16 ms·
Whatever happened to QuickTime?
- maxbaines 5y agoOnly now did I realise QuickTime was made by Apple.
- peakaboo 5y agoReally? I remember their logo all over the software... And the mac-gray default look with big round buttons.
- toast0 5y agoAlso, if you had the misfortune of running the software on Windows, it insisted on trying to look like a mac. In it's meager defense, almost all media players tried to look non-native at the time.
- steve_adams_86 5y agoSkinning media players was one of the ways I got into graphic design (and became a software developer as a result). It was a ton of fun as a kid! I wonder if kids these days have anything like it. You sure can’t skin Spotify or Apple Music.
- pavo-etc 5y agoYou can actually skin Spotify! I used to run a different spotify theme through Spicetify. I think its CSS based.
- kalleboo 5y agoInfamously QuickTime player didn't even look like the Mac on the Mac itself. http://hallofshame.gp.co.at/qtime.html http://hallofshame.gp.co.at/qtime.html
- maxbaines 5y agoYes really.
- rasz 5y agoApple was on the forefront of computer Video. They founded ATG (advanced technology group) in late eighties and as a result came out with Road Apple Video codec (Road Pizza) in 1991. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Advanced_Technology_Group https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Advanced_Technology_Grou... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Video https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Video https://computerhistory.org/blog/quicktime-and-the-rise-of-multimedia/ https://computerhistory.org/blog/quicktime-and-the-rise-of-m... Fun facts: 1 Look up S3TC/DXTC texture compression, S3 copied Apple video codec verbatim and patented it for 3D graphics use. Somehow Apple missed that and didnt fight initial patent, resulting in losing couple iphone court cases 10 years later and purging S3TC from mobile. 2 Microsoft fucked up getting caught conspiring with Intel, paying third party contractor to steal QuickTime code https://www.theregister.com/1998/10/29/microsoft_paid_apple_150m/ https://www.theregister.com/1998/10/29/microsoft_paid_apple_... Thats the origin of the infamous "Microsoft saved Apple in the nineties" myth https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r5TdqfNE1QU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r5TdqfNE1QU
- majormajor 5y agoThat 1998 article is the first I'd seen claiming that the 1997 deal was a repayment, versus a purchase of non-voting shares as described at the time and announced by Jobs and Gates at Macworld. https://www.wired.com/1997/08/apple-takes-150-million-from-microsoft/ https://www.wired.com/1997/08/apple-takes-150-million-from-m... The register article quotes a note saying there was a significant MS payment for QT specifically, but doesn't actually claim that the 1997 investment wasn't an investment, as far as I can tell. Saving, of course, was always an exaggeration, as reported in that Wired article from the time too: "For Apple, the cash is symbolic. While the company has been bleeding money, it has about $1.2 billion in cash, according to its last quarterly earnings report, and doesn't need Microsoft's money to fend off immediate starvation." Recommitting to Office was a much bigger thing than the cash, probably,
- philistine 5y agoExactly. A commitment by Microsoft to support the Macintosh was more valuable than 150 million dollars. Such is the power of a good word.
- PopAlongKid 5y agoI'm proud to say that Quicktime remains the only Apple product or service I have ever purchased, and I've been using time-sharing computing since before Apple existed, and desktop computers since the TRS-80. Ironically, the original reason I bought it was due to needing, on very short notice, software to play a short video of that old "Get A Mac" ad on TV[1] with actors playing a young Steve Jobs and Bill Gates. [1]https://www.cultofmac.com/548865/apple-get-a-mac-ad-campaign-ends/ https://www.cultofmac.com/548865/apple-get-a-mac-ad-campaign...
- musicale 5y ago> I'm proud to say that Quicktime remains the only Apple product or service I have ever purchased, and I've been using time-sharing computing since before Apple existed, and desktop computers since the TRS-80. You might consider getting an Apple II. It has color graphics and a lot of good games. You can even add a Z-80 card to it to run CP/M software.
- throwmeariver1 5y agoHardware accelerated codecs happened.
- eyelidlessness 5y agoAnd HTML5 video, with royalty-free codecs eventually becoming more viable and capable while MPEG-LA licensing terms became more and more absurd.
- plorkyeran 5y agoAnd ffmpeg. An open-source, cross platform set of video libraries made the proprietary and system-specific ones a lot less interesting.
- kalleboo 5y agoAlthough back in the day there was an FFmpeg plugin for QuickTime! https://www.perian.org/ https://www.perian.org/
- tveyben 5y agoI got a copy of the QTVR Authoring Studio sw in mid 90’ and me (and 1-2 colleagues) created a full multinode qtvr demo of the place I worked at then - I think this was the most impressive task I have ever done (I was really young and in-experienced then…) - Some people thought it was ‘video’! qtvr was that impressive at that time… I just restored a DAT backup tape last month with the result (it was labeled ‘chicken backup 1996…’) and had to find an old Mac in order to watch it…!
- dmix 5y agoFound a YouTube video that shows a QuickTime VR demo someone pulled up from their garage: https://youtu.be/Y1lhZzAhN2Y https://youtu.be/Y1lhZzAhN2Y
- anthk 5y agoInstall Mac os 7-9 on a emulator. Get Virtual Paris from Macintosh Garden. Enjoy.
- dylan604 5y agoBack when the first digital cameras were coming out in the mid-90s (the type that saved to 3.5" floppy disks), a friend of mine and I were playing with QTVR. We had this brilliant idea of making websites for real estate listings to offer virtual tours. Turns out, in the mid-90s and its state of online capabilities, we were 15 years to soon. Nobody, and I mean not-one-damn-person that we showed our demo to understood where it could go.
- nuclearsugar 5y agoIn the VJ community, QuickTime is still used heavily due to the HAP codec being decompressed on the GPU and includes support for an alpha channel. https://hap.video/benchmarks.html https://hap.video/benchmarks.html
- aspenmayer 5y agoWhat software is used for VJ setups these days?
- djkoolaide 5y agoMixEmergency is what I use. I'm not sure whether or not it's QuickTime under the hood.
- nuclearsugar 5y agoResolume, VDMX, Modul8, TouchDesigner, MadMapper are the most common softwares that performers rely on
- aspenmayer 5y agoNeat, I’ve seen Resolume before and didn’t know how common it was. Thanks for the recs!
- ttoinou 5y agoHap video frames are stored in a MOV container, but you could use .MKV too. What exactly do you need from Quicktime ? I work with the Hap codec too, so Im interested :)
- nuclearsugar 5y agoHmm that's an interesting idea. After Effects still does not support exporting to the MKV container and so it doesn't fit into my typical rendering workflow. Hence I've stuck with MOV using HAP-alpha. As a experiment, I rendered out a PNG frame sequence (with alpha) and then used FFMPEG to render out both an MOV and MKV using the hap_alpha codec. --- When I tried importing both videos into Resolume then the MOV was successful but the MKV was rejected. Doesn't seem to be a supported. --- VLC could not playback the MKV. --- MPC-HC successfully played back the MKV and reported it was an rgba video. So it was interesting experiment, but not something that my necessary software pipeline supports. Here is some of my 3D animations for context. https://www.jasonfletcher.info/vjloops/ https://www.jasonfletcher.info/vjloops/
- JKCalhoun 5y agoSome memories, thoughts on Quicktime. Yes, I had heard it came out of ATG (Apple's Advanced Technology Group). Lots of cool things came out of ATG when it was still around. Initially though Quicktime could barely play wallet-size video but we still thought it was kind of cool. Peter Hoddie. Now that is a name I haven't heard in a long time. Some of the more ... eccentric engineers I met worked on the Quicktime team, ha ha. Some of us were of the opinion at the time that one of Quicktime's failings was the lack of codecs that shipped with the OS (Mac's System 7, 8, 9). Mention this around engineers on the QT team and the response was something like, "Codecs are for 3rd parties, Apple is not in the Codec business." Too bad. There was, perhaps undeserved, a sense that the Quicktime team were a bit haughty, maybe thought they were bigger than Apple. I say this regarding the time when Apple was circling the drain, so they may well have been correct. But I think Jobs return to Apple must have been another nail in the coffin for Quicktime. NeXT was still his baby and you suspect that Quicktime's not-invented-here status (and, quixotically, "here" in this case means "NeXT") might have meant Jobs had it in for the technology. Aside: Did Jobs shut down ATG? (I know he shut down Apple's technical library. Given, as I say, Apple circling the drain at the time, shutting down ATG might have seemed an act of financial prudence.) The NeXt app, Preview, was handed to me when Mac OS X was just getting going: Preview being wholly built upon the image offerings of AppKit (NSImage). Someone though had grafted a bit of Quicktime code that would add a handful of additional image types that AppKit did not support so Preview could also open BMP files, maybe Targa files, etc. It was just a sort of "image pre-processing" though to get the pixels from Quicktime — go straight to NSImage at that point. It looked to me that Quicktime was not going to be a First-Class Citizen in this new Mac OS X. Quicktime stuck around for quite a while longer though. I vaguely recall that the QT team had the cross-platform code that iTunes would need in order to serve iPod playlists for owners of Windows PC's. Basically Quicktime had something like the old Mac Toolbox (yes, Quickdraw included) that also ran under Windows. I came to like OS X though. It showed its UNIX pedigree by leaning more on open libraries like JPEGLib, TiffLib, PNGLib and other industry image frameworks. For a while there Apple was not trying to set the tone with proprietary formats (and just now FireWire comes to mind), but rather happy to follow where the "industry" was going. It seems only when Apple had regained a healthy market share again (about a decade later?) would it begin to resume introducing new standards and, in that regard, be more of a leader. Much too late for Quicktime.
- noduerme 5y agoWe had so much fun making teapots you could spin in QuicktimeVR when I was in junior high. I was still using it for putting out quick architectural design walkarounds until a couple years ago, when it became basically impossible for most people to run a version of Quicktime Player old enough to support it. After that I hacked together my own pipeline with ThreeJS/WebVR to turn panoramas into point to point walkarounds, and sent clients Oculus Go's as Christmas presents so they could view them through the browser. [Edit] Also, I just found a review of my favorite tech toy from the early 90s: The VideoSpigot card that let you actually digitize composite video on a home Mac. The quality was absolute shite and the memory and storage at the time were hardly capable of handling it, but it was the first time you could ever do something like that. It came bundled with Premiere! https://tidbits.com/1992/04/20/videospigot-review/ https://tidbits.com/1992/04/20/videospigot-review/
- tveyben 5y agoPlease share tips for how to consume qtvr on current sw! - I am sad that I am not being able to demo this old qtvr work (and recording a video of is my current alternative - it shows the point, but without the interactivity)
- tveyben 5y agoThese two articles/tools might be helpful https://blog.solidstatecode.com/converting-qtvr-panoramas-to-cubic/ https://blog.solidstatecode.com/converting-qtvr-panoramas-to... https://jurnsearch.wordpress.com/2019/04/07/how-to-get-an-old-quicktime-qvtr-onto-facebook-360/amp/ https://jurnsearch.wordpress.com/2019/04/07/how-to-get-an-ol...
- mmaunder 5y agoIt is impressive how Apple ProRes has become the standard intermediate video format for creators. It absolutely dominates the industry as the most popular way to exchange high quality compressed footage during post production.
- dylan604 5y agoCan ProRes be decoded at full bit depth on Windows now? The original decoder for Win would only decode at 8bit, and that was after Apple finally relented to offering a decoder for Windows at all.
- pipeline_peak 5y agoThe same thing that happened to Windows Media Player, they got replaced by streaming. Anyone tech savvy enough to still use local digital media playback uses freeware and open source like VLC which have a lot more compatibility. If you mean QuickTime as a framework, ffmpeg.
- csydas 5y agoI'm actually not sure this is entirely accurate; I used a Mac basically all my life (OS 7 all the way to current) and never had a Windows based machine until well into my 20's, so Quicktime and I were good friends for a long time. We also fought a lot when it came to the early days of torrenting anime and movies. I don't think Streaming and QuickTime really ever cross paths. It just didn't support as many fancy features that VLC and Media Player with the various Codec packs did, and later on players like MPV absolutely overwhelmed QuickTime in terms of playback and feature sets. I have vague memories that QuickTime used to come with the iTunes package for Windows, but I may be wrong on this so don't quote me on it. I do distinctly remember a period of time when many people who had Windows would ask how QuickTime got on their system. From the Mac side of things, QuickTime always felt like it didn't know what it should be. It was aways a sort-of media player without all the library features and playback features the other players had, along with a very basic media editor, media converter/exporter, and a few other bells and whistles that were neat but no one used and very few people wanted to pay for. Eventually I think Apple just realized there was no sense in maintaining it as a priority. As I wrote this post, I realized that on Big Sur, the dictionary no longer corrects QuickTime like it corrects iTunes or iMac or many other Apple products. (amusingly, apple seems to have had the self restraint not to assume you mean the company and not the fruit when writing apple, just a neat little fact ;)) Ultimately though, I don't think streaming and QuickTime really were enemies at all. I don't think streaming was even really a thing by the time QuickTime was really relegated to "that app you accidentally open movies in sometimes." Now it just is a media player that sticks around because you have to have a media player with your OS or the other OSes will make fun of you.
- chipotle_coyote 5y ago> I have vague memories that QuickTime used to come with the iTunes package for Windows, but I may be wrong on this so don't quote me on it. It did, because QuickTime is/was a media handling framework. The article isn't talking about the QuickTime Player application except incidentally. When you were using the Mac on OS 7 up until about 2011 (with the introduction of AVFoundation), just about everything that was playing media using Carbon or Cocoa API calls was using QuickTime under the hood. When Apple ported QuickTime Player to Windows, they ported the QuickTime framework, too -- and iTunes for Windows was built to use that. So QTP basically came along for the ride whether you wanted it to or not. I don't know if this is still the case, though.
- gcanyon 5y agoI still remember the amazement of watching a small video rendered into black and white pixels on an SE-30. Later I used TotallyHip's LiveStage to create some all-in-a-QuickTime-movie interactive gizmos. It's weird to see cutting-edge things fade into obscurity.
- sonicggg 5y agoYou could make a series out of these projects. Another one that suddenly died is RealPlayer, which used to be herpes back then.
- steve_adams_86 5y agoI remember clicking around that application as a kid trying to figure out what was good about it. I never figured it out. Seeing the splash because it decided it was the default application for some random format was always annoying. But back then you kind of kept everything around just in case - sometimes nothing could play a file except for real player so you’d begrudgingly let it play it for you.
- Sateeshm 5y agoThe only time I used to use real player was to download music from official CDs, the ones you couldn't just copy and paste. Otherwise the whole software looked and felt like malware
- hansel_der 5y agoimo it's the 'real' prefix that makes it shady. like realtek audio drivers taking more time to install than windows itself, or realme phones ...
- b215826 5y agoAnother one that died silently is Winamp. Oh man, I still remember those funky Winamp skins from the early 2000s.
- RedShift1 5y agoI still use Winamp every day and you can find the skins online easily.
- npteljes 5y agoNot silently at all. HackerNews alone has 165 discussions with WinAmp in the title, and some 2500 comments mentioning WinAmp. There are revival projects, a JS port, archive.org themselves use WinAmpJs to let you listen to their content, and so on. WinAmp has quite a legacy. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=winamp&sort=byPopularity&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...
- GeekyBear 5y agoQuicktime is the basis of the MP4 file format, so it's still in use pretty much everywhere. >MPEG-4 Part 14 is an instance of the more general ISO/IEC 14496-12:2004 (MPEG-4 Part 12: ISO base media file format) which is directly based upon the QuickTime File Format which was published in 2001. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MPEG-4_Part_14 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MPEG-4_Part_14
- DrSiemer 5y agoHaving to install QuickTime on Windows was far from a pleasant experience. If I remember correctly, it came with its own non-native UI and a massive pile of bloat you never used. It was incredibly slow. Before it (thankfully) disappeared altogether, we used the tiny and much faster "QuickTime alternative" player, to avoid needing to install the original.
- cm2187 5y agoI never understood why major OS developers never saw codecs as their responsibility. Instead, the native video player for each platform supports a very limited number of codecs, and sometimes isn’t even extendible with more codecs. You shouldn’t need a VLC. This has been the case since the beginning of the internet.
- CJefferson 5y agoIn many cases it was patent issues -- putting the codecs in the OS could significantly increase it's cost. I'm at least 15 years out of date, so this may be a much less serious issue nowadays (although also codec issues seem less serious, windows will just open most formats I try).
- cm2187 5y agoWell, how do ffmpeg and vlc go around that problem then? Most players will not even touch an mkv file, whatever the codec.
- soapdog 5y agoBecause there is no money in suing either projects. If a large company such as Apple ships all these codecs, patent holders will flock to try a quick cash grab. These litigations are time and money consuming.
- prmoustache 5y agoThey don't sue because they can't sue. Software patents aren't valid in europe.
- soapdog 5y agoThey can sue in the U.S.
- jasode 5y ago>, how do ffmpeg and vlc go around that problem then? The ffmpeg project does not distribute binaries with unlicensed or illegal code. E.g. if you want ffmpeg to use libdvdcss for decrypting DVDs or use libfdk-aac to encode aac/m4a without paying license royalties to Fraunhofer, the end user has to download those components and build a custom ffmpeg on their own. No legitimate website will host ffmpeg built with the "illegal/unlicensed" libraries. E.g. When the popular Zeranoe website hosted ffmpeg executables for download, it was only built with the free GNU components. The vlc project says they can include libdvdcss because they are a French company instead of American. E.g. Microsoft removes DVD playback from Windows 8 but VLC does not: https://www.zdnet.com/article/if-vlc-can-ship-a-free-dvd-player-why-cant-microsoft/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/if-vlc-can-ship-a-free-dvd-pla...
- runxel 5y agoI'm so happy QuickTime is finally gone for good. Hassling with it on Windows was always a big pain, with the versions being incompatible to one another. Also it left so much bloat and changed so many settings it looked like malware. But to be fair most of those crude media applications did that at this time. (Looking at you, Realplayer!) Also you needed the browser (Internet Explorer) plugin, because HTML5 video wasn't a thing, but everyone wanted to display their media. In a sidenote QuickTime also was part of other installers, too. One big CAD application needed QT on the system for displaying their help files (and I guess some media im-/export). It wouldn't even install without it. To make things worse, the installer itself – not the app, mind you – was in Java. To uninstall now you both need an old Java and an old QuickTime to be installed first...
- debug-desperado 5y agoI distinctly remember the QuickTime uninstaller had a checkmark option for “full uninstall” or similar that nuked my sound driver on Windows XP. Probably caused some missing DLL for the Sound Blaster card. The only way my high school self could fix it was full OS reinstall!
- ungamedplayer 5y agoYou just solved a mystery that has been knocking around in my mind for over a decade. Thank you.
- netsharc 5y agoAh geez, you remind me of the CD-ROM of "A Brief History of Time", which also used QuickTime videos: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jXh3WHb_ktc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jXh3WHb_ktc I wonder if I still have that CD somewhere in my basement, and if I could port it to a modern platform...
- discordance 5y agoVLC happened
- tehwebguy 5y agoI remember how much it sucked on Windows. It’s good on macOS as a standard desktop app these days with solid screen recording. Would be nice if it came with built in computer audio recording though, Soundflower seems to be behind by a few releases & Blackhole murdered my ability to use speakers on Zoom calls until I uninstalled it.
- mushyhammer 5y ago> solid screen recording You don’t need to open QuickTime anymore for that, just press cmd shift 5 I love the feature, but it doesn’t record the computer audio like it does on iOS. I hope it comes eventually, I don’t want to deal with bloated third party apps. I love that QuickTime lets you cut (not just trim) and join videos. It’s a fairly obscure feature that has helped me avoid iMovie for the past few years.
- jerrysievert 5y agoIf you use the app, you can specify the audio input in addition to recording the screen.
- mushyhammer 5y agoNo, you still cannot record the computer’s own output. The choices are microphone or “none”. The UI is literally the same. The only way to record the computer output is to install a kext or some other similar hack.
- jerrysievert 5y agohave you tried using black hole or sound flower? once you have a virtual audio interface installed, you can use the built in audio/midi editor, create an aggregate device, and use that from inside QuickTime. it's not super straightforward to set up, but once you have it set up, you can route audio anywhere and record that easily with QuickTime. using an extension for virtual audio, for a system designed for routing audio isn't really a "hack", and I'm kind of surprised that with the audio routing already available in macOS that it doesn't ship with a virtual audio device out of the box. the worst part is that most Mac owners don't know about "Audio MIDI Setup.app"
- nrjames 5y agoOn a related note, MacOS QuickTime Player has the ability to record the screen, or sections of it, and it is super easy to use. I wish MS would build a similarly easy-to-use tool into Windows. Is there a Win utility that is as easy? I’ve tried 3-4 but have struggle to make short recordings of portions of the screen without a struggle.
- kenrick95 5y agoOne trick I learnt is that you can do screen recording using PowerPoint https://twitter.com/MicrosoftEDU/status/1253778753530089472 https://twitter.com/MicrosoftEDU/status/1253778753530089472
- tehbeard 5y agoThe Xbox game bar app? I've used it to record short segments at work of issues in chromed, etc.
- Jaxan 5y agoYep this. It took me a long time to find this app, since I am not a gamer.
- nsonha 5y ago...and iOS screen, I use that to stream iOS screen to desktop so that I can share screen on my Mac with it
- lelandfe 5y agoYou can bypass the app! Hit Cmd-Shift-5 to get the exact same interface from anywhere on MacOS. Makes it much easier to record things while on a separate space, for instance.
- grishka 5y agoModern-ish macOS has a built-in screen recorder. Try pressing Cmd+Shift+5
- jeroenhd 5y agoFor recording a single application or the full screen, you can use the Xbox game bar which is built into Windows. I don't know about recording part of your screen, though, I haven't tried it so I don't know if it's possible with the built in functionality. I'd probably go for OBS but that's far from easy to work with.
- quitit 5y agoNoticeably absent from this discussion: Microsoft's attempts to kill Quicktime(amongst a range of competitor technologies), and their reasonable success in these pursuit. Relevant excerpt: Microsoft Threatens QuickTime Partners In addition to providing roadblocks to QuickTime running on Windows, Microsoft also worked to stop QuickTime by threatening its partners to abandon licensing, distribution, or development of anything related to QuickTime, or else prepare to face the retribution Microsoft could deliver. Hardware: Microsoft leaned on its Windows PC OEMs to prevent them from bundling QuickTime; trial testimony revealed specifically how Microsoft took quick steps to block Compaq's licensing of QuickTime. While Compaq was enthusiastic about licensing QuickTime to help differentiate its PCs from those of rivals, after Microsoft heard about the plans and expressed its disapproval, the company suddenly withdrew and refused to continue any talks with Apple. Applications: Microsoft also jumped on Avid Cinema, a new consumer video editing product based on QuickTime that long time Apple partner Avid was preparing to release. Microsoft told Avid engineers, "You need to rip QuickTime out of your product if you want to be in this channel." Months later, Avid announced a partnership with Microsoft on its new AAF format for multimedia authoring. Drivers: Microsoft also pounced on Truevision, a video capture card vendor. After learning that the company was developing QuickTime drivers for its video capture cards, Microsoft invested in the company with the proviso that the company could not market, brand, or refer to the drivers as a QuickTime driver, and could only bundle them with a specific application, not offer the drivers for sale separately. Advanced Authoring Format Microsoft had backed up its threats to jump into the media authoring business to kill QuickTime entirely by developing the Advanced Authoring Format, the last missing component of Microsoft's rival offerings. In June 1998, Microsoft advised Apple that its only remaining choice in the matter would be to agree to a broad technology sharing plan that donated its technology to Microsoft and abandoned its own competitive efforts: •Apple had to agree to cross-license its codecs and collaborate with Microsoft on all future codec development •Apple had to adopt Microsoft's DirectX run-time platform on Windows in place of QuickTime •Apple had to adopt Microsoft's proprietary streaming technology •Apple had to adopt Microsoft's new proprietary AAF file format for media authoring http://www.roughlydrafted.com/RD/RDM.Tech.Q1.07/5F0C866C-6DDF-4A9A-9515-531B0CA0C29C.html http://www.roughlydrafted.com/RD/RDM.Tech.Q1.07/5F0C866C-6DD...
- Gunax 5y ago
- crossroadsguy 5y agoI feel saddened by the pseudo halo Apple software gets to be associated with for no valid reason. While it’s the opposite. Apple software is utterly mediocre and more or less it has been so. What Apple has managed to do is a disgustingly closed ecosystem and a genius racket of a marketing and has built an aura around itself. It’s so obscene that when it brings a feature on its phone that was available on Android for years, and was released on Android without any fanfare - merely as an essential feature, Apple pushes it, and the media, bloggers, and many users lap it up, as if Apple just figured out perpetual energy. I seriously doubt the scene will be any different if Apple tomorrow announces a mechanical trolley for $9989 and says it runs on Apple exclusive TrueWheel™. It feels such journalists and bloggers live in a different universe and no I’m not even talking about Apple shills (some of them have become “critic” of late; jg et al), I am talking about the ones who are probably not shills. > QuickTime was bigger than Apple itself, so widely known that many who used it on their PCs weren’t even aware that it was an Apple product Alright, definitely an alternate universe.
- Gunax 5y agoPerhaps Apple does not invent it, but perfects it in a 'no wireless, less space than a Nomad' way.