6 ms·
Island is among the fastest companies to reach unicorn status
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- acdha 5y agoIs there any reason to think this number is real rather than what the VCs need to turn a profit? A Chromium fork which competes with Google in a core focus of the Chrome team seems like a tough market to be profitable in.
- pmayrgundter 5y agoTotally agree
- ushakov 5y agothe real number is what someone else is willing to offer to buy this company i’d give $30, but only because of the domain name :D
- invalidname 5y agoThis isn't in competition with Google. It isn't really a "browser". It's an enterprise security app that helps web applications be more secure on end-user devices. The fact that it's implemented on top of Chromium is an "implementation detail". Security tools is a HUGE market that you can sell to the enterprise. Firefox or Google could do the exact same thing. But they aren't. There's also Talon (another Israeli company that raised a bundle) which does the same thing.
- acdha 5y agoIt is a browser, as clearly explained by their own marketing material. They’re trying to build some nice security policies into it but that’s something Google and Microsoft are also doing or have already done — for example, restricting where you can screenshot or copy and paste is a demand in certain fields but neither of those are huge technical hurdles and would be minor extensions to the existing group policies. I’m aware it’s a large potential market - note that I was asking was why this particular company would be capturing a billion dollar valuation as opposed to their competitors, many of whom are more established and have high-functioning engineering teams.
- invalidname 5y agoPerhaps I wasn't clear. It isn't "sold" like a browser is sold. That's not the "product". Technically, yes it's chromium. Sales/profit/product wise. It isn't.
- Gys 5y ago> Although Island’s service is built on the same Chromium engine as many popular browsers, and therefore has a familiar interface, it places a number of restrictions on the way in which end users can interact with the web. For example, the Island browser gives security teams control over simple functionality such as copy-and-paste, screen capture and content downloads. It also places limits on the kinds of extensions that can be installed and the domains that can be visited. I think this is a great idea. I can understand enterprises do not mind paying a subscription fee per user to fully control an important piece of software. Edit: typo
- enos_feedler 5y agoProbably a better idea for school kids where it makes sense to lock down their chromebooks. But that market is much smaller than “enterprise” and Google has probably figured it out already there. This just seems like a concept for enterprise that isnt really a solution to anything
- ec109685 5y agoThose don’t seem like hard controls for Chrome or Edge to support for businesses if the market demand is there. Companies can already lock chrome down to a decent extent.
- notyourwork 5y agoSubscriptions are how you lock customers (companies) in and companies have fat wallets and are slow to migrate away.
- kbelder 5y agoThis sounds like the type of thing IT would push on us, causing great inconvenience until we found a way to work around it and install the browsers, extensions, and functionality we really need.
- asojfdowgh 5y agoChrome has policies for all of that except copy/paste, which is probably more suited to a OS policy https://chromeenterprise.google/policies/ https://chromeenterprise.google/policies/
- nicolasmelo12 5y agoI feel like startups is just a way to do money laundering nowadays. You can say what you want but there is NO way this startup is worth a billion dollars and that this money is actually clean. Seriously, look at their website: https://www.island.io/ https://www.island.io/ There is not even a SINGLE image of the browser itself, it's just 3D renders, there is no way to test it. At least BREX, Slack and the others are product you can see, it's something that you can know it exists. Even in the use cases for the browser they don't show anything about the browser itself. This is REALLY disappointing for any entrepreneur working on a REAL product and receiving NO from every single investor they talk to. I mean: i, a nobody, has a solid product, has paying clients. But because i am not friend of a VC or somebody else i need to listen that my product is not good enough, that it will never scale, that i don't have the right revenue to justify an investment. You can see my product, you can test it if you want. But then a guy comes with something that doesn't even have a proper website and is valuated a billion dollars out of the gate. It's just sad to see what the startup ecosystem has become.
- motoboi 5y agogoogle for venture capitalist. You will be amazed.
- ushakov 5y agoVC-funded startups are legitimized MLM schemes
- doppp 5y agoIt's HBO's Silicon Valley all over again.
- vmception 5y agoJust because you’re a nobody doesn't mean that somebodies are money laundering. To expand on that, although being a limited partner is a great way to clean money there is no difference between a small round or a big round in that regard. There is just unlimited money for a limited amount of things.
- 52-6F-62 5y agoThat is the way the world has always worked. It’s about relationships, not industrial merit. Sometimes those relationships are sound and the ambitions more honest, and other times they are flaky, dishonest or downright fraudulent. And very dimensional gradient between. You’ll (almost) never get a leading role in a Hollywood blockbuster off the street after an audition. You will maybe get a smaller part. Why? Relationships. It’s the same everywhere.
- civilized 5y agoI can hear IT salivating. Cut-and-paste will be disabled and I will have to manually transcribe from StackOverflow. Like many enterprise things, this will be a lose-lose. Jobs will be harder, but no one will be more secure. No one will even get a bonus for pretending to make something more secure. I guess that faceless IT group in every company that loves locking things down will get some sort of satisfaction. Not sure if that counts as a win.
- mistrial9 5y agolike Medium does ?
- civilized 5y agoNothing makes your platform scream "legacy" like disabling cut-and-paste. No wonder they're getting wiped out by Substack.
- NovemberWhiskey 5y agoNo-one cares about you copying from the web; they care about you pasting to the web.
- ocdtrekkie 5y agoAs a faceless member of the IT department, we generally only lock something down because someone has found a way to do something really dumb with it. For copy/paste, I can already tell you: We blocked installing Grammarly because there's no reasonable guarantee of what happens to the sensitive data we are legally obligated not to share, so people copy/paste sensitive data into Grammarly's website. Now we have to block Grammary's website, but I could see someone giving up and taking away pasting into websites as a next step...
- civilized 5y agoI will admit that this does make sense.
- parkerhiggins 5y agoWonder how long it will take until Google copies these features for Chrome Enterprise. Just like they did with Google Calendar and Clockwise.
- antiterra 5y agoI know hand waving about customers is a common startup tactic, but if it’s true that they’ve landed a couple prime customers after years of stealth development, then it makes at least some sense: > Island CEO Michael Fey tells TechCrunch that the investment is a result of “very fortunate” customer demand since it launched in February. > “Our team has been able to secure business across a wealth of sectors and organization sizes.”
- emerongi 5y agoReminds me of Theranos for some reason.
- DyslexicAtheist 5y agothat Theranos CEO was one hellova "female Christian Bale". just watching "The Dropout" now and this story is so insane.
- mcintyre1994 5y agoJohn Carreyrou's book Bad Blood about this is absolutely amazing as well
- ARandomerDude 5y ago> For example, the Island browser gives security teams control over simple functionality such as copy-and-paste, screen capture and content downloads. It also places limits on the kinds of extensions that can be installed and the domains that can be visited. Honestly, the day this landed on my work machine would be the day I turned in my notice.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- blurker 5y ago> the service gives IT administrators ... full insight into all deployments to help identify the source of incidents as quickly as possible. Yeah, and this part gives me the picture that they'd be able to monitor absolutely everything you do with the browser.
- biryani_chicken 5y agoSo... an adblocker and client-side certificates? Please at least add the client-side certificates.
- atarian 5y agoCopy-and-paste is disabled? Let me just take a screenshot.
- rurban 5y agoso this looks like two engineers weeks, and 3 man years for cooperate/media. evaluation checks out.
- quadrifoliate 5y ago> “Island has created a whole new way of thinking about enterprise work. By fundamentally transforming the work environment to be secure-by-design, the Island Enterprise Browser enables organizations to achieve entirely new levels of security, productivity, and IT efficiency,” added Fey. These "whole new ways about thinking about enterprise work" frequently translate to endless micro-management and requesting permissions from the gods of IT to do what's often very necessary to your job. It's not really possible to just "turn in your notice" (like someone else suggested) if you get this sort of micromanagey corporate spyware installed – but I would definitely treat it as a negative while looking at and negotiating job offers. Clearly the market for this sort of nonsense is high, so it needs to be addressed via the market. For folks who are managers or similar, trying to get productive output from a programmer while forcing them to use intrusive corporate spyware is like locking an artist in a cell, putting a camera on them, and saying "Paint the best artwork you can". Please avoid doing this as far as possible. And to address an immediate reply that often comes up – no, SOC2 doesn't mean you have to do this; simple home-grown software suffices. Yes, we know your compliance audits cost a lot. Believe me, losing a fully-trained software developer also costs a lot in the current market. Find unintrusive, basic software that will satisfy your needs with easy controls for advanced users. The real controls are that you should be able to trust the software developers that are creating ridiculous amounts of value for your company.
- thinkharderdev 5y agoI doubt the target market for this product is as a web browser for developers. Seems like a reasonably useful product if you want to deploy a call center application as a web application or an application for some sort of data entry in a bank or financial institution. In that case it makes total sense to heavily restrict what functionality is available in the browser.
- hirundo 5y agoAny required, installed software is a red flag for me. I've been working for an all-remote web shop for the last decade. They don't care what software we use to create our deliverables. It's our own software on our own hardware, and as long as we can do the work, it's up to us. The only time a particular browser is required is if we have a browser-specific bug. (I'm not sure there's a choice for the VPN authenticator, but there is for pretty much everything else.) There are a few SAAS apps that we all use to communicate. But except for sysops we work on our local machines most of the time. I find this to be a wonderful perk, and would probably more than hesitate to lose it. Hopefully this model and the growth of remote work puts a serious crimp in Island's market size.
- kornhole 5y agoThe browser is probably the main attack vector these days. Companies are spending massively to secure their endpoints, but the mouse fingers are difficult to control. I see the value proposition but struggle to see it at this figure when someone else should be able to build the same limitations into another fork. I guess subscription to a service to customize to a company's needs is warranted.
- mellosouls 5y agoI opened this wondering if it was a retrospective assessment of the famous record label. But no, it's a new company using the same name.
- pojzon 5y agoIts hard to find ppl that know how to work securely, so we create tools to make work of security oblivious ppl more secure.
- mihaitodor 5y ago> For example, the Island browser gives security teams control over simple functionality such as copy-and-paste, screen capture and content downloads. Are investors really blown away by such "features"? Most people have a webcam near by or a second phone. Surely this can't be the killer feature set which justifies so much investment.
- f7ebc20c97 5y agoBlocking copy-paste, blocking screenshots, and blocking file downloads...for only $1.3 billion dollars! Are you sure we're not in another tech bubble?
- freediver 5y agoNo, what investors are excited about is the ability to sell this to enterprises, because it sounds 'good' and 'important'. It will get nods. When Zoom came around, it did not bring anything new (video calls existed for 20 years) but their ability to sell this to companies was remarkable.
- totalview 5y agoIt pains me to see good tech all over HN and then get a reminder of where the software market’s focus is at: endlessly regurgitating the same idea (wow, another browser) while adding “enterprise features” that aren’t even features. Also, what is up with the $1B valuation when they just came out of stealth mode? This isn’t deep tech. Do they good profit margins (lol)? Do they even have revenue? I don’t even have to ask…
- tomp 5y agoWhy not, after Slack (trivial, not deep tech) - main feature of business model is make something corporations want.
- jjsteele 5y agoEnterprise Browser is not a new concept, at all. Both Chrome and Edge has Enterprise Browser versions for years, with central control capabilities like these built in and controllable by the enterprise admin. See more here: 1- Chrome Enterprise: https://chromeenterprise.google/security/ https://chromeenterprise.google/security/ 2- Edge Enterprise: https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/deployedge/ms-edge-security-for-business https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/deployedge/ms-edge-security... Also, keeping a browser software itself secure from all external threats is a very very tall order. Both Google and Microsoft have large teams of security experts and trillions of daily points collected that helps to find and fix security issues in the browser software itself. Not sure one can trust a very early product and nascent software - while copy-paste by employees may have been controlled, the real hackers may not be prevented from exploiting the security issues in complex browser software that Google and Microsoft fix on a daily basis. This startup will have a very hard time to compete or replace either Chrome or Safari, when enterprises who care about such central controls can turn on such tech within Chrome and Safari itself. Enterprises who would want to silently monitor will simply turn on such control capabilities in common browsers, vs blatantly asking their teams to switch and use a browsers that is only known for such monitoring--- LoL