7 ms·
As of now, the longest vowel-less meaningful sentence in Czech is: Škrt plch z mlh Brd pln skvrn z mrv prv hrd scvrnkl z brzd skrz trs chrp v krs vrb mls mrch
by inglor_cz 5y ago
As of now, the longest vowel-less meaningful sentence in Czech is:
Škrt plch z mlh Brd pln skvrn z mrv prv hrd scvrnkl z brzd skrz trs chrp v krs vrb mls mrch srn čtvrthrst zrn.
The meaning of the sentence is:
Stingy dormouse from Brdy mountains fogs full of manure spots firstly proudly shrank a quarter of handful seeds, a delicacy for mean does, from brakes through bunch of Centaurea flowers into scrub of willows.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Str%C4%8D_prst_skrz_krk https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Str%C4%8D_prst_skrz_krk
I just walked around Brdy yesterday, but I didn't meet any stingy dormouse. They must be rare.
- adrian_b 5y agoIn reality this sentence is not vowel-less. It is vowel-less only from the perspective of the languages where "R" and "L" can be only consonants, i.e. they must always belong to syllables where another sound is the vowel (i.e. the peak of sonority). In Czech and in many other present or past languages, including in the Proto-Indo-European, "R" and "L" can be both consonants and vowels, depending on the neighbour sounds. While there are many languages where "R" and "L" cannot be vowels, in almost all languages "I" and "U" can be either vowels or consonants, also depending on their environment. There are languages where even "E" and "O" can be consonants in certain environments, not only vowels. There are also languages where the nasal plosives or even some sibilants may be vowels, not only consonants. In general, only "A" is always a vowel and only the non-nasal plosives are always only consonants. For the other sounds of intermediate sonority, it varies from language to language whether they are used only as consonants or only as vowels, or they may be used as either consonants or vowels, depending on the environment.
- dotancohen 5y agoAt my skill level in life, burgundy is red, Excel is witchcraft, and "Škrt plch z mlh..." is vowelless.
- dylan604 5y agoHow do we make "At my skill level in life..." the next viral meme?
- hnbad 5y agoYou're conflating syllabic consonants and vowels. Phonetically, R and L are always consonants. The distinction between consonants and vowels is not in whether they can appear by themselves as syllables. For example, in many English dialects "bottle" has two syllables and the second syllable is just an "L". But that L is still a consonant.
- azangru 5y agoHow is it known, about bottle, whether it has one or two syllables? According to the sonority sequencing principle, /l/ has a higher sonority than /t/ or a glottal stop; so one would expect bottle to always have two syllables (this is reflected in transcriptions provided by Merriam-Webster's or Cambridge Advanced Learner's). When would this not be the case?
- hnbad 5y agoIt depends on the dialect but in many cases the /l/ is syllabic. The difference is mostly in whether the second syllable is just the /l/ or also contains a schwa. I don't think there are any dialects where the word is monosyllabic as that would probably require making the /t/ completely silent (not just a glottal stop).
- adrian_b 5y agoYou are right only if you redefine the word "consonant" to mean a name attached permanently to certain sounds based on their kind of articulation, regardless how they are used in a word. Such terms are e.g. "obstruents", "sonorants", "nasals" etc. The word "consonant" (like all Latin grammatical terms it was a calque after a Greek term) was defined more than 2000 years ago as "con-" + "-sonant", i.e. a sound pronounced together with another in a syllable and not pronounced independently, like a vowel. The original word has nothing to do with the manner of articulation of the sound, but only about how it is combined in speech. The terms "semivowel" or "semiconsonant" that are sometimes used, are not helpful at all, because in a given word any sound is either used as a vowel or as a consonant and not as something between them. Some sounds are always used as vowels, some are always used as consonants and others are sometimes used as vowels and sometimes used as consonants. The partitioning of the sounds between these 3 classes varies from language to language and this fact needs to be understood by whoever wants to understand the pronunciation of foreign languages. It is necessary to have 2 terms for the 2 kinds of roles that sounds may have in a syllable. "Consonant" has the right original definition and etymology for one of the roles and there is no better alternative and no reason to replace it. It is much less established what "vowel" should mean, because it is used both in the traditional sense for the sounds that are the syllabic peak of sonority and for a particular class of sounds based on the articulation type, i.e. for those where the vocal tract is less constricted than for other classes of sounds. If "vowel" is assigned to refer strictly to the articulation kind, then the only existing term that can be used for the role in a syllable would be "syllabic". With this term choice, one can say that "I" is a vowel that is syllabic in "pin" and consonant in "yard" and that "N" is a nasal sonorant that is syllabic in "button" and consonant in "nut". However, if "vowel" is restricted as a name for a class of sounds, then it is not more surprising to have human names without vowels then e.g. having human names without dental obstruents or human names without any other particular kind of sounds. The supposedly surprising fact was the existence of human names without syllabic sounds. Had that been true, the names would have been unpronounceable. So "vowel" in the thread title had to mean "syllabic" for the title to make sense. In fact there is no surprise except for English speakers, because in other languages there are types of sounds that may be syllabic even if they cannot be syllabic in English.
- Asraelite 5y agoBy nasal plosive do you mean nasal sonorants, [n] [m] etc. or do you mean something like [ⁿd]? "nasal plosive" sounds like an oxymoron to me.
- adrian_b 5y agoI have meant nasal sonorants. The terminology is not uniform. There are many (typically in older literature) who call [m], [n], ... nasal plosives, in opposition with oral plosives [b], [d], ..., because the only difference between them is the open nasal path. It is true however that having an open nasal path means that they are not really obstruents so they should not be called plosives according to more modern classifications that partition the sounds into obstruents and sonorants, where plosives belong to the obstruents. However here I do not know how many are familiar with the more recent linguistic terms, so I tended to use more ancient terms.
- Asraelite 5y ago> because the only difference between them is the open nasal path I wonder how denasalized nasals like Korean [m͊] would fit into the picture then. I did not know about that older terminology, thanks for explaining.
- adrian_b 5y agoWhile I know a little about written Korean, I am not familiar with the Korean pronunciation. Nevertheless, according to Wikipedia, the Korean denasalized nasals are pronounced exactly like their oral counterparts, i.e. "b" instead of "m" and "d" instead of "n". They use a special notation only because at their origin they were nasals and even now the denasalisation happens only in certain contexts and in certain cases the denasalisation is partial, the resulting sound being intermediate between the oral and the nasal variants (i.e. the nasal path is only partially open).
- Asraelite 5y ago> according to Wikipedia, the Korean denasalized nasals are pronounced exactly like their oral counterparts, i.e. "b" instead of "m" and "d" instead of "n". I don't speak Korean, but from hearing it I get the impression that it's more complicated than that: Korean word-initial nasals vary randomly in their nasality. Sometimes they are partially nasal, sometimes there is no nasal airflow at all. And when they are fully denasalized, the resulting [b] and [d] are voiced for the full duration that they are held, while normal [b] and [d] resulting from word-medial /p/ and /t/ are only partially overvoiced i.e. similar to English /b/ and /d/.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]