3 ms·
How many monopolies were lost without government intervention? I wouldn't call Apple's OS a monopoly, and even if it were, it wasn't for 10 years since Windows
by mattmaroon 18y ago
How many monopolies were lost without government intervention? I wouldn't call Apple's OS a monopoly, and even if it were, it wasn't for 10 years since Windows overtook it in 1990.
I'm trying to think of genuine monopolies that faded away without intervention and am coming up blank.
- davidw 18y agoGood question. I suppose you'd want to dig around dead technologies... perhaps someone had a monopoly in the wooden wagon spoke business or something like that, that simply ceased to matter as an industry.
- dnaquin 18y agowestern union?
- davidw 18y agoStill the only way that millions of poor people working in rich countries have to send money home. If I recall correctly, at least.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoI'm outsourcing to South America and I've been using PayPal. There were a few other options, as I recall. A service called Payoneer, some others. It used to be W.U. exclusively, but that's changed in the last ten years.
- davidw 18y ago> I'm outsourcing to South America and I've been using PayPal. Sure, but that's not the group of people I was talking about, who generally go into a physical office, cash in hand, and want to send it somewhere else where someone can go pick up cash. WU isn't a complete monopoly in terms of sending money, obviously, but they still have a big chunk of the market. Actual facts would help the conversation, though:-)
- visakhcr 18y agoWestern Union still has a huge presence in India..especially in southern parts..
- speby 18y agoI'm not sure if they qualified as monopolies per the true definition, but what about TWA and PanAm for international air travel during the regulated airfare days? They each had respective monopolies on huge numbers of routes on separate coasts.
- mattmaroon 18y agoEven if you give them monopoly, it was a shift in government policy (deregulation) that took it away.
- 13ren 18y agoWell, it's a hard question, because they won't easily come to mind - by definition. If you were 100 years old, this question might be easier. - IBM had a monopoly on electronic computers (mainframes) for a long time. And, hey, it also had one on "IBM" PCs for a while there... - Cray supercomputers - there's an excellent example - The original Apple II computer was a monopoly for a while. - DEC minicomputers - SUN microsystem workstations - Silicon Graphics workstations - that guy who patented the "car", and everyone licensed it from him (and who Ford challenged and defeated). Although this was a government created monopoly (a patent), it wasn't lost through government intervention. Or is that just semantics. - Ford mass-produced cars - General Electric (do they even sell light bulbs anymore?) Another difficulty with the question is how you define monopoly: "well if you lost it, it wasn't really a monopoly, was it?"