4 ms·
Can you elaborate on what Germany has done to make its democracy more resilient? I am also concerned about the state of democracy in the US, but it doesn't str
by jfengel 5y ago
Can you elaborate on what Germany has done to make its democracy more resilient?
I am also concerned about the state of democracy in the US, but it doesn't strike me as being similar to what happened to Weimar. Rather, I see it as a very long, slow process of combining some basic inequities in the political system with deliberate stoking of grudges among the people those inequities benefit. It took decades to get where we are.
I don't believe anything can be done about it -- it's too late, and those inequities have now hardened into permanent, overwhelming thumbs on the scale. But I'd be curious to know what lessons have been learned elsewhere.
- atoav 5y agoInstead of trying to explain it myself, I give you a hint where to start reading. In German there is the idea of "wehrhafte Demokratie" which translates to "defensive democracy". The Wikipedia article on that topic might give you some idea: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defensive_democracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defensive_democracy I think the problem in the US is that none of the actors that could implement any needed systemic change has the incentives to do so...
- mannykannot 5y agoI notice that the article you link to says "The United States, for example, is considered a country that uses defensive democratic tactics frequently." There seems to be an unavoidable paradox here, in that anti-democratic measures can be presented as being in accordance with defensive democracy: take the issue of election fraud, for example...
- atoav 5y agoCould you elaborate? Maybe I cannot follow because I am not feom the US..
- mannykannot 5y agoFrom the post I was replying to, and the post of yours that preceded it in this thread, I take it that you consider democracy in the USA and UK to be less resilient than in Germany and Austria, and you attribute this to the latter pairs' defensive democracy. The Wikipedia article you linked to, however, claims that the US uses defensive democratic tactics frequently. I'm not saying this implies the US has a resilient democracy - I'm not sure about the link between defensive democracy and resilience, and I am not sure this claim about the US can be justified in the first place - but if this claim were true, it would appear to contradict what I take to be your thesis, as outlined in my first paragraph here. I my second paragraph, I am making the claim that there is a paradox in how the the defense of democracy can, and quite often has been, used to justify acts that do no such thing. In the US, since the 2020 elections, various states have amended voting laws, allegedly to defend democracy against electoral fraud, even though there is no evidence for any threat justifying these particular defensive measures, despite a great deal of effort being expanded in trying to find any.
- jfengel 5y agoThank you. That's very interesting. I'm put in mind of community organizations, which have the same risks. I've seen several organizations do abrupt turns where one group gains power and then cements it by rule changes. Organizations are different in that you can't just opt out of a country, but it's interesting to see the ways organizations might look to this to protect themselves. I believe one of the most important things Germany has is its assertion that "Human dignity shall be inviolable". The US does not have that. As written it's too vague to apply directly, but it does imply an ethos of protecting people that isn't usually found in the US Constitution. We resist protections, especially when they interfere with somebody's economic freedom or their freedom to persecute others when not expressly forbidden.