4 ms·
This is theoretical preprint that reinterpret some previous experimental results. The fine technical details are well over my head, but I hope this is accurate
by gus_massa 5y ago
This is theoretical preprint that reinterpret some previous experimental results. The fine technical details are well over my head, but I hope this is accurate enough.
There is a very strong experimental support for the "old" Higgs Boson discovered in 2012 that has a mass of 125Gev, and there is some recent weak experimental support for another "new" Higgs Boson with a mass of 95GeV. (For comparison, the mass of a proton is ~0.9GeV.)
In this preprint, they propose that there is a family of tree Higgs Bosons. The "old" one, the "new" one and a third one yet to be detected. The structure of the family forces some of the properties of the bosons and how they interact with the other particles.
The hard part is tweaking the properties of the family of Higgs Bosons so they predict the results of the experiments where the 125GeV and 95GeV are seen, but they don't cause weird results in all the other thousands of experiments where the Higgs Bosons have a negligible effect.
- progrus 5y ago> The hard part is tweaking the properties of the family of Higgs Bosons so they predict the results of the experiments where the 125GeV and 95GeV are seen, but they don't cause weird results in all the other thousands of experiments where the Higgs Bosons have a negligible effect. These don’t sound like “risky predictions” at all! We already know everything that the model should output? Popper is spinning in his grave. And a real theoretical physicist would have been able to tell you “95GeV” before seeing it.
- gus_massa 5y agoI agree that "predictions" is not the right word. It's easy to explain the problem looking at the Figure 7 of the preprint. The fist graph shows how many times an experiment produced a pair of photons. The x axis is the energy of the photons, and the y axis is the number of events (I'm not sure about the scale here). The dashed line is the theoretical result without the second boson IIUC. The green zone is the range of a difference of ±σ. The yellow zone is the range of a difference of ±2σ. The continuous line is the experimental data. As expected, the experimental data is close to the theoretical result, but it is not exactly equal. It moves most of the time in the green zone of ±σ. Sometimes it moves in the yellow zone of green zone is the range of a difference of ±2σ. The interesting part is that in some parts it goes outside the yellow some. For those energies the theoretical model is too different of the experimental data. Back to your objection, the idea in the paper is to make a model with a few parameters, and then optimize the parameters until the curve of the new model fits the experimental data as much as possible. It's not enough to say 95GeV, the model has more parameters and also they must verify that the new model modifies the range of energies where the difference is big, but does not modify too much the other ranges.
- progrus 5y agoWell also, in my partly-serious physics trolling I left out that maybe the model could then predict a value for the next in the Higgs family (if such a thing exists), which according to my limited understanding doesn’t seem impossible.
- sideshowb 5y agoThanks for the summary! I wonder if you could eli5: I thought the Higgs was what gave other particles mass? How can it be heavier than the particles it gives mass to?
- harshreality 5y agoIt's the Higgs field that gives particles mass. https://www.britannica.com/video/185531/explanation-field-Higgs-particles-mass https://www.britannica.com/video/185531/explanation-field-Hi...
- felipellrocha 5y agoOh, sure, sure. What is the field?
- ajkjk 5y agoIt is just one of the fields. The one whose interactions give particles mass. Modern physics has been working on finding and naming all of them.
- ericbarrett 5y agoIt gives some particles some mass. I had to look it up, because I'm no physicist, but e.g. most of a proton's mass comes from the strong force binding energy of its quarks.
- ajkjk 5y agoThat's true. I should have specified, fundamental particles. Although we're not sure about neutrinos.
- gus_massa 5y ago> I thought the Higgs was what gave other particles mass? Sorta yes, but it's more complicated. > How can it be heavier than the particles it gives mass to? There are a few bad explanations about the Higgs boson floating around. I hate all of them. I wish I can write a good one, but it's very difficult task. One of the explanations is the "prime minister" analogy, that says that the usual particles are like a prime minister, and the Higgs bosons are like the press reporters that follow the prime minister around. So even if the prime minister has no mass, the big bundle of the prime minister and the journalist has mass. In this explanation it's difficult to imagine why the mass of the bundle is smaller than the mass of each journalist. [Did I already said that I hate this explanation?] Oversimplifying toooo much: The idea is that the usual particles have something that look like mass because they bounce against the Higgs boson. They don't absorb the Higgs boson. They are not surrounded by Higgs bosons. They just bounce against a Higgs boson from time to time, and that somehow cause that they look like particles with mass. It's weird, very weird. The analogy does not give an intuitive explanation, but this can be formalized and the equations model the experiment accurately. But actually, the usual particles are not bouncing against Higgs boson, they are bouncing against the non-zero vacuum expectation value Higgs field. What is the Higgs field? What is the vacuum expectation value? Why it is not zero like in most fields? Those are hard questions! I watched the video in Encyclopædia Britannica linked in the sibling comment, and it's quite good. I hope it makes thing more clear than my explanation.