3 ms·
> It’s open to objections: first, Github does this already, so it’s a solved problem. I can buy the reasoning that it's a solved problem with additional softwa
by dijit 5y ago
> It’s open to objections: first, Github does this already, so it’s a solved problem.
I can buy the reasoning that it's a solved problem with additional software, but citing github specifically here is absurd.
Github is a SaaS, centralised, closed source and unfederated platform.
I can understand that you think they're a good service, but there's a huge difference between something like git (which is a tool and a flexible one) and SVN, vs a hosted service.
You can think of it like VLC media player vs youtube.
- dash2 5y agoSure. If you think everything centralized, closed source and federated should be replaced with something decentralized, federated and open source, then Github is unacceptable. Just note that these are not inherently features. They may at some point become useful features - if e.g. all closed source software eventually is exploited by monopolists - but that is a very particular viewpoint. Given the success of Github, it seems that many people don't yet share that view. So, if I were persuading people to use Fossil, I would try to focus on features that most people want. But OK, if it's going for a free software niche, then fine.