5 ms·
> And of course, in the end even talking about utility assumes the price someone is willing to pay reflects their utility gain. This is the most fundamental ass
by lotsofpulp 5y ago
> And of course, in the end even talking about utility assumes the price someone is willing to pay reflects their utility gain. This is the most fundamental assumption in economics, but it's pretty clear that in the real world this is not the case. Especially for luxury goods such as air travel.
Why? I would expect luxury goods to reflect utility very accurately since they are not necessary purchases.
If you are paying $1k to go travel to Disney World, then that seems like a pretty good signal that the flight to Disney World gave you at least $1k worth of utility.
- geysersam 5y agoDoes the $1k to go to Disney land buy the same utility as the $1k average yearly income in Bangladesh? Or the utility a 80th percentile household in the US could buy for the same amount.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI have never heard of utility to be used as an objective measure. It is subjective, symbolizing an individual’s (perceived) value of a transaction relative to other possible transactions. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utility https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utility > a utility function that represents a single consumer's preference ordering over a choice set but is not comparable across consumers. This concept of utility is personal and based on choice
- solveit 5y agoPhilosophers spend a lot of time trying to figure out a way to define an objective measure of utility that can be compared across different people. This is necessary for many formulations of utilitarianism. And probably many HN commenters are more familiar with the word in this context. That economists use the same word with a much more limited scope does tend to detract from discussions like this, I feel.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThis discussion is specifically about economics, linked to an article in a prominent economics publication.
- geysersam 5y agoThe paper talks about maximizing "welfare" what is that if not an objective measure of utility?
- geysersam 5y agoOf course utility is used as an objective measure. That's the basic foundation of utilitarianism, and utilitarianism is the ethical foundation of market economics.
- solveit 5y ago> even talking about utility assumes the price someone is willing to pay reflects their utility gain It does. It reflects their utility gain relative to the utility they gain by spending that money somewhere else, or just keeping the money for the future. People not made of straw do not generally believe that the price someone is willing to pay reflects somebody else's utility. Nor are they unaware of the tendency for marginal utility to decrease.