6 ms·
I hate all these new 3D imaging things. I wonder how much difference there really is with the older tech based on looking at outcomes. For standard surveillanc
by giantg2 5y ago
I hate all these new 3D imaging things.
I wonder how much difference there really is with the older tech based on looking at outcomes. For standard surveillance, does the new 3D dental xray actually benefit me? Granted the cost is low (<10% normal yearly exposure), but I still wonder.
- abxytg 5y agoOften it's a volumetric view of the same data, which is usually viewed as 2D slices. Doctors tend to prefer the slices.
- giantg2 5y agoYeah, but what are they doing with that to benefit me? Does it identify dental issues that traditional imaging misses? How common is that?
- wincy 5y agoI remember almost fainting when my doctor showed me the MRI scans of my brain. It doesn’t bother me to see someone else’s scan, but I just couldn’t stomach looking at mine at all, seeing my optic nerve and my eyeballs and everything.
- jhgb 5y agoAnd I got my MRI brain scan and I had absolutely zero emotional reaction to it, except for curiosity. But then again I'm a schizoid so that was very likely anyway...
- fedorareis 5y agoWell according to the article in this case 3D imaging is reducing false positives by about 6% which seems like an actual benefit. Would it be a benefit if it is easier to maintain or easier for the doctor to read?
- dontreact 5y agoIt will take a long time to sort this out. I think that eventually, the ability for AI to review 3D in greater detail will improve on false positives and false negatives. For CT vs. XRay there have already been 2 long term randomized controlled trials that look at outcomes for lung cancer screening. PLCO, the XRay study, was not effective in improving long term outcomes like mortality. NLST, the CT study, showed a 20% reduction in mortality. With more modern techniques that actually look at the tumor in 3D NELSON in Europe has seen even better mortality reduction. DBT is newer so A) Radiologists are not as good at reading it yet B) the long term evidence hasn't accumulated yet, but I am definitely optimistic that it will present a big improvement over the previous state of the art. As mentioned elsewhere in the thread, this false positive number is already better than the existing state of the art for 2D.
- stewbrew 5y agoPlease read the original article linked from the axios piece.