3 ms·
> History is written by the victors. It is not. The loosers keeps writing their opinions and versions of events, you just ignore that. The struggle for interpr
by watwut 5y ago
> History is written by the victors.
It is not. The loosers keeps writing their opinions and versions of events, you just ignore that. The struggle for interpretation of events starts right after war ... and there is no universal law to guide who wins. For example, the popular history of American civil war was dominated by loosers view for years.
In Russia, the history of Stalin ended up dominated by point of view of KGB agent ... who was looser after fall of communism and used it to rise back.
> They are 'recovering' what are called ‘subaltern voices’ (ie women, LGBT+ people, people of colour, people in poverty, etc).
There is no reason to put those into quotes. Pretty often, it is literal recovery - a matter of picking up letters, books, court documents etc out of archives and reading them instead of ignoring.
In other cases, it is reading business documents and doing deductions out of that. That would fall under recovery too.
- usrusr 5y agoAh, that guy... and my impression is that the self-image of KGB itself seemed to be built on the key event of one train from Zurich supposedly deciding an entire half of a world war, that's what they wanted to duplicate/prevent from happening to them again. Completely ignoring February and related events. Another example of selective perception. Speaking of history and how it's told, I wonder how the standing of Eisenstein's Battleship is these days?
- watwut 5y agoNo I dont mean that at all. I mean the point of view that Stalin was effective manager and that purges was unfortunate event that "just kinda happened" without anyone being responsible for anything. I also mean interpretation of Ukraine as "not a real thing" and everything related to it. I also mean what went on with Memoir group in Russia for years already, suppression and persecution. I also mean closing of archives in Russia that happens years ago. Self image of KGB is based on them considering themselves useful and good servants of the country. The ones keeping it together and the ones protecting it. I am not entirely sure what you refer to.