3 ms·
I believe this was a risk spacex were deliberately taking to get more satellites launched on a single rocket. By launching to a lower altitude initially, then
by londons_explore 5y ago
I believe this was a risk spacex were deliberately taking to get more satellites launched on a single rocket.
By launching to a lower altitude initially, then more of the propulsion effort is done by the satellites themselves, and less is done by the rocket. All other things being equal, this simply means put more fuel in the satellites, and less in the rocket. Total mass is the same.
But all other things are not equal. Specifically, the satellites have 'engines' which have over 10x the specific Impulse - ie. Thrust per kilogram of fuel used.
So it makes huge sense to launch the satellites to a super low orbit and use their far more efficient engines to boost themselves up.
With the downside being the satellites ion drive engines take a long time to do the job, and if they aren't strong enough to fight against the headwind of atmospheric drag during that time, then the mission will fail.
In this case, spacex just pushed a little far.
- bell-cot 5y agoIIR, SpaceX talks up the initial low orbits as an important anti-space-junk measure. Starting low, any Starlink satellites which fail to power up & orient & respond to ground control commands will be fail-safe de-orbit by atmospheric drag. And they will have spent zero time at more-viable altitudes, where they might be a hazard to operational satellites.
- londons_explore 5y agoSpace junk isn't really a concern at any of the orbits spacex uses. They only talk about it because this anti space junk launch plan happens to be the cheapest, and it distracts from other environmental issues they don't look so good in.
- cma 5y agoIt's a concern, it is just that it may only knock out space access for a few years instead of hundreds, and it may destabilize nuclear détente, orienting things towards theater missiles for a while.
- gameswithgo 5y ago
- bburrito 5y agoI think that you have a great argument for what they were doing. But one thing to consider too is that the space weather events they launched into were known 2-3 days out. So if it was a concern they would have scrubbed the launch. I think they saw it as a good opportunity for a test and launched even though they knew they would lose some satellites. What was different about the ones successfully launched versus the ones that didnt make it?