3 ms·
People embrace romantic notions about warfare and like to imagine a fanastical version of it. Call of Duty does very well! We tend to think of warfare as a game
by wolverine876 5y ago
People embrace romantic notions about warfare and like to imagine a fanastical version of it. Call of Duty does very well! We tend to think of warfare as a game.
The reality is the polar opposite of a game: Games have rules and fairness; warfare has almost no rules (by definition - it exists where rules and laws fail), and nobody wants a fair fight - they want a massacre (or surrender). Games have no stakes - they are for entertainment, and no matter how many points you score, you drink a beer with your buddies that night; warfare is life and death - you literally might not sleep again, some of your friends in your unit will likely be killed in the next battle, your loved ones and society might be destroyed, and the brutality and pain is commoplace. And the responsibility, stress and pressure are enormous - if you mess up, you don't kick the ball out of bounds, your friends die.
In histories of some wars I've read about - and it's probably true for others others - describe that before the war people are very excited for it; I have felt that powerful urge myself. IIRC, people had picnics to watch early US Civil War battles, and soldiers can be very excited to. The reality then hits quickly, as people experience things too horrible to describe on HN, including the horror of killing other human beings, often in gruesome ways. Even in the relatively low-level wars the US recently was involved in, even the very well-trained, very safe (relative to other wars) soldiers who have a safe home to return to, have very high PTSD and suicide rates. As has been noted throughout history, warfare changes the survivors for the worse.
Maybe there are some things that could be gained from games, but I imagine training would be far better. Imagine someone who played software developer games (if only such fun toys existed!) as preparation for being an actual software developer. It might be a nice intro, but mostly irrelevant to actual training.
EDIT: To be clear, I think the article may be more descriptive - how certain games affect thinking - than prescriptive - 'we should learn through games'.