5 ms·
Those annual trainings are there to show compliance. This prevents pro active investigations by authorities into business conduct. Without those corporations ar
by hef19898 5y ago
Those annual trainings are there to show compliance. This prevents pro active investigations by authorities into business conduct. Without those corporations are free to engage in all kinda of shady business behaviour. And when something turns sideways, the offending employees passed the training, so the company is shielded, to an extend.
- akhmatova 5y agoThose annual trainings are there to show compliance. And also obeisance -- on the part of the person required to sit through these trainings (and pretend that they had some connection to reality).
- leetcrew 5y agomeh. I'd be happy to sit in a chair and watch nonsensical videos for $100/hr any time you like.
- kabdib 5y agoNot when you have a deadline and your stuff is behind, you don't :-) Happily, it was better than that. Most of these courses were online, and you could just let the videos of actors working through scenarios run in the background and then answer some simple questions. The questions never varied and the correct answer was usually pretty obvious (e.g., don't pick any answer that includes hiding a body).
- mupuff1234 5y agoAlso it's not like you can fail the test, it just keeps you on the question till you select the right answer.
- mstipetic 5y agoFfs
- lostlogin 5y ago> The questions never varied and the correct answer was usually pretty obvious Siemens ask different questions in reruns of end tests, vary the order the questions are in, and also ask questions you can’t answer from understanding the topic. Eg ‘what colour was the background of the graph demonstrating the effect?”
- NullPrefix 5y ago>what colour was the background of the graph demonstrating the effect? Sounds like a bad test. You are not supposed to fill your head with details like what color shoes your teacher was wearing.
- akhmatova 5y agoAgain -- it's a test of obedience (and a CYA ritual for the company's owners). It's not supposed to impart useful information, otherwise make sense.
- HWR_14 5y agoIf I have a deadline and stuff is behind, it's my job to tell my boss. It's their job to get an exception so I take the training after the deadline. Also probably their job to get some of my tasks reassigned.
- lostlogin 5y agoWatching company policy videos wears thin after about 2 minutes, but I wasn’t paid anything like $100/hr… My method was to open another browser tab, then you can play several at the same time. The next company I was at prevented that somehow. So I opened a few different web browsers. Then they broke that and also made each clip about 2 mins long and had loads of them, so you can’t even queue them up in one browser.
- akhmatova 5y agoIt's not about the videos. The main point it enforces is that you're supposed to hold hour tongue as your company engages in a kinds of intrinsically abusive and unethical practices (as long as you, personally, are not breaking the law). Still sound like $100/hr of fun?
- robertlagrant 5y ago> the offending employees passed the training This is the definition of ineffective training :)
- amalcon 5y agoIt's effective in its real goal (preventing fines), just not in its stated goal (preventing bribery). Of course this means that it's at best a half-truth to call it training (a more accurate name would be e.g. "indemnity procedure").
- robertlagrant 5y agoMight be effective indemnity, but it's ineffective training :-)
- wolverine876 5y agoIf they are aware of what is right and wrong, it is effective.
- mark-r 5y agoIf they are aware but still do wrong anyway, I'd argue it's NOT effective.
- jjkaczor 5y agoExactly - all they are is formal "risk mitigation"
- wolverine876 5y agoPeople downplay such training, but imagine the environment without it. Imagine if nobody officially talked about corrupt practices: it would create a very dark place for such things to occur, nobody would know what the rules are or what to do, and especially the silence would speak very loudly. Edit: By training everyone, not just the people directly involved with such situations, anyone considering corrupt acts will know that everyone - from the tech support person who helps them send the corrupt message to the receptionist who takes the corrupt call to the finance underling who mails the check - everyone will recognize it. There is no talking the rube into helping them; there are eyes everywhere, all the time.
- burntoutfire 5y agoPeople know that what they hear in the training videos and how they must really act are two different things. If you find out that your boss's boss is corrupting goverment officials in Poland to get a $100m contract (a real case BTW, involving one of MS's big competitors), do you really think the company wants you to raise alarm and blow that contract? What good does it do to your boss's boss career, or the shareholders?
- whimsicalism 5y agoI think Enron would have been better off if someone had blown the whistle early. Probably would still be in existence. Me, I'd be more likely to narc to the government, especially if I can get a share of the penalty like SEC narcs do.
- HWR_14 5y ago> Enron would have been better off if someone had blown the whistle early Blown the whistle to who and about what. As I understand it, Enron's brilliance was breaking up the actions so each low ranking employee was looking at legal things and you had to be quite high up to see the issues
- wolverine876 5y agoIt's not a perfect solution, but nothing is. The training shifts the equation significantly relative to no training (as described in the GP). Our alternative to perfect solutions, if that's what we require, is to do nothing. > What good does it do ... the shareholders? Note that we commonly talk as if people will naturally care about the interests of one group of humans they don't know, the shareholders, but not another group, the public. Various rules say you should care about both (and there are many more rules regarding the latter).