14 ms·
Poppers whole theory on open and closed societies was that open societies have some sort of mechanism to change who is in power without a violent revolution or
by atoav 5y ago
Poppers whole theory on open and closed societies was that open societies have some sort of mechanism to change who is in power without a violent revolution or a war.
I am not sure I know what Plato envisioned as a society, but his strict division between intellectual and working class seems like a receipe to disaster. Two or three generations in nothing would have been left of the potential advantages of putting the intellectuals in power, because their sons would've taken that power for granted and soon you would've ended up with an ordinary aristocracy.
Granted, those were other times — slavery was totally common for example. But I still think Popper has the better take on how to organize power and who knows, maybe Plato would have agreed if he had the chance to read Popper.
- krazii 5y agoFrom memory Plato's ideal society was pretty wack. A "great lie" to wow citizens into respecting the ruling class. Taking children from their parents, forbiding knowledge of your biological family to avoid nepotism. Banning music and theatre so people don't get too excited about alternatives.
- willcipriano 5y agoContrast Plato with his allegory of the cave vs Aristotle, inventor of common sense. Its clear why dictators throughout history favored Plato, as well as modern academia.
- shadowofneptune 5y agoThe part of it that raised my eyebrows the most back in school was the idea that formal education should only start at age 18, and students graduating at age 50.
- bobthechef 5y agoThat’s not quite what Plato held. What you call the intellectual class (the philosopher-kings) would actually be forbidden from procreating. Here’s a description in the context of an analysis of our social predicament[0]. (Whether you agree with the analysis or not, the summary of Plato’s views still stands.) [0] https://americanmind.org/salvo/woke-ideology-is-a-psychological-disorder/ https://americanmind.org/salvo/woke-ideology-is-a-psychologi...