3 ms·
"Packing", as in, withholding hearings on a candidate for over a year in the hopes that you could have him replaced with a partisan of your own? So that court i
by jfengel 5y ago
"Packing", as in, withholding hearings on a candidate for over a year in the hopes that you could have him replaced with a partisan of your own? So that court is now nearly 70% members of your own party?
I am not a lawyer, and I have had real lawyers of both parties insist to me that Thomas is, in fact, a well-qualified and competent jurist. But as a non-lawyer, this does not strike me as a serious way to talk about the law.
- s1artibartfast 5y ago>Packing", as in, withholding hearings on a candidate for over a year in the hopes that you could have him replaced with a partisan of your own? So that court is now nearly 70% members of your own party? No, he is talking about packing as in expanding the number of justices beyond 9. This would entirely delegitimize the court. This is a serious and legitimate concern. Withholding votes is another legitimate issue, but largely resolved at this point. The president selects the candidates, but you need 51 senate votes to confirm.
- jfengel 5y agoYes, I know what he's talking about. I am reminding him that the rules are the rules. If the President and Congress are legally allowed to expand the Supreme Court, it delegitimizes the court not one whit more than following the laws to refuse any Presidential nominee indefinitely for purely political reasons. The ship of "delegitimizing" has sailed. The court is already overwhelmingly full of his partisans, and will be for the rest of his life (and mine, for that matter). Which makes his one-sided carping about which rules need to be followed to the letter, and which ones have some kind of unwritten spirit, look like poor reasoning from somebody whose job is supposed to be entirely about his reasoning skills.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI get your "the rules are the rules" argument, but there is still a difference between "abusing" the rules to put 1 justice on the court verses putting 4 more on the court.
- jfengel 5y agoIs that difference something other than "we didn't think of it first?"
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- s1artibartfast 5y agoNo, it is a matter of magnitude. A first grader can tell 4 is more than 1. Is a moot point because senate Democrats know that 4 is greater than 1 and don't have the appetite for such an escalation
- salawat 5y agoI'd say he's entitled to speak his mind, same as everyone else. The fact he feels the need to be as talkative as he's gotten in the last decade or so is a sign of how royally screwed things seem to be getting. I'm glad he's speaking out more. Someone damn well needs to. The level of cavalier attitude taken toward the maintenance of institutional integrity in civic life suggests frank conversations on the topic need to be had and reaffirmed.
- smt88 5y agoIf he cared about institutional integrity, he would have asked his wife not to try to illegally overturn the most recent presidential election. Or he would vote against partisan gerrymandering, or he would have spoken out about the Jan 6 insurrection in general. Whatever motivation he has, it's not about maintaining traditional institutions. He is the most partisan and unprincipled judge on the Supreme Court. There is no philosophical consistency to his decisions other than "whatever my party wants".
- salawat 5y agoNot everyone sees the protests of the 6th as insurrection, the actions of a small number of idiots aside. This is the central problem of people these days. An unwillingness to even recognize that priors different than their own are worthy of recognition and action. I was talking to a relative about it recently, but in the context of wider adoption of mail-in ballots to increase voting accessibility, balanced against ensuring the ultimate provenance of a vote is actually associated with who it claims to be. Yes, the absentee ballot and mail-in is awesome for not having to go to a poll if you're disabled or what have you. It also means, anyone who gets access to voter lists, envelopes, ballots, and enough stamps get to chuck in whatever they want, with minimal informing of an actual inactive voter that a vote was cast in their stead. This is a glaring hole. There is no answer to it from the side of people who think access is more important, but for the person who deems integrity more important, the access prioritizer completely debases the entire enterprise. As someone who seriously wanted to tackle the electronic voting system issue over the years, it is not an easy problem, and does not lend itself to an easy technical solution. It's a people problem first and foremost. Right now, there just isn't the mutual trust in each other for it not to be seen as anything but potentially malicious. It sucks, but it is what it is, and that's a massive disappointment and reminder of why it seems like we just can't have nice things.