3 ms·
I'm not pro-voucher but I think it's a bit unfair to compare case based public funding to flat value voucher funding and declare all voucher funding is a racket
by zamadatix 5y ago
I'm not pro-voucher but I think it's a bit unfair to compare case based public funding to flat value voucher funding and declare all voucher funding is a racket based on that comparison. There is no reason vouchers couldn't also have value based on how much the student costs, in fact some voucher systems work exactly this way.
All that is to say: this is an example of why _flat rate_ vouchers don't make sense.
- TimPC 5y agoI agree this is a case for why what you call flat rate vouchers don't make sense. But what you call flat rate vouchers is also the predominant program of vouchers being advocated for in most policy. When the mainstream discussion moves on to better programs of vouchers I'm happy to discuss the separate merits of those programs. As long as people are advocating for stealing money from vulnerable groups I think that is the most important issue with these programs that needs to be highlighted.
- wbsss4412 5y agoI very often, though, this is how privatization schemes end up working. The private sector takes over the most profitable consumers, leaving the unprofitable, costly customers to the public sector. And realistically, if a voucher policy were implemented, it is unlikely that it will be perfectly designed. Unfortunately public policy is not driven entirely by well designed models.
- UncleMeat 5y agoTFA mentions this but concludes that it is unlikely to nail that policy precisely enough to avoid the problem. Better to just avoid vouchers.