3 ms·
Yes, this is ignoring Quantum Mechanics. Oversimplifying, Physics is divided in "General Relativity" and "Everything Else". Where "Everything Else" includes Q
by gus_massa 5y ago
Yes, this is ignoring Quantum Mechanics.
Oversimplifying, Physics is divided in "General Relativity" and "Everything Else".
Where "Everything Else" includes Quantum Mechanics, Special Relativity, Chemistry, particle Physics in the CERN, Superconductor, Semiconductors, Conductors, ..., and a simplified model of Gravity because people is interested in rocks that fall, airplanes, Astronomy, and other stuff.
And "General Relativity" includes another copy of Special Relativity and an accurate model of Gravity, that is only important if you are studding black holes, gravitational waves at LIGO, some parts of Astronomy, GPS and not too many more applications. This part of Physics ignore the Quantum Mechanics effects.
There are some results that mix both, like Hawking radiation around black holes. The idea is to find a more general theory that joins the two parts of Physics, but it's apparently a very difficult problem because a lot of smart people has tried to solve it and failed.
The research paper is about black holes, so it has a huge invisible disclaimer at the top that says:
fake quote> <huge><red>We are going to use General Relativity and we are going to pretend that nobody discovered Quantum Mechanics and the universe is 100% deterministic.</red></huge>
This disclaimer is actually not written because everybody reading the journal will assume that, so it's not necessary to explain that. The problem is that this simplification leaked to the press article, and the simplification was not well explained. So it looks like the author or journalist are not aware of Quantum Mechanics, but actually they are fully aware, it's just that they need this simplification to be able to do the calculations. It's a standard trick in the area.
Also the "100% deterministic" in may fake quote is a lie, because the problem is that in some parts inside black holes the equations of General Relativity have technical problems and have multiple solutions. The article is about this region and about how many horrible things would happen if you try to visit that part of a black hole. The main result is that in some cases it's not as horrible as expected and you may survive.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]