4 ms·
The problem is our politics - clearly our health care system needs fixing. But nobody chooses to act on politics, and the obvious obstructions to progress. > I
by wolverine876 5y ago
The problem is our politics - clearly our health care system needs fixing. But nobody chooses to act on politics, and the obvious obstructions to progress.
> I'm reminded of a patient encounter. A man was in my office talking about conflicts at work re: a micromanaging supervisor. It was a group of PhD-level software engineers. I was thinking, do these people even need "supervision"? Shouldn't they be trusted? Trustworthy professionals can be relied on to do their jobs. Sure, keep an eye on work quality, allow the track records to speak for themselves.
Generally, yes, good management is knowing who to trust, and putting them in a position to succeed. But the original bias, of course, is toward ourselves. They/we are still human, we still put our pants on one leg at a time. Just because we are highly skilled in something, doesn't mean we have good judgment in other ways, we are motivated, not distracted, biased in other ways, etc. Plenty of very successful people do god-awful stupid things.
- jrapdx3 5y agoNo question about it, no one is immune, "to err is human". Also true that assessing performance of tasks requiring complex judgement is itself error prone. Credentials alone are an insufficient baseline. So for all kinds of roles auditing mechanisms are necessary to monitor performance. And truly responsible professionals don't object to quality assurance measures, in fact they want to know if their performance declines in some respect. In my observation it's problematic when rules become intrusive, overly restrictive, or needlessly punitive. At that point monitoring no longer serves its nominal purpose. There's a proper balance that's minimally adversarial, making it work requires mutual respect and constrained interaction between professionals and reviewers. I think that's the source of a significant share of the problems in our health care systems. Way too much energy is wasted on battling phantoms. Not sure how the trends can be reversed. Best advice to patients is to make sure to strongly advocate for themselves. I know both sides as doctor and patient, I know how big a challenge it can be getting what we need despite layers of roadblocks and potholes on the path.