6 ms·
That's an argument from an era when people seriously discussed how to make this civilization thing work.
by Animats 5y ago
That's an argument from an era when people seriously discussed how to make this civilization thing work.
- atoav 5y agoWhat I like about Popper is the ingenious inversion of principles: He realized that democracy is not about being able to get those you like into power — democracy is about being able to remove those you don't like from power. Take away the ability of the public to rid yourself of certain politicians by voting them out, and you take away democracy, even if you maintain the illusion of choice.
- verisimi 5y agoShame he didn't go all the way and realise it was about giving the illusion of choice, via the use of a false dialectic.
- atoav 5y agoWhat do you know about Popper and the environment he had been in when he wrote this idea? Let's not forget: Popper wrote this in 1945 directly after the Nazis lost the war – he, like many post-war German thinkers spent a lot of energy on pondering how a new democracy must be designed in order to never allow this quick takeover of democracy never again. I am currently living in Germany and I grew up in Austria where Popper lived. There is a lot to argue about in these nations, but we have actual choice in our votes (compared to democracies whose models pre-date Popper's thoughts, like UK or the US). I am not very worried about the stability of modern democracies that looked at what happened in the Weimar republic, understood that such a thing could also happen to their democracies and reformed their systems in order to become resilient against such threats. The US (and the UK for that matter) are not such resilient democracies, and this worries me, just like it would have worried Popper.
- jfengel 5y agoCan you elaborate on what Germany has done to make its democracy more resilient? I am also concerned about the state of democracy in the US, but it doesn't strike me as being similar to what happened to Weimar. Rather, I see it as a very long, slow process of combining some basic inequities in the political system with deliberate stoking of grudges among the people those inequities benefit. It took decades to get where we are. I don't believe anything can be done about it -- it's too late, and those inequities have now hardened into permanent, overwhelming thumbs on the scale. But I'd be curious to know what lessons have been learned elsewhere.
- atoav 5y agoInstead of trying to explain it myself, I give you a hint where to start reading. In German there is the idea of "wehrhafte Demokratie" which translates to "defensive democracy". The Wikipedia article on that topic might give you some idea: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defensive_democracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defensive_democracy I think the problem in the US is that none of the actors that could implement any needed systemic change has the incentives to do so...
- mannykannot 5y agoI notice that the article you link to says "The United States, for example, is considered a country that uses defensive democratic tactics frequently." There seems to be an unavoidable paradox here, in that anti-democratic measures can be presented as being in accordance with defensive democracy: take the issue of election fraud, for example...
- atoav 5y agoCould you elaborate? Maybe I cannot follow because I am not feom the US..
- mannykannot 5y ago
- Animats 5y ago(Popper) realized that democracy is not about being able to get those you like into power — democracy is about being able to remove those you don't like from power. That's an old observation. It goes back to George Washington at the end of his term as President, shaking hands with his successor and walking away. That surprised many Europeans.