4 ms·
I really want to like Destin (SmarterEveryDay) as his videos are frequently on topics that interest me. That said, ever since he went about happily shilling fo
by sneak 5y ago
I really want to like Destin (SmarterEveryDay) as his videos are frequently on topics that interest me. That said, ever since he went about happily shilling for the armed forces (in exchange for access to fighter pilots for content), I am no longer personally morally willing to contribute to his view counts.
I understand it comes with the territory in the US south (he's also a devout christian, another hallmark of that archetype) but it's just not something I can stomach. Weapons of war are cool tech but we shouldn't be actively promoting ways we can kill other human beings, and we absolutely should not be promoting taking those types of jobs as a reasonable or legitimate choice.
When we promote content, we do so in a wider context: we are also promoting the creator of that content, and their views on society, and our attention and linking is materially enriching them to further those views. Watching his videos and suggesting that others do the same literally puts money in his pocket to advance this worldview.
- jabiko 5y agoI'm not sure how to put that in words, but I feel that we are loosing the ability to accept and interact with people who have a slightly different worldview. I am totally with you in your view on the military. In my country there used to be a mandatory military service or alternatively a longer civilian service; I choose the latter However, I think that just because a person holds a different view on things we should accept that and not disregard other things this person does based on a diverging worldview. This tolerance can of course have boundaries, but these boundaries should be reasonably broad.
- sneak 5y ago> I'm not sure how to put that in words, but I feel that we are loosing the ability to accept and interact with people who have a slightly different worldview. I am totally with you in your view on the military. I can accept him, and will interact with him, but I won't do things that put money in his pocket to further advertise his views. Increasing his view counts, either via my watching, or my linking others to watch, does that. I am morally opposed to doing that. It's nothing to do with "the ability to accept or interact" with him; I just won't fund him. > In my country there used to be a mandatory military service or alternatively a longer civilian service; I choose the latter I'm sorry that your country condoned slavery. These sorts of policies and laws will eventually be condemned universally by history once they fall out of fashion.
- jabiko 5y ago> I'm sorry that your country condoned slavery. Now I am truly at a loss for words
- mathieuh 5y agoIs conscription not forced labour? How do you see it differently? You may think conscription is neutral or even good, but it seems fairly reasonable while maybe a little inflammatory for a general audience to describe it as slavery.
- jabiko 5y agoI can agree that conscription is forced labor. However, there is still a very far way from that to slavery. Using words like "slavery" just for added effect is not good style.
- Tabular-Iceberg 5y ago> I'm sorry that your country condoned slavery. Let’s not throw the baby out with the bath water here. Entirely professional armed forces risk filling up with people who actually want to go to war and shoot people. Conscription is a moderating force. You want a more representative selection. Americans probably wouldn’t vote for so many disastrous foreign interventions if they would have to personally fly over and do it themselves.
- kfrzcode 5y agoYou're virtue signaling. I'm going to go donate $50 a month to both his Patreon and increase my donation to the DAV, entirely to spite you. Carry on!
- avs733 5y agowouldn't...that also be virtue signaling?
- 5y ago
- regnerba 5y agoSo why not watch the content you do want to support? That does directly help inform the content creator which content to create.
- sneak 5y agoI do! I watch stuff made by other people. Veritasium is an example of a similar channel that's better. I also inform others about the situation so they can make their own informed content consumption choices as may align with their own morals. Decisions are always better with more data, even if I don't agree with the ones others may reach.
- namibj 5y agoHe meanwhile contorts reality for clickbait, see the transmission line debacle for a good example. I like his presentation otherwise, but I consider his information harmfully deceptive and thus mildly dangerous to watch.
- alexb_ 5y agoThis video may be worth a watch: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CM0aohBfUTc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CM0aohBfUTc Side note: I don't really agree with a lot of his other videos. Yet I am sharing this one, because I believe it's worthwhile and am not taking his other videos into account for a context that doesn't matter :)
- huffmsa 5y agoYou know he did / does work for the US military, right?
- this15testing 5y agoI remember his religion and morality coming up in more than one occasion in his videos, only to then learn that he worked for a weapons manufacturer. It was really jarring and made so much come off as disingenuous that I just can't watch his content anymore, not that promoting weapons on his channel was good on its own anyway.
- freetime2 5y agoCan you give a specific example of something that he said that you felt was disingenuous? Or even just elaborate further why you feel that is disingenuous? It seems like you are implying that someone who works for the military cannot be religious or have morals. But even if your religious beliefs or morals prevent you from working for the military, surely you must recognize that there many people whose morals and religious beliefs do not conflict with military service. And that’s not being disingenuous, that’s just having a different point of view.
- theideaofcoffee 5y agoI'm not the poster that you replied to, but I feel the same way that this15testing does. I was turned off from all future videos by a specific line in one of this recent videos, specifically #242 "World's Fastest Pitch - Supersonic Baseball Cannon" (see starting approximately one minute into that video) because of just how unexpected him mentioning his work as a "developmental weapons tester" jarred with his supposed piety and his aw-shucks folksiness. Couple that with a grinning photo of him sitting on top of an industrially-produced cannon-type weapon in that same video just made me uneasy. The end of every video on that channel has a bible verse citation so it's especially mind boggling. Isn't the fifth commandment "do not kill"? I believe if you're a religious person working in weapons development and choose to compartmentalize your beliefs for a paycheck then you are either naive or malicious, I don't know which is worse.
- freetime2 5y agoThe commandment is more accurately translated as “though shalt not murder”, or commit unjustified killing. The bible provides many examples where killing is justified, such as punishment for a crime, defending ones’ self or property, and - especially relevant here - warfare. [1] So no compartmentalization of beliefs is necessary to work in defense. I see this a lot where people try to use christians’ beliefs against them to try pigeonhole them into thinking and acting a certain way, or call them hypocrites for not acting the way they believe christians should act. But religion is open to many different interpretations - just look at the number sects within every religion - and we shouldn’t really assume anything about a person’s beliefs just because they are “religious”. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thou_shalt_not_kill https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thou_shalt_not_kill
- freetime2 5y agoI think calling him a shill is a bit out of line. Shill implies dishonesty, but he’s pretty transparent about the fact that he used to work for the military, and that the reason he is getting access to nuclear submarines etc is that the military views it as good PR. I think it’s also fairly safe to assume that the military gets a say in what ends up in the final video, but that shouldn’t be a surprise to anyone - not least because a lot of what happens on a nuclear submarine is highly classified. My sense is that he genuinely believes that the military performs a necessary role, and has a lot of interesting components, and is just trying to show that to the world. And we shouldn’t be so quick to label someone a shill just because we disagree with them.
- sneak 5y agoShill may imply dishonesty, but it is not by definition someone who is dishonest, simply a promoter. It means coordinated conspiracy; it may or may not include dishonesty. Transparently advocating for people to join up with the military is no improvement. My issue is more fundamental than whether or not it is disclosed as an ad. My issue is with all of those who would promote violence as a solution to problems, regardless of how such promotion is carried out.
- alexb_ 5y ago>My issue is with all of those who would promote violence as a solution to problems You are completely delusional. Nobody wants war, but the truth of the matter is might makes right. We must be good at making war not because we want fighting, but because we want to be so good at it that other countries cannot just take over. You can choose to abstain from war, but you will quickly lose to those who do not. And those who do not may have systems and politics that make life much, much worse for those in the country.
- donatj 5y ago> It means coordinated conspiracy Conspiracy by definition means secrecy. As the previous poster said, he’s been more than open that he worked on rockets for the military and his relationship with it. I don’t think there’s any secrecy here. > My issue is with all of those who would promote violence as a solution to problems I strongly promote non-violence, but there is always value in speaking softly and carrying a big stick. You need to be able to defend yourself or someone less keen on non-violence will obliterate you.
- martyvis 5y agoI don't particularly like war, and ultimately it is almost always the result of greed and evil intent. Most of us are appalled at the Russian war of aggression on Ukraine. While we all wish it would just stop with fine talk and reason at this point only the bravery of the Ukrainian people and the use of defensive weapons is going to limit Russia's advances until they see no further benefit from what they are doing.
- freeflight 5y agoNo single conflict in human history was made less bloody by pouring more weapons into it.
- eliaspro 5y agoI think Karl Popper's "Paradox of tolerance" [1] applies here as well. An open, democratic and pacifist society can only continue to exist if it defeats those who try to end it. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance
- alexb_ 5y agoSo what exactly should we be doing? Not developing any technology at all with the military? Making the military look as unappealing and awful as possible so that we completely lose any and all advantage we have over other countries in military might? War is awful. It's horrific and has killed millions and traumatized or impacted millions and millions more. But someone has to be good at it. Because if we as a nation decide to not be the best at it, someone else will. And I would much rather have the United States and it's moral systems be running things than our enemies. >I understand it comes with the territory in the US south Please, please, please stop talking about the south as a monolith. Or as if you are somehow so above the dumb hicks in the south, who are not enlightened with your amazing views such as "why don't we just stop killing eachother?". >When we promote content, we do so in a wider context: we are also promoting the creator of that content, and their views on society, and our attention and linking is materially enriching them to further those views This is such a horrible and terrible way to think about things on the internet. This type of thinking is how you get extremists and complete and utter polarization. Because when you not just unconsciously surround yourself with media that only you agree with, but WILLFULLY do it, you hurt yourself and make extremism even more likely. And that's only for things that are relevant - you are going a step further, and taking this to a level that makes no sense. If you were in charge of hiring people, would you never hire anyone who was pro-military? You putting money in their pocket is enriching them to help further their views which are oh-so-terrible. This type of thinking gets really bad, really fast, and it's not something we want to promote. It's exclusionary thinking that can only result in missing out on very talented people because of something that isn't actually relevant.
- sneak 5y ago"A permanent peace cannot be prepared by threats but only by the honest attempt to create a mutual trust. However strong national armaments may be, they do not create military security for any nation nor do they guarantee the maintenance of peace." "I believe serious progress (in the abolition of war) can be achieved only when men become organized on an international scale and refuse, as a body, to enter military or war service." - Albert Einstein (both quotes)
- 5y ago
- freeflight 5y agoI got that very same vibe/problem when watching his series on US nuclear subs. As cool and as interesting as that was, it was kinda off-putting to realize how a big part of it was very much PR for the US military.
- throw0101a 5y ago> Weapons of war are cool tech but we shouldn't be actively promoting ways we can kill other human beings, and we absolutely should not be promoting taking those types of jobs as a reasonable or legitimate choice. Si vis pacem, para bellum. * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Si_vis_pacem,_para_bellum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Si_vis_pacem,_para_bellum What is not legitimate about wanting to defend your country and defend the principles and values that it lives by? Especially in the context of current world events.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ethagknight 5y ago>> I understand it comes with the territory in the US south (he's also a devout christian, another hallmark of that archetype) This turned into a weird ad hominem attack.