5 ms·
American Culture Ate the World
- oh_sigh 5y agoIs there any evidence that Americans are particularly ignorant of the world relative to other nationalities?
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoin my opinion the evidence is anecdotal from mainly Europeans, the problem there is that Europeans are perhaps more aware of other parts of at least Europe than most nationalities are of their local environment. So the ignorance of Americans is a source of humor. This however is just a surmise, based on some observation. The other evidence is that Americans generally know very little of geography, it's a big thing in countries I've visited to laugh about, although given that when I say I lived in Utah in the U.S a lot of years and the geographically cognizant Dane will sagely say "oh, the middle of the country" I'm not sure how much to value that opinion either. At any rate I don't much value the fact that people can tell you what the capital of Ethiopia is or where Andorra is because these bits of trivia don't actually tell you anything significant about the countries under discussion. It's true, not knowing these things you are extremely unlikely to know anything worth knowing about the region under discussion, but on the other hand it's been my experience that knowing them you somehow think you do know significantly more about the region than someone who does not know whatever trivia is the subject.
- wbsss4412 5y agoEuropeans tend to be fairy elitist about their own history and culture. Specific to the example that you brought up, why is knowledge of Andorra or any of the other European micro states any more geographically important than knowledge of US States? Anecdotally, Europeans will respond that those are _countries_, yet those realistically only exist due to the quirks of European political history, one can hardly hold up Lichtenstein as the geopolitical equal to California, yet in discussions with Europeans it seems that knowledge of its existence is somehow superior.
- eurasiantiger 5y ago> one can hardly hold up Lichtenstein as the geopolitical equal to California Why not?
- wbsss4412 5y agoSure, technically you can do whatever you want. But by any measure, political/cultural/economic influence it’s pretty evident that the two are not in the same category.
- eurasiantiger 5y agoLiechtenstein has over double the GDP per capita.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agowell, yeah Liechtenstein has nearly 7 billion, California has 3 trillion.
- eurasiantiger 5y agoYet it’s California that has double the murder rate, massive homelessness issues, not to mention substance abuse, armed robberies and car theft in broad daylight, the list goes on… and ends in an incarcerated population of over 2 million people, whereas Liechtenstein is incarcerating around twenty people. (TWENTY! In the entire population!)
- wbsss4412 5y agoYou’re totally missing the thread here. The discussion isn’t about which is a better place to live/governance. It’s about what’s a more relevant measure of geographical knowledge.
- 5y ago
- Gunax 5y agoI suspect so, but these questions are often defined more by the type of knowledge they would ask. Canadians tease Americans for not knowing Canada, but that's an unequal comparison. Of course Canadians know more about America than Americans do about Canada. They hear about American news and elections and watch American movies. Ask canadians and americans about Uruguay or Mali and they probably know about the same. It's not that Americans are dumb or don't care--they are just at the center of the world.
- AniseAbyss 5y agoWhen I go to the gym I pass a McDonald's drive in. Feel a bit annoyed we are letting our minds and bodies be poisoned by American culture but they are all doing it voluntarily. It is like a junkie blaming his drug dealer for the addiction.
- ipaddr 5y agoDoes his drug dealer bear some responsibility? Courts would charge him with committing crimes causing harm to the people they sell to.
- just_steve_h 5y agoThis article includes some essential details that are largely unknown to most readers: the US government not only severely restricted the ability of foreigners to even enter the United States based on ideology and national origin; they also severely restricted the ability of Americans to LEAVE THEIR OWN COUNTRY, again based upon ideology and "race" (see the case of the Black American journalist whose passport was revoked because he dared to report from Cuba!) The greatest triumph of the American system of doctrinal management has been the inculcation of the bedrock belief that "we live in a free society." We do not, and we never have. It remains a worthy goal; many of those fighting to realize it remain criminalized, ostracized, and imprisoned. Would a "free" country jail its citizens at a rate FIVE TIMES HIGHER than the other countries of the world? Would a "free" country maintain police forces in every major city that are larger and more well-equipped than most national armies worldwide? If one were so inclined, one might wonder how these tendencies manifest in one's professional, social, and personal spheres. Or one might argued about the advantages of higher-bandwidth system RAM vs faster SSD's… or vi vs emacs…
- _8j50 5y agoYou have good points but what is freedom and who is free? Most minorities don't think "we live in a free society" in this same sense. Relatively speaking, there maybe other countries with better freedom to specific groups but America is still the best place to be if the freedom you want is freedom to make a lot of money. You are confusing the animosity between social groups with lack of freedom. The incarceration rate, much like the gun ownership rate is a direct result of americans using their freedom to have their elected officials pass specific laws. Being tough on crime is still one of the best policies a politician can advertise in a campaign because that's what people want to hear. The free people use their free ballots to make sure miniroities are kept in check by an army of cops enganged in a "war on drugs". This is freedom. It includes freedom of the majority to restrict the freedom of the minority. All of the problems you mentioned are caused by freedom, not by oppressive forces that disregard freedom. Freedom in america means political participation. No one has protests as much as americans or vote at the scale of america (except maybe india). You can free all the prisoners and disband all the cops if enough americans agree. It's not lack of freedom but quite the opposite, the people, your neighbors excercising their freedoms to an unfortunate end. Lack of freedom would be wanting to enact changes with popular support but being unable to.
- readonthegoapp 5y agoA _free_ world... dedicated to free information flows. Meanwhile, you can't even get AJE on cable in the US
- gruez 5y agoI'm presuming that by "AJE", you're talking about Al Jazeera English. 1. but you can get it over internet? I don't see why it not being available on cable is indicative of "freedom" (ie. government oppression) 2. according to wikipedia the only countries that have it "on cable" are: UK, New Zealand, Afghanistan, Sub-Saharan Africa, and Sweden. I guess every other country not on that list are not "dedicated to free information flows" by your criteria?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]