3 ms·
It's a nice explanation. I'll compare this video with https://www.britannica.com/video/185531/explanation-field-Higgs-particles-mass https://www.britannica.com
by gus_massa 5y ago
It's a nice explanation.
I'll compare this video with https://www.britannica.com/video/185531/explanation-field-Higgs-particles-mass https://www.britannica.com/video/185531/explanation-field-Hi... that was linked in a sibling comment by harshreality.
The PBS video:
* Has more technical stuff, so I'd recommend to see the other video first.
* I like that it explain chirality. It's very important for this subject.
* I don't like that they say that massless particles "experience no time". It's a common idea floating around, but it cause more misinterpretations than what it helps in the explanations.
* They explain hypercharge. It's really important, but I'd hide under the carpet because there are too many things to explain.
* In particular the circle in 5:22 is misleading/wrong. IIRC it's not a circle (aka U(1)), it's a magic double sphere (aka SU(2)). A circle is a nice representation, but they put a "real" and a "imaginary" axis in the graph, as it were actually the circle in the complex plane. This part is also important, and specialist love it because spontaneous symmetry breaking is so unusual and weird, but I'd just hid it under the carpet too.
* The idea that the "spin constantly flips back and forth" is wrong. The spin is stable. For example the left handed (L) version of the electron and the right handed (R) version have spin 1/2. If you take a particle with spin +1/2 in one direction, the L and R version "flips back and forth" but when you measure the spin again in the same direction you still get +1/2, because the spin does not change.
What "flips back and forth" is the direction. The idea is very similar to what is explained in the video in Britannica. If you mix different amounts of L and R with spin +1/2 in one direction, you can get a particle that has spin +1/2 in that direction and any speed you like because the speed is something like the average of both speeds. The Higgs field somehow keep the L and R version together, instead of them flying away in oposite directions. For this part I strongly prefer how it is explained in the video in Britannica.
It's a nice video, but they should fix the part about spin flipping. (And perhaps hide the some details, but this is a personal preference.)