4 ms·
People always say the same thing when someone is critical of crypto. Its too early! I mean after all, we are only 13 years in. Or: there is a lot of bullshit
by bawolff 5y ago
People always say the same thing when someone is critical of crypto.
Its too early!
I mean after all, we are only 13 years in.
Or: there is a lot of bullshit but the interesting things are outside of your echo chamber.
But then never link to such counter examples. At best people talk about filecoin, which does pass the bar of not being a literal scam, but still makes no sense from a product-market fit (storage has 3 metrics to judge by: price, retrieval latency, reliability. Filecoin is order of magnitudes worse than competitiors on all metrics).
I don't think i am irrationally biased against bitcoin & friends, i actually think the original paper was quite ingenious. However its been over a decade - we're well past the "benefit of the doubt" stage and into the "put up or shut up" stage when it comes to cryptocurrency.
- sneak 5y agohttps://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/03/09/ukraine-has-received-close-to-100-million-in-crypto-donations/ https://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/03/09/ukraine-has-rec... This happened primarily in a matter of hours. In cash. Across borders. Without being subject to sanctions or restrictions by any country. It may not be your use case, but it has definitely "put up".
- sgift 5y agoIt obviously isn't cash, it isn't even money - that's the reason the amount received is stated in something else, namely dollars, which this has to be exchanged into to be useful. What happened here is a wire transfer, not different from me sending money from my bank account to someone else bank account. Just with two additional transformation steps (make money into whatever crypto, make whatever crypto back into money).
- sneak 5y agoIt is very different than you sending money via an intermediary bank. I dare you to describe a method of wire transfer to Kyiv that works in that quantity and timescale and is practically usable by the recipient that quickly and cannot be blocked by your local government's policies. There simply isn't anything close to that. People that think that this is the same as a wire via a regulated bank are ignorant of the specifics of each type of payment. Cryptocurrency is indeed cash, and is useful the same way cash is useful.
- di4na 5y agoNone because if it was a high quantity method it would get regulated or banned by society The regulations exist for a reason. The reason crypto do not have them is because there is no quantity. Not because it is magically immune to existing in societies
- roenxi 5y agoSociety has banned the consumption of illegal drugs (!). How is that ban going vis a vis shutting the market down? Ditto copyright infringement. Some things the government cannot ban. Without the ability to create and control chokepoints like banking institution, it may be impossible to stop people voting with their feet when it comes to international crypto transfers. Especially once people figure out what privacy preserving designs work in practice. Given the whispers around unbanking political protesters, at some point it may become necessary to deal in crypto to have a political opinion. They can't arrest everyone.
- phatfish 5y agoAs the parent said, if Crypto ever became a threat to government control of their economies it will be regulated. In fact the blockchain protocol provides the audit trail to enable the regulation. Any anonymous chains like Monero will be blacklisted and only exist in an island where its economy is limited to certain illegal commodities, with the off ramp to wash it clean complex. I don't want some unknown group of Crypto Bros completely outside my control running the economy of my country. At least in a democracy the people have some control.
- SilasX 5y ago"Cryptocurrency has no practical use case." 'Yes it does, I got money to refugees when it was otherwise impossible.' "Well... you shouldn't be able to do that."
- throwawaydroid 5y ago> more than $60 million of the $100 million was received in the main fund run by Kuna, the Ukrainian crypto exchange. So the majority of crypto donations were from Ukrainians on Kuna exchange; hardly a prime example of global crypto's good will. Also $100M is kind of small when you consider it next to the $14B congress has promissed to Ukraine. Then consider the total $1.5T sticker price of the congressional spending bill that $14B was a part of and it all seems insignificant. In short we can and should give more to Ukraine.
- chrischen 5y agoPayPal and bank wire transfers still work in Ukraine, so this not a particularly good example of a crypto use case. Russian hackers demanding ransom payments in bitcoin—thereby circumventing economic sanctions—now that is a legitimately illegitimate use case for crypto.
- sneak 5y agoTry sending PayPal from Russia to Ukraine. PayPal requires identity and permission. I am barred from using it, for example. No barriers to me donating to Ukraine via cryptocurrency.
- phatfish 5y agoUkraine is not short of donations, they don't need money from the country currently destroying their cities and committing war crimes. What they are asking for is more sanctions (which the Crypto utoptia is supposed to make impossible) to try and force the hand of a mad dictator without ushering in WW3. Crypto is barely a footnote.
- chrischen 5y agoI just sent money to Ukraine via PayPal and the Ukrainian recipient confirmed they were able to add it to their bank card. I’m not sure why you are barred but if I sent you crypto you’d probably need verification to withdraw it to fiat as well.
- hiq 5y ago> Try sending PayPal from Russia to Ukraine. Sounds like the real problem is having RUB. > No barriers to me donating to Ukraine via cryptocurrency. In this case you're not starting with RUB, so you're solving a different problem.
- bawolff 5y agoFair enough - I actually do think bitcoin is the only use case of this crypto stuff that remotely makes sense. Its not without issue, but its passed the proof of concept stage into something sort of useful for some people.
- dmitriid 5y agoAh yes. Desperate people in need have received a bunch of fantasy novelty tokens that they are going to use... how exactly?
- flaque 5y ago> Its too early! I think most critics of crypto come into the conversation with a "crypto is bad, and so I must find ways to reinforce this belief", and it's relatively obvious that the critic doesn't have the perquisite knowledge to craft a critique that can be responded to easily. Specifically, a critic might say "the set A is bad". The critic is under the assumption that the set A is small, perhaps a few items, and they've seen the majority of them. But the "defender" knows that the set is hundreds of thousands of items, but still has only seen a few of them. The critic operates under the assumption of maybe 4/5 items are bad, and the defender is operating under the assumption that 4/100,000,000 are bad. So when a critic asks you to link to projects, there's a problem: even if the defender shows 100 projects, and the critic rejects all of them, then it doesn't change the defender's position, because 104/100,000,000 is still a small survey. Sane "defenders" don't need to disagree with the critics on their points. They can differ primarily in seeing a much, much larger, unexplored search space. If you assume the space has been fully searched, then its safe to stand back and critique. However, many folks conducting the search see much farther than you do, and see the entirely unexplored space as quite large. And so, it’s reasonable for the defender to not want to engage in your risky position, that assumes snake eyes for the next 100,000 dice rolls. If you see how large the unexplored search space is, then it sounds ridiculous to declare the entire thing “done and bad”. It’s the same reason why you may choose not to engage with the flat earther. It’s hard to engage with a position so disconnected from rationality. That said, there’s plenty of people in crypto who are equally disconnected from reality, either because they too only see a small search space, and have declared the contents “good” with little examination, or because they see the large search space and assume all dice rolls will come up as 6’s. Those folks tend to create a cycle. Folks with no opinion see crazy crypto person, and develop into their own crazy anti crypto person. Neither party is acting rational, because both have claimed certainty with extremely little working information. That said, there's other projects that are worth while, here's some to add to your N: - https://strangemood.org https://strangemood.org (decentralized competitor to steam; this is what I work on) - https://www.helium.com https://www.helium.com (incentive layer for the LoRaWAN network) - https://tea.xyz https://tea.xyz (new homebrew) - https://handshake.org/ https://handshake.org/ ("really" decentralized DNS) - (Compound / Aave / Solend) (decentralized loans) > still makes no sense from a product-market fit (storage has 3 metrics to judge by: price, retrieval latency, reliability. Filecoin is order of magnitudes worse than competitiors on all metrics) We use Filecoin and IPFS and have found solutions to these issues typically, and are happy "customers". It's also worth noting that we _can't_ use S3, or traditional cloud hosting, which therefore adds a new metric for us to judge storage on: decentralization.
- olalonde 5y ago> I mean after all, we are only 13 years in. How long did it take for gold to become a store of value? I am guessing millenia.
- hotpotamus 5y agoProbably more like 13 billion years after it was first created.
- arbol 5y agoConsidering how long it can take a SAAS company to build one product, 13 years and counting is not that long for re-platformimg the global economy.