5 ms·
People have what seem like impossible talents. I could practice every day for decades and not be able to dunk a basketball from mid-court even once. But there a
by ncmncm 5y ago
People have what seem like impossible talents. I could practice every day for decades and not be able to dunk a basketball from mid-court even once. But there are people who can do it without even looking where they are throwing the ball. I would not believe if if I had not seen it.
- mirceal 5y agoI think you could dunk a basketball from midcourt easily if you trained for it. It baffles me when people think X or Y are impossible. Sure, for some things you need to work a lot. Genetics plays a huge role. Where you where born and your environment matter a lot. But at the end of the day you can do many more things that you believe you can if you apply yourself.
- garyfirestorm 5y agoSounds like a nature vs nurture argument. I think there is a lot of literature out there on this.
- ncmncm 5y agoAnd there are other things you can never do, no matter how much apply yourself. It is difficult to discover which is which.
- cafard 5y agoFrom midcourt, as in leaping from the midcourt line and not landing again until you have dunked? Doesn't the distance from the half-court line to the basket exceed that of the world record long jump?
- ncmncm 5y agoYou seem to be using a definition of "dunk" unfamiliar to the rest of us. Maybe you use a different word for the ball dropping through the basket without touching the rim or backboard? (A recent crossword had a word "teardrop" whose clue suggested it might be that.)
- bayesian_horse 5y agoI think the basketball example isn't true - this is a skill someone with the basic ability to throw a ball that far and no neurological impairments should be able to acquire, even if it takes a few months or years. Chess? Not so much. In my opinion there is something in some people's brains that is akin to a custom hardware acceleration. It can be trained and further developed but the first seed must actually happen by chance. Nobody knows what creates those circuitry in some people's brains and there is no way to reliably recreate it.
- ncmncm 5y agoLiterally millions of people train and practice basketball for decades, from early childhood. How many of them can reliably sink a shot from mid-court? How many without looking? How much longer do you imagine they would all need to train? Even most of the best professional players can't do it. Why would they drive all the way to the basket if they could chuck it in from the other side of the court?
- bayesian_horse 5y agoI didn't say "reliably" and not blindfolded. Nor do people who practice basketball for decades usually practice this particular skill every day excessively.
- ncmncm 5y agoIf every pro could do it, the amount of practice wouldn't be excessive, it would be expected.