then is done very rarely, is now a full page ordeal, with a small column down the middle of the page for content. Apparently the popup was too clumsy or something? I seriously don't understand why any UI designer ever cared. Everything is now bring dumbed down, information that doesn't satisfy the top 80% just gets completely removed and the space saved is dedicated to padding and margins making the entire UI more bloated.
Then there were dumb plans to make Firefox interesting (I think? What else were they doing?) like the idea of "colourways" being available for a limited time only, which was simply preposterous. Earlier they took over Pocket, a service everyone has now seen the icon for and barely anyone ever uses. When it comes to decisions about the browser, everyone who dares reduce telemetry gets ignored . Mozilla brands itself as a privacy aware company, but when you try to use that privacy it turns its back on you.
I suppose I should be thankful Mozilla isn't trying to ruin Firefox in desktop as much as it's trying to push users to abandon Firefox on mobile. My tab bar has gone through three changes I don't really give a damn about, collections have come and gone, and I've given up on ever using the addon API again. The text encoding settings and menu seems to have inexplicably disappeared, leading to some very annoying broken web pages that can't be fixed anymore.
You can't even enter an IPv6 address on Android. The browser engine can browse to IPv6 addresses just fine, the URL bar just doesn't accept them. The regex to determine if an input is a URL or not doesn't test for IPv6 and the single attempt by someone else to fix it was apparently too complex and therefore removed later. That person abandoned their efforts and the whole process doesn't exactly make me want to contribute either.
In my frustration I've actually considered (and quickly dismissed) the idea of writing a tool to spam Mozilla with telemetry to get the features that I use more hits. Telemetry warfare, of sorts.
- politelemon 5y agoI quite like the new certificate page, the information is a lot better presented than the previous tiny window where the information was in weird nested panels and harder to find. It's a lot easier to search through the cert info now. Yeah agree about the 'colorways' thing. I've read through their blog post a few times, and I still cannot understand why it was necessary or whether it accomplished its goals. https://blog.mozilla.org/en/products/firefox/introducing-new-colorways-for-firefox-94/ https://blog.mozilla.org/en/products/firefox/introducing-new...
- userbinator 5y agoThat was more likely marketing having nothing better to do, just like what happens when designers are left idle. They need to justify their existence somehow.
- dkbrk 5y ago> it's trying to push users to abandon Firefox on mobile The funny thing is, extensions are completely functional on mobile. All you have to do is: 1. Create a collection at addons.mozilla.org containing exactly the addons you want 2. Install firefox for android, developer edition 3. Sign in to sync 4. go to "about firefox" and tap the logo 5 times 5. select "custom Add-on collection"
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- svnpenn 5y agoIs this a joke? You shouldn't have to create an AMO account just to install an addon.
- brimble 5y ago> Then there were dumb plans to make Firefox interesting (I think? What else were they doing?) like the idea of "colourways" being available for a limited time only, which was simply preposterous. Nothing about this—the feature, and especially how they publicized it—made sense to me at first. Themes? OK, old feature, nothing to get excited about and I didn't even know they'd removed it in the first place, but sure. Limited time? Uh, what? Big announcement and interrupt my browsing session with a big ad? For a feature that wouldn't have been novel 25 years ago? None of it made sense. ... until they did the Disney tie-in colorway, at which point it all made sense. The original push must have been to generate "engagement" stats to show to potential advertisers, using a media push and user experience similar to what one would see for a paid advertising colorway.