3 ms·
> That last part is pretty dumb! It's not just dumb, the whole process is at the edges of the law. Art. 12 GDPR mandates "intelligible and easily accessible fo
by mschuster91 5y ago
> That last part is pretty dumb!
It's not just dumb, the whole process is at the edges of the law. Art. 12 GDPR mandates "intelligible and easily accessible form", which navigating through a number of pages, wait times and finally a 74-link download is certainly not fulfilling.
The gold standard, for what it's worth, is a direct link from the privacy policy page in the section that details GDPR subject rights to the page that provides the download - basically, three clicks in total.
> but it seems entirely plausible to me that many of the datasets being requested have "ask an engineer to run through this long manual process" as a dependency.
Which is ridiculous for a company at Amazon's scale and again at the edges of legality - Art. 12 GDPR mandates "without undue delay" and the one month is clearly meant as an upper bound here, not as the regular case.
That is the problem with American companies and also the US government: they all default to hoard data in warehouses and make use of it later, and completely ignoring that all the data they hoard must also be made accessible to the people it's related to.
- plandis 5y agoClicking a bunch of links is pretty accessible, perhaps you’re translating accessible to convenient?
- mschuster91 5y agoThe spirit of the GDPR law was to make life for people easier. Putting hoops in front of users that are clearly not needed - Amazon could, for example, offer a single ZIP file like Twitter does - will some day earn them trouble.
- shadowgovt 5y agoThis is yet another example of how the GDPR is bad law. "Intelligible and easily accessible" is way too vague. Are 74 zip files intelligible and easily accessible? Of course not! I don't want to pull 74 links! Is 1 zip file intelligible and easily accessible? Of course not! Way too big to pull in over my low-bandwidth connection. Are zip files intelligible and easily accessible? Of course not! Not everyone understands compression. ...etc., etc. I'd have a lot more respect for that law if it spelled out concretes instead of handwaving technical details and leaving it up to regulators to decide what passes and what doesn't.
- dmitriid 5y agoThis is yet another example of a random commenter on HN parroting "GPDR bad" nonsense while being intentionally obtuse. Laws are often written with "common sense" in mind. HN commentators prefer to eschew common sense to try and excuse bad actors, bad behaviour, bad UX, bad anything.
- mschuster91 5y agoThat is how laws are usually written. Hashing out the details will be done by the courts.