6 ms·
Brewster Kahle and the Internet Archive still working to democratize knowledge
- edward 5y agoThe people at the Internet Archive do amazing work. They can always benefit from donations. See https://archive.org/donate https://archive.org/donate
- verisimi 5y agoI'm a big fan.. and I agree with: “Corporations continue to control access to materials that are in the library, which is controlling preservation, and it’s killing us.” .. but why get into bed with Cloudflare?
- nix23 5y ago>.. but why get into bed with Cloudflare? Why not, is Cloudlfare controlling preservation? Is Cloudflare not exchangeable?
- verisimi 5y agoIts not controlling preservation but it is involved: “Through our partnership with Cloudflare, we are learning about, and archiving, web pages we might not have otherwise known about, and by integrating with Cloudflare’s Always Online service, archives of those pages are available to people trying to access them if they become unavailable via the live web,” said Mark Graham, Director of the Wayback Machine at the Internet Archive. https://www.cloudflare.com/en-gb/press-releases/2020/cloudflare-partners-with-the-internet-archive-to-keep-the-web-always-online/ https://www.cloudflare.com/en-gb/press-releases/2020/cloudfl... But the broader point is that now they are in the door would we even hear about any new developments in the partnership?
- temp8964 5y agoWhat if someday the CEO of Cloudflare decides some websites should not be archived?
- toomuchtodo 5y agoThe Internet Archive will continue to rely on its own infrastructure to perform crawls. You can take corporate handouts without becoming beholden to the corporation.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoI have a disorder where I go through phases where I compulsively scan and clean-up old books and booklets that are long out of print but which, for one reason or another, had made an impression on my younger self. I have uploaded those to the Internet Archive so that they might be more likely to outlive me.
- scrollaway 5y agoThank you, fellow archivist :)
- toomuchtodo 5y agoThank you for putting in the effort! For those who don’t know, if you don’t need the book or media back, you can mail the artifact to the Internet Archive’s San Francisco address and it will be added to their catalog as processing capacity permits. I’m sending them a family members’s extensive LP collection when they pass, for example. https://help.archive.org/help/how-do-i-make-a-physical-donation-to-the-internet-archive/ https://help.archive.org/help/how-do-i-make-a-physical-donat...
- causality0 5y agoThe IA is one of the purer forces for good on the internet. It's definitely worth your donations. I do wonder, though, how well-filled the niche is for providers for the content that can't be on IA, specifically that which has been requested to be taken down. Quite a lot of the "wild west" era internet content both ranks highly on things I personally want preserved and is quite likely to have takedown requests.
- ravenstine 5y agoIt'd be pretty cool if someone could organize an "Internet Wild West" archive specifically for that kind of content and host it using torrents and I2P so that it can't be easily challenged. Yeah, there's probably a lot of problems with that, but there's nevertheless parts of the Before Time that I'd like preserved. This is why I download and archive locally things I enjoy repeatedly and find significant. If I remember something I once loved or laughed hysterically at back in the old days, I use yt-dlp to download it because I know someday it'll get erased and a shrinking minority of people will even remember what it was. To me, it's about personal culture. There are videos and other online content that became an institution in my young brain, but inevitably faded into irrelevance, eventually disappearing entirely in some cases. If I remember a piece of media but find that it's been lost for good, it's like I've lost a small part of myself. In any case, I definitely recommend creating a personal archive. I agree that the Internet Archive is an amazing thing and that we are blessed to have it, but clearly not everything has an obvious place on it and I think it's only a matter of time before the Cathedral, if you will, recognizes its existence and subverts or destroys it.
- causality0 5y agoIf I remember a piece of media but find that it's been lost for good, it's like I've lost a small part of myself. I could not have phrased it more perfectly myself. Those things are a part of us. Back in the day your preserved memories were a journal, a book, a photograph, a videotape. Now they live on the cloud and all it takes to lose part of it is for a creator to decide that content doesn't suit their brand anymore and erase it. Just going through your Youtube Liked Videos list and seeing how many are no longer available should be enough to send a cold chill down your spine. If I like it, I save it. There are some things I suspect I may have the only existing copy of. I wish someone would come up with a site archiver like HTTRACK but built for archival of modern websites that are full of content not hosted directly on the site's server.
- Centigonal 5y agoBrewster Kahle is a fascinating human being. Before the Internet Archive, he created and sold Alexa.com to Amazon, and sold a different company to AOL. He had a similar start to many current serial entrepreneurs or VC folks, but he chose a different path.
- 30367286 5y agoA long time ago, on what.cd, I spent some time to upload rare and odd CDs I found at the library in Austin, TX. For a while, I had only one downloader, consistently. A user name Librarian. I looked up their IP address as it was connected to my seedbox and it was The Internet Archive’s. I suspect they have more content than they let on — that they are sitting on a trove of content that they are waiting for copyright expirations or reform. If I were Kahle, on my death bed I would just upload the entire archive to some IPFS or torrent site and just let it all be free. Side note: libgen is still around and it’s also another pure instance of what the internet should be.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- zozbot234 5y ago> I suspect they have more content than they let on — that they are sitting on a trove of content that they are waiting for copyright expirations or reform. This is one of the things that their official status as a "library" explicitly allows them to do, so yes, I think they have even acknowledged that. When stuff goes into the public domain, the Internet Archive will release it.
- dewey 5y ago> Librarian If I'm remembering it correctly the user name was "Archivist". As far as I know most of the meta data of the albums that were listed on What are publicly visible on archive.org.
- 30367286 5y agoYou are correct. It was Archivist.
- xhkkffbf 5y agoI'm generally a big fan of the IA, but lately they've gotten lost on one big issue and this could hurt them. They tried to give away digital books still under copyright when the pandemic began. They seemed to think that this was somehow helping people who couldn't get to a physical library, but this was kind of a ruse. First, many bookstores were still open online and they were desparate for orders to stay in business. Second, many libraries were also operating, albeit under COVID rules. When they started this plan, I wrote my friends at the IA and begged them not to go down this route. They answered with lots of rhetoric about how they were some how helping and seemed oblivious to the claims of the authors and the libraries. So I'm not surprised that they're being sued. They went down this path willfully.
- Chris2048 5y agoI agree - A real, processional company shouldn't be skirting the law. IA is too important a source of legal archives, it shouldn't be risking that.
- dredmorbius 5y agoA real, professional company? You mean such as Facebook, Apple, Amazon, Netscape, or Google?
- Chris2048 5y agoNo, none of those
- dredmorbius 5y agoThe law is in large part a creation of the interests it serves --- in the case of copyright, that being publishers. Changing that regime requires challenging the assumptions and spotlighting the harms and costs. Which is what IA undertook. It's an activist cause, yes, and one aligned with the Archive's interests and mission. To that extent, IA's action is entirely commendable.
- mistrial9 5y agoI believe in the Internet Archive ! many happy returns
- wackget 5y agoArchive.org is blocked by UK mobile ISPs and has been for many years: https://www.privateinternetaccess.com/blog/internet-archive-wayback-machine-blocked-vodafone-three-o2-ee-can-change-that/ https://www.privateinternetaccess.com/blog/internet-archive-...
- dredmorbius 5y agoI'm somewhat encouraged to see that Kayle's view of Hathi Trust is largely that I've formed: all but entirely useless. Even Hathi's version of IA's Bookreader is crippled.